Reliable Brokers
Online Investing
Alerts & Analysis
Easy Trading

What are they thinking in Delhi?

Update : 27 Oct 2013, 07:25 PM

Could the raw nature of a power-play disrupt representative democracy?

Seven years ago, we all saw the film “Dumb and Dumber: How to Dump Democracy.” Bangla-style. Is the sequel on the cards?

I cannot believe I am even writing this. Again. Incredibly, the two political families are returning us to the same build-up and mock theatre. The same stand-offs. The same, take-it-to-the-wire, five minutes to midnight, poker game that sends shudders of fear among the poor and small traders while the middle class feel disgust.

Higher up the food chain, especially from the rag trade, and he is likely to “damn the lot of them” and demand that we ditch democracy.

These are uncertain times and the finger of blame must be pointed at the two dynasties. Did they learn anything in that “interim period?” Did they not learn how to communicate with each other, to keep things within control?

It is not only garment buyers and suppliers who need a code of conduct. The royal families need to sign a “political code of conduct” on how they should respect the norms of democracy and the citizens they claim to serve.

That their exalted status has to be earned, not inherited. Most of all, they need to stand up for Bangladesh in the true spirit of 1971. That, alas, has hardly ever been the case and helps explain why foreign embassies and agencies hold such a sway over domestic politics.

With all due respect to many self-styled “development partners,” the decisive hand can only be dealt by Delhi, for virtue of its proximity, size and also its fateful decision to “contain China,” to please the global Robocop.

The latter is likely to allow the sub-continental Robocop to decide. The families, and pretenders beyond the Big Two, are queuing up to present their credentials to the giant neighbour. They might well be in for a surprise.

So, is it to be the AL or the BNP?

Except for a case-by-case defensive posture by Dhaka’s regimes, it is never clear how Bangladesh’s elite really wants to negotiate, if at all. Only long marches led by left-wingers seem to retain some semblance of our national sovereignty whenever the elite tries to do a fire-sale.

Delhi, not surprisingly, has drawn its red lines not to be crossed: No arms shipments to Assam and Nagaland, no abuse of Hindu minorities, no significant inroads by China.

The foreign policy stalwarts in the BNP might think they have satisfied Indian “concerns” with some soothing words on these issues. They might even be genuine now that their right hand in the form of Jamaat is electorally crushed.

Of course, the BNP sommeliers might just be changing the labels and still only serve them plonk.

As for the utterly complacent Awami League high command, living it up in la-la land, it might not be able to satisfy India. The Yunus affair hasn’t helped. The inability to push through enough big-ticket projects to benefit Indian behemoths also rankles.

It seems the Awami League prefers controversial projects such as the environmentally-criminal despoliation of mangrove forests for coal, providing more ammunition to maintain the charge of Indian exploitation.

Given that they are likely to receive the traditional anti-incumbency electoral hiding, in any case, they may be doomed.

Even if they could contrive an unlikely return to power, the impact of the war trials will come to the fore.

The trouble with religion

In political terms, the decapitation of the Jamaat may only result in stronger Islamist forces emerging with a compelling narrative for the residents of forgotten small towns, villages and, critically, slums in the big metropolises. Add the threat of revenge, civil unrest and violence, and you sense a gnawing worry in the heads of Delhi diplomats: Can the Awami League provide the stability needed for Indian commerce, cross-border movement and resource extraction?

More simply, can a second Awami League administration control the streets in the face of an opposition counter-offensive?

If the answer is no, then there follows an examination of whether the BNP is believable or not. Its strongest card is its claim that it can limit the damage by its Islamic allies. In other words, by bringing them inside the tent.

With the likely election of the hard-line BJP’s Narendra Modi in April 2014, the temptation for his crowd to sabre rattle on its Eastern Front might be too tempting to resist, when things go pear shape for a sputtering Indian economic machine.

Imagine the possibilities with the BJP in Delhi and the BNP in Dhaka, both using nationalism and religion to bolster support. Only leaders, on both sides, exhibiting the highest levels of maturity will be able to avoid clashes. Their track record does not inspire confidence.

Delhi might conclude that while the BNP may well be sincere in initially turning a blind eye to mischief in India’s North East, it could eventually be persuaded to allow Pakistan’s military spies to play. On top of this, it might be emboldened by China to this time seriously look East and deny India space and advantage in economic and infrastructural terms.

The bottom-line is that, in Delhi’s eyes, Bangladesh is a pass-through state on the way to Mandalay. That is one big difference, seven years on.

So, if not a weakened unpopular Awami League nor a difficult-to-gauge BNP, who else does a Delhi diplomat turn to?

Answers on a postcard, please.

An aspiring local superpower in a hurry will pick any “junior partner” who can keep the lid on and play the game, the professional way.

The correct answer to the question in the headline (what are they thinking in Delhi) should be: “Who cares! We only care what 160 million Bangladeshis think.”

One day, we will get there, won’t we?

Top Brokers