I have some bad news, I'm afraid. It's a proper worry, a terror.
Some humans will lie.
There, I've said it. Not all of our fellows are wholly honest, willing to abide by morals, ethics, or even the law. Of course, to anyone over the age of six, this is not a grand surprise. Well, that is, anyone over that age of innocence and also not a bureaucrat or law maker.
The spark of this is a report in this newspaper that some Indian clothings “sarees, lehengas, two-pieces, three-pieces, panjabis” are being imported but the importers are misdeclaring their value at the border. The value at that border is being declared as Tk60, perhaps Tk120, when they go on to be sold for Tk1 lakh.
Now, of course, as an elderly Englishman I've not much clue about what these clothing items are -- but I can identify what is happening with alarming accuracy.
People are lying. They are telling untruths. And this is one of those things that we've got to grasp about the law, economic planning, rules about this and that. People will lie. Not all of us, not anyone all the time, but enough people enough of the time that strict rules, in detail, don't work.
Now, this is about high-end Indian garments and let's be honest: The market for Tk1 lakh pieces of women's clothing -- now the government's changed -- is pretty limited. So we're not talking of something that is a grand danger to the republic, only of someone lying to get around the rules.
But we can still use it as a useful illustration of something larger.
In Australia they're trying to wipe out smoking. Huge, no truly vast, taxes on legal cigarettes. Vaping with liquids that contain nicotine seems to be illegal. The result is that some 50% of the Australian cigarette market is illegal. There have been -- by one count -- 200 fire bombings of tobacco outlets as varied gangs fight to control the distribution network. In Britain we seem to have a brand called “Manchester” as one of the top sellers. Except this is not, in fact, a legal brand. It's never been legal anywhere in fact, it's entirely an invention of the tax dodgers.
Smugglers only exist when there's a profit in smuggling. If we wish to have an absence of smugglers then the correct answer is not to create profits for them to capture
It's as if the American experience with prohibition hasn't impacted upon the minds of the politicians and planners.
People will lie and people will take advantage of the law if there's a profit in it.
Which is one of those things which makes me what I am, a minarchist. No, monarchist is something different. I am someone who insists upon minimal government. For, yes, we can have all sorts of lovely plans about how to make the world, a country, a better place. If only the rulers were to get the regulations, the law, entirely right then we'd be golden. An idea which always runs headlong into that brick wall of people being willing to lie, cheat, steal.
This is what led to the old English political settlement. I agree that this wasn't what John Company imposed in Bengal but it was what happened at home. There would be very few rules. Those that did exist would be really important. Therefore we could expect most of the people, most of the time, to obey them.
When we expand the system beyond that then we simply increase the number of people willing to break those laws in pursuit of personal enrichment -- as, observably, happens.
Here the original example is whether a lady's clothes are made in India or Bangladesh, in West Bengal or independent Bengal. This is not an important enough issue to invoke the law -- say I. But more importantly, it's a law so easy to break that people do.
Smugglers only exist when there's a profit in smuggling. If we wish to have an absence of smugglers then the correct answer is not to create profits for them to capture. This is true of most forms of economic law breaking.
Whether the item under discussion is booze, 'baccy or ladies things. If we've not got vast taxes and detailed regulations, then why would anyone bother to break the rules?
Tim Worstall is a senior fellow at the Adam Smith Institute in London.



