Reliable Brokers
Online Investing
Alerts & Analysis
Easy Trading

A relationship under strain

Neighbourly relations are sustained not by declarations of friendship but by restraint, sensitivity, and an awareness of asymmetry

Update : 22 Dec 2025, 11:42 AM

In South Asia, history is never merely about the past. It is constantly repurposed, selectively recalled and, at times, conspicuously edited to serve the needs of the present.

This is why the way history is remembered, and more importantly, the way it is narrated by those in power, often becomes a political act in itself.

Recent developments in India-Bangladesh relations suggest that memory, language, and political signalling are once again colliding in ways that have unsettled Dhaka and raised uncomfortable questions about respect, sovereignty, and intent.

This unease began, symbolically at least, on December 16. For Bangladesh, Victory Day is the defining moment of national birth, the culmination of a brutal nine month war that claimed millions of lives and left deep scars across society.

It was the day the Pakistani army surrendered in Dhaka, acknowledging the irreversibility of Bangladesh’s independence. India’s military intervention in the final phase of that war was decisive and historically acknowledged in Bangladesh.

Yet the moral and political centre of the war remained Bangladesh’s struggle for self determination.

This year, however, that balance felt disrupted. In marking Vijay Diwas, Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi paid tribute to Indian soldiers and described December 16 as a moment of India’s historic victory in 1971.

Bangladesh did not appear in the message at all.

There was no reference to the Mukti Bahini, no mention of a new nation emerging from genocide and occupation, no acknowledgment that the war’s primary outcome was not India’s triumph but Bangladesh’s liberation.

The omission was all the more striking because the Indian Army’s own statement on the same occasion adopted a markedly different tone. It explicitly referred to the joint struggle with Bangladeshi freedom fighters and clearly stated that the war led to the birth of Bangladesh.

For many observers in Dhaka, this contrast sharpened the sense that something had shifted at the political level.

What might once have been dismissed as a communication oversight was instead read as a subtle recalibration of narrative, one that appeared to place India at the centre while pushing Bangladesh to the margins of its own history.

Diplomacy is built as much on symbolism as on substance. When a neighbour with whom history is deeply intertwined appears to retell that history in a way that diminishes the other’s agency, it inevitably creates friction.

That friction has since spilled into a much more contentious domain, Bangladesh’s internal political process.

India’s recent public statements urging Bangladesh to hold free, fair, inclusive, and credible elections have triggered an unusually firm response from the interim government in Dhaka.

Foreign affairs adviser Towhid Hossain’s assertion that Bangladesh does not require advice from its neighbours on how to conduct elections reflects more than irritation. It signals accumulated frustration rooted in lived political experience.

Over the last decade and a half, Bangladesh’s electoral credibility has been repeatedly questioned, both domestically and internationally. Elections in 2014, 2018, and 2024 were all marred by allegations of exclusion, manipulation, and coercion.

Throughout these cycles, India was widely seen as a consistent supporter of the government led by Sheikh Hasina. Indian officials engaged actively with political actors during moments of crisis, endorsed election outcomes that others criticized, and maintained close ties even as democratic standards eroded.

This history matters. When a state that was perceived as legitimizing deeply flawed elections now speaks the language of inclusivity, it is difficult for Bangladeshis to hear the message without recalling the past.

The problem is not the principle of fair elections, which commands broad consensus within Bangladesh. The problem is credibility. Advice does not exist in a vacuum. It carries the weight of prior conduct.

This is why similar statements from Western capitals often generate less public anger. Their past positions, however imperfect, are not associated with sustaining a single party’s grip on power in Bangladesh.

India’s case is different precisely because of its proximity, its influence, and its long record of engagement in Bangladesh’s political landscape.

That sensitivity has been further inflamed by the unresolved issue of Sheikh Hasina’s stay in India.

After being forced to leave office amid mass protests last August, the former prime minister sought refuge across the border. Since then, Bangladesh has repeatedly requested her return to face trial, including for alleged crimes against humanity.

These requests have gone unanswered. Meanwhile, several leaders and activists associated with the now banned Awami League are believed to be operating from Indian territory.

Against this backdrop, Sheikh Hasina’s continued political statements from India have become a flashpoint. For many in Bangladesh, this is not simply about partisan rivalry. It is about the optics of power.

A former ruler commenting on domestic politics while sheltered by a neighbouring state inevitably raises suspicions of patronage, whether or not such patronage exists in reality.

Professor Muhammad Yunus’s call for restraint, describing such interventions as an unfriendly gesture, reflected a widely shared concern that political discourse emanating from foreign soil undermines both stability and legitimacy at a critical juncture.

The anxiety is compounded by fears that these developments are part of a broader attempt to shape the political field ahead of the next election.

Analysts have noted that India’s repeated emphasis on participatory elections is increasingly interpreted as an effort to reintegrate the Awami League into the political process.

From New Delhi’s perspective, this may align with strategic interests rooted in long standing security cooperation and political familiarity.

From Dhaka’s perspective, it appears as selective engagement that prioritizes a particular actor rather than democratic norms.

This divergence of perception is at the heart of the current tension. India insists it does not interfere. Bangladesh increasingly feels that it does, or at least that it has in the past.

In such circumstances, even well-intentioned statements are filtered through suspicion. The result is a diplomatic environment where trust is scarce and every word is scrutinised for hidden meaning.

The stakes could not be higher. Bangladesh is attempting to navigate a fragile transition after years of polarized politics. Public faith in elections has been deeply damaged. Rebuilding that trust requires not only institutional reform but also a clear sense that political outcomes are determined domestically, without external pressure or perceived guardianship.

Perceptions of foreign influence have long shaped political narratives in Bangladesh. They have been used to mobilize supporters, delegitimize opponents, and explain away democratic failures.

If those perceptions intensify now, they risk undermining the very electoral process that all sides claim to support.

The broader regional context adds another layer of complexity. Bangladesh is recalibrating its foreign policy, balancing relations with India, China, and Western partners while asserting a more autonomous voice.

India, facing its own strategic challenges, understandably seeks stability on its eastern flank. But stability secured through political leverage is inherently unstable. It breeds resentment and fuels nationalist backlash.

At its core, the present moment is a test of mutual respect. Respect for history that recognizes Bangladesh as the principal subject of its own liberation.

Respect for sovereignty that allows Bangladesh to conduct elections without unsolicited commentary.

Respect for political boundaries that discourages the use of foreign territory as a platform for domestic mobilization.

Neighbourly relations are sustained not by declarations of friendship but by restraint, sensitivity, and an awareness of asymmetry. When one country is significantly larger and more powerful, the burden of care in communication falls heavier on its shoulders.

Bangladesh’s strong reaction, therefore, should not be dismissed as overreaction.

It is a response shaped by memory, by past experience, and by the urgency of the present political moment. If India wishes to preserve goodwill and influence in Bangladesh, it must recognize that influence rooted in trust is far more durable than influence asserted through words.

As Bangladesh moves toward another critical election, the lesson from history is clear. Liberation was about agency. Democracy is about agency too.

Any narrative or intervention that appears to compromise that agency, however subtly, will meet resistance.

And in a region where history still speaks loudly, silence and omission can be as consequential as overt interference.

HM Nazmul Alam is an Academic, Journalist, and Political Analyst based in Dhaka, Bangladesh. Currently he teaches at IUBAT. Email: [email protected].

Top Brokers