It's easy enough -- and I do it often enough -- to point to something a government is doing wrong and then snarl about that thing the government is doing wrong. It is more difficult to find something a government is doing right and then congratulate that government.
It's possible to go on and say that this is because governments do so many things wrong and so few right -- but that would be cynical. I am indeed cynical, but at least part of this is that it's so much more fun to criticize than it is to praise.
Yet here we are, the Bangladeshi government is getting a good part of cleaning up the banking system right.
We all wish we weren't here in the first place of course. We'd all prefer that there weren't years and years where well connected people were able to pillage the banking system. Yet there were, and we've now got to deal with what did indeed happen.
What happened is that people borrowed money they had little ability to repay -- or little intention to repay. That causes a significant problem for the rest of us because stealing from banks is not victimless.
Too many loans not repaid means the bank will -- eventually -- run out of capital and fail.
If the banks fall over, then a basic requirement for a useful economy stops happening -- our savings stop being recycled into the investments that make the future richer. We do not want this to happen.
One part of this is to identify and isolate those banks that have lost some or all of their capital. This is being done: “15 banks, including five merged Shariah-based banks, were behind more than 85% of the over Tk600,000 crore in non-performing loans (NPLs).”
Some of the NPLs are just loans that didn't work. That always does happen and a system that had none at all would be a system that wasn't lending enough money -- thereby failing to make the future richer. But a large portion of these were loans that should never have been made -- to those who could not, or would not, repay them. People who were insiders at the banks and were able to short-circuit the normal lending standards.
So, now we know which banks have these problems. We can then use special measures to manage these banks. Insist that they raise more capital. Merge some of them. Keep a special eye on who they lend to. If necessary -- and we don't like doing this but sometimes we must -- put more tax money into the banks so they have capital again.
We also want to punish those who borrowed and did not repay. This is also being done: “A court in Chittagong on Thursday sentenced former land minister Saifuzzaman Chowdhury Javed to 15 years in prison for embezzling Tk25 crore in loans from United Commercial Bank Limited (UCBL) and laundering the money abroad.”
This is also good and the right thing to do. Thieves should go to jail and thieves who threaten the entire economic system with their thefts should spend more time in jail than those who steal lesser things.
We're never going to catch everyone who stole from the banks. But that's not actually the point. While it would be nice to punish them it's still not the point. It would be just to jail them all, but even that's not the point.
What we must do is make sure that no one steals from the banking system in the same way again. Because, as above, having a banking system is what makes the joint future richer. So we need to protect the banking system itself, not just some of the money in some of the banks.
Fifteen years -- plus a fine -- is a hefty sentence. The next man who decides he'd like to defraud a bank will think quite a lot about whether he's willing to risk it. Sure, it's great to fine as well and that might put some of the money stolen back into the bank.
The correct reaction to a banking system that has been pillaged is for the central bank -- and so the taxpayers -- to recapitalize the banks so that there is still a functional banking system.
This is needed to make the future richer. Then we need to visit those who stole all the money with prosecutions and long jail sentences so that no one tries this again.
The Bangladesh Bank, the government, is starting to do this. Good. We can be cynical and think that most governments don't do many good things. But that just makes praising the few done even more important. So, well done.
Tim Worstall is a senior fellow at the Adam Smith Institute in London.



