Reliable Brokers
Online Investing
Alerts & Analysis
Easy Trading

Resignations and the constitutional crisis

Update : 13 Nov 2013, 06:12 PM

A very serious constitutional crisis is prevailing in the governance of our country, which is unprecedented in the history of parliamentary governance of our state. As per the request of Prime Minister Sheikh Hasina, all her cabinet members submitted blank-dated resignation letters to her on November 11 to be handed to the president.

Some members reportedly submitted resignation letters earlier. This en masse resignation was with an end to fulfill the public commitment of the prime minister for forming her well-publicised all-party interim government for the upcoming 10th parliamentary election.

This resignation has, on the one hand, put the country in a serious constitutional crisis, and on the other hand, pushed the whole prevailing political crisis into a deeper state.

The cabinet secretary in a press briefing on November 11, said all cabinet members submitted their resignations for the reshuffling of the cabinet, though the resignation of all members was not at all necessary. The provision of Article 58 (2) of the Constitution could be used.

But some prominent members of the cabinet, like Suranjit Sengupta, Obaidul Kader and others, who are considered to be well conversant about our constitution, publicly announced their decision to submit their resignations in a body, to enable the prime minister to form an all-party government.

Unfortunately, they misread the constitution and created this embarrassing situation. Upon a plain reading of Article 58 (1) (a) of the Constitution, which reads as follows: “58. (1) The office of a Minister other than the Prime Minister shall become vacant – (a) if he resigns from office by placing his resignation in the hands of the Prime Minister for submission to the President,” we find that the offices of all the cabinet members have fallen vacant right at the time when they handed over their resignations in the hands of the prime minister for submission to the president.

There is no scope for dilly-dallying. The holding of office by the ministers, after handing over their resignations, is not permitted by the constitution, and all functions discharged by them after resignation are unconstitutional.

Law Minister Shafique Ahmed said they have not properly submitted their resignations as per the provisions of the Constitution and hence they are working, because the prime minister has not yet submitted the resignations to the president.

As per the law minister’s claims, the resigning ministers have further scope for intimating their decisions to the president. If we take the version of the law minister to be true, who could be held responsible for mistaken letters of resignation without proper adherence to the provisions of the Constitution?

This argument, placed by the law minister for the continuation of the resigning cabinet members as being constitutionally permissible, does not hold water.

Astonishingly, Information Minister Hasanul Haq Inu has differed with the law minister saying that they have submitted the resignations as per the law and if there be any question raised, the same can be resolved before the proper court.

A free, fair, and participatory election for forming the tenth Jatiyo Sangshad has become a far cry. The resignation issue needs to be resolved in a manner that does not just quench the thirst of the ruling party, but addresses the real catastrophic situation for the general election.  

Top Brokers