Reliable Brokers
Online Investing
Alerts & Analysis
Easy Trading

Pacta sunt servanda

How water treaty disputes shape South Asian relations

Update : 30 May 2025, 10:57 AM

On April 23, 2025, India announced that it would hold the Indus Waters Treaty (IWT) in abeyance. The World Bank-brokered treaty, signed in 1960, established a water-sharing mechanism between Pakistan and India over the river Indus and its five tributaries.

The treaty, signed between then Indian Prime Minister Jawaharlal Nehru and Pakistani President Ayub Khan in Karachi on September 19, 1960, functioned successfully for over six decades, enduring heightened tensions and wars between the two countries. However, following what was perceived to be a militant attack on tourists in Indian-administered Kashmir, India unilaterally suspended the treaty, citing national security concerns and alleging Pakistan’s support for state-sponsored terrorism.

As an agrarian economy, millions of Pakistanis depend on the Indus River System. Originating in Tibet, the Indus flows down to the alluvial plains -- where, for over a millennium, it nurtured one of the world’s earliest and finest civilizations, the Indus Valley Civilization, dating back around 5,000 years.

There is an overarching expectation and binding principle in all internationally recognized water conventions that if co-riparian countries sign a treaty on the sharing of waters from transboundary rivers, no party may unilaterally suspend it. Unilateral suspension is considered a breach of established norms of inter-state relations, which are based on the foundational principle of international law -- pacta sunt servanda (agreements must be kept).

There are serious implications when one country unilaterally withdraws from its obligation to provide another country its due share of water from common rivers. In our region, where many countries are seemingly disadvantaged as lower riparian states, they must rely on the ‘good senses’ of upper riparian countries for their just rights to shared river waters.

For many years, nations in South and Southeast Asia drew inspiration from the success of the Indus and Mekong river water-sharing arrangements. Many even emulated favorable clauses from these two agreements in their own bilateral treaties -- Bangladesh and India’s Ganges Water Sharing Treaty being one example.

In about a year, the 30-year Ganges River Water Treaty will lapse unless both parties -- Bangladesh and India -- begin discussing its review and renewal now. Though Bangladesh and India share 54 transboundary rivers, this treaty remains the only one worth celebrating so far.

A few decades ago, there was an interim water-sharing arrangement between the two South Asian neighbours concerning the Teesta river. However, since those arrangements lapsed, Bangladesh and India have failed to reach a tangible treaty on sharing Teesta’s waters -- waters that are crucial for northern Bangladesh, its agriculture, and the livelihoods of a vast population.

The 414-km-long Teesta river has most of its catchment area in India. Yet when it comes to the concentration of population along the Teesta basin, the overwhelming majority resides on the Bangladesh side, and their livelihoods fully depend on the river. 

The Teesta basin is home to around 30 million people -- only 2% in Sikkim, 27% in West Bengal, and 71% in northwest Bangladesh. Sikkim is mountainous with low population density; West Bengal has a mix of low hills and plains, while Bangladesh’s terrain is mostly flat. Unfortunately, a large volume of water is diverted at Gajoldoba in West Bengal before the river enters Bangladesh.

It has been fourteen years since India showed readiness to sign a Teesta deal in 2011, but it backtracked at the last moment, citing the insistence of one of its states (namely West Bengal), which refused to provide Bangladesh with water without first ensuring its own share.

As a result, vast swaths of fertile northwest Bangladesh remain largely uncultivated and less productive due to lack of water and irrigation. In the absence of a water-sharing treaty, Bangladesh has had to abandon the second phase of its Teesta Barrage project.

There is an overarching expectation and binding principle in all internationally recognized water conventions

At a press briefing last month, the Chief Adviser’s High Representative Khalilur Raman rightly noted that the life and livelihood of about 14% of Bangladesh’s total population, living in the Teesta river basin, depend on the availability of Teesta water. "We cannot put about 14 percent of the people in such a dire situation, and that's why we continue talks with all. We are asking India to sign the deal (the Teesta water-sharing treaty)," Khalilur said.

A priority task at hand must be to walk the water talk -- to advance discussions and review and renew the Ganges Water Sharing Treaty before it expires next year. It is crucial for Bangladesh to continue engaging with India so that the Ganges treaty remains intact and both co-riparian countries can expedite negotiations on other transboundary rivers.

While it is now history, it is important to remember how pre-1971 Indo-Pak relations were strained by India’s construction of the Farakka Barrage across the Ganges river in Murshidabad district, West Bengal, near the border with then East Pakistan. The barrage, intended to divert water from the Ganges into the Hooghly river to maintain the navigability of Kolkata Port, became operational in April 1975, a few years after the emergence of Bangladesh in 1971.

The Ganges -- known as the Padma in Bangladesh -- enters the country near Shibganj Upazila in Chapainawabganj district. It runs 230 km southeast, meeting the Brahmaputra at Goalanda and eventually joining the Meghna near Chandpur before emptying into the Bay of Bengal.

It is vital for Bangladesh now to prioritize data analysis and assess the last 29 years of real-time dry season flow from the Ganges -- whether it has received its agreed-upon share, whether guarantee clauses are being upheld, and whether the Bangladesh-India Joint Rivers Commission (JRC) mechanism is being reactivated for necessary renegotiation and renewal of the Ganges treaty in due course. This treaty remains our only bilateral river water-sharing instrument to build upon in guaranteeing our share from other common rivers.

Although Bangladesh and India established the JRC mechanism early in Bangladesh’s post-independence history, recent years have seen a significant decline in holding regular meetings. The last time water ministers from the two countries met under the JRC framework was in August 2022 -- after a 12-year hiatus. While 36 rounds of talks were held, in between 1972 and 2010, only two rounds have occurred in the last 15 years.

It is encouraging, however, that at least at the technical level, there have been visits between the two countries as recently as March this year. This process needs to be expedited, in our interest as a lower riparian country, so that our people are not left water-starved.

Moreover, the lack of engagement and delays in joint monitoring and data sharing hinder early warning systems for floods and droughts and increase the risk of environmental disasters such as desertification.

Lasting peace in South Asia requires, among other things, that international conventions, treaties, and norms be honored, and that countries engage with one another on the basis of mutual respect, international standards, and sovereign equality.

Reaz Ahmad is Editor, Dhaka Tribune.

Top Brokers