Islamic finance doesn't matter in the slightest. Or, obviously, Islamic finance is absolutely essential to the salvation of our souls. It's possible to hold both these views simultaneously and as a Catholic I'll only insist upon the one. Those of other religious beliefs might differ. Which is one of those glories of how economics works. For what we think about our souls doesn't, in fact, matter to how markets, investment, banking, and so on work. To the surface of them, perhaps yes. But to the underlying nuts and bolts, no, not at all.
Recent news in this newspaper is that a bank opened an Islamic window, another had a Shariah committee meeting, another again, Shariah compliant window, the government itself borrowing via Sukuk -- sharia compliant bonds.
To which one reaction is how wonderful. People are able to do things -- save and invest -- in the way their morals, ethics, religious beliefs, say they should. The other reaction is that it doesn't matter. The difference between the two reactions is whether we are viewing these as a human or as an economist.
The economist's view is, in the very specific field of economics, the correct one. In anything wider, more useful, it's that human view that matters.
This is a little more philosophical than I normally am here but it's an absolutely vital point. Economics does not tell us what should be. In the same way that physics does not tell us about morals, nor chemistry about ethics.
Morals, ethics, religious beliefs, these are things that might tell us what we wish to do. They could tell us methods we shouldn't use to gain them. But they are things which we bring to physics, chemistry -- or economics.
What we wish is not something economics can tell us. Only that if this is what is wished then this is how to get from here to there -- and not always that either.
The usual statement of this in the textbooks is that economics is not moral, or immoral, it's amoral. It's a technical subject which says that if -- for example, and just as an example -- you wish for everyone to have a higher standard of living, then capitalism and markets really do work in gaining that goal. It doesn't tell us that the goal is worthwhile -- even as I myself would insist that that's the whole point of even having an economy.
It's entirely possible to insist that the use of capitalism and markets is immoral in and of itself and many socialists and other fools do so. At which point economics just says well, those are your choices so the average person isn't going to get rich then. There's no argument with the morals being insisted upon, with the ethics being imposed. Just the logical result of what is being demanded.
Which brings us back to Islamic finance. The ban on interest is not unlike the one Catholicism had for near a millennium. It's also one of those things which, in economic terms, doesn't in fact matter.
It's wholly possible to share risk and thus profit instead of insisting upon interest. We're still working with the underlying truth -- for investment to take place someone, somewhere, has to save, not consume, and they deserve something for doing that.
It's even possible to argue that the Islamic restrictions are more capitalist than Europe -- everyone's a capitalist and no one collects interest.
Which brings us to why it doesn't matter. The form doesn't, the fact does. Savings happen -- consumption does not happen now. Those savings are then invested and those that work produce returns for those who have saved. Those that don't, don't.
We have a system that invests in the future and makes that future richer because investment in it has taken place. With a system that rewards those who invest in what works well and doesn't those who don't. We have accorded with the lessons of economics.
Or, to make this point about economics being amoral again. The subject doesn't tell us about what. It tells us how. That is important when we evaluate the next dreamer who tells us how everything is going to be so much better -- ok, how? But what is still something that we decide first.
Tim Worstall is a senior fellow at the Adam Smith Institute in London.



