Foreign Direct Investment (FDI) is really, hugely, crucially important. Therefore a 13% decline in FDI into Bangladesh in 2024 is a disaster. On the other hand FDI flows don't matter all that much therefore, well, why worry?
It's possible to see a certain tension between those two statements, but I assure you that both are true. What makes each of them true at the same time is our ability to play a little with the definition being used.
The specific report is that “(FDI) in Bangladesh declined by 13.20% to $1.27 billion in 2024 from $1.47 billion in 2023, resulting in a decline for the fourth consecutive year since 2021.” It's true that we do not want that to be happening. As to why it was happening there's the obvious -- and true -- explanation. Last year was somewhat fraught, to put it mildly. Foreigners do not like investing in fraught places. It might be true that locals understand what's going on, who will win, how they will and so on, but this all becomes something of a blur to those from outside -- for cultural, linguistic, and simple knowledge reasons. Therefore the difficulties of last year were bound to reduce foreign investment.
But there's another issue here too. Sure, the past regime suggested that it would, could provide stability and that would produce growth and investment. But as we're finding out that stability was, at times, encouraged -- are we ready to use the word “bought” yet? By the handing out of economic favours for political support. Things like import licences, loans from state banks, permits to perform specific actions. One of the things that foreigners -- and thus foreign investors -- hate is this sort of economic policy. For, of course, foreigners cannot offer any political support and so cannot gain any of those favours.
This isn't because foreigners are more moral, that's not true of any group of capitalists. It's that foreigners don't gain access to the goodies being strewn around for political support. It's not even jealousy -- it's that if locals are gaining government favours and we're not then why would we invest there given how much more difficult it will be to profit if they've favours and we have not?
But is FDI important? In one sense, yes. Bangladesh has less capital than can be usefully employed in Bangladesh. So, more capital imported and put to use will make the country richer -- this is a good thing. But this is where FDI flows don't really matter all that much -- there are other ways of gaining investment. A new factory simply doesn't have to be owned and paid for by foreigners. We can most certainly have a local building the new factory and borrowing to do so -- which is not FDI. So, this number that is “FDI” isn't the whole and the importance of the thing.
On the other hand foreigners know how to build a business, design a factory, better than we do. Obviously this is true, that's why they have the ability to do this and we don't. This is the form of FDI which is vital. By that foreign knowledge coming in then we get to leapfrog that whole process of having to learn it all over again for ourselves.
Enticing foreigners to send us their money (the usual definition of FDI) is one of those things. There are other ways of gaining access to money other than allowing a foreigner to build a factory after all. But all of that knowledge (both implicit and explicit) that people wanting to invest have, that's between hugely valuable and vital.
And, as we've learned from recent years, they will not arrive with either if the government is handing out economic favours for political support. Foreigners don't have the vote, are not part of the political system, so they will never gain those favours. Thus, political favouritism always, but always, means foreigners are -- economically, in business -- discriminated against. So, they won't come.
Tim Worstall is a senior fellow at the Adam Smith Institute in London.



