Reliable Brokers
Online Investing
Alerts & Analysis
Easy Trading

Dreams, deals, and delusions: India’s dance with Trump

India’s hopes for a stronger global role may clash with the unpredictability of Trump’s policies and their own internal challenges

Update : 20 Jan 2025, 03:23 PM

The streets of New Delhi’s diplomatic hub are abuzz with excitement. Why? Because Donald Trump is poised to return to the White House. In anticipation, India’s External Affairs Minister, S Jaishankar, has been singing praises of the “special bond” between Modi and Trump -- a relationship he claims is as strong as the chai served at Indian railway stations.

Jaishankar, with a twinkle in his eye, proudly shared that Modi’s congratulatory call to Trump after the 2024 elections was one of the first three calls the future US president picked up. This, according to Jaishankar, proves the depth of their friendship. 

And now, India hopes to ride on Trump’s coattails once again, ignoring the fact that Trump’s policies often resemble a rollercoaster ride -- unpredictable and occasionally nausea-inducing.

A bid for global manufacturing

India’s grand plan? To become a hub for global manufacturing as supply chains move away from China. But there’s a tiny problem. Vietnam and Malaysia have already rolled out the red carpet for these companies, offering genuine ease of business and fewer bureaucratic headaches. India, on the other hand, clings to outdated land acquisition and labour laws like a stubborn relative refusing to move with the times.

The result? India risks missing the manufacturing bus once again. While Jaishankar speaks of reform with catchy slogans, businesses seem more impressed by countries that actually deliver. For now, Vietnam and Malaysia are the cool kids at the global supply chain party, and India is still waiting for an invitation.

The brain drain

But don’t worry, the Modi government has another ace up its sleeve: Manpower. Yes, India’s biggest export isn’t software or spices -- it’s people. The government proudly highlights the vast pool of skilled workers, particularly in science, engineering, and management. But here’s the kicker: Even this isn’t the trump card it once was.

While China has spent decades building a strong STEM education system, India’s focus has been different. During Mao’s era, China made math and science a priority in schools. Today, it reaps the rewards, standing toe-to-toe with the US in technology and innovation. 

Meanwhile, India invested heavily in prestigious institutions like IITs and IIMs. But instead of benefiting the nation, these graduates often head straight to Silicon Valley, taking their taxpayer-subsidized education with them. It’s a win-win … for America.

This brain drain has left India in a peculiar spot. And let’s not even get started on Trump’s “America first” policy. Mukesh Aghi, president of the US-India Strategic Partnership Forum, made it crystal clear: If India wants to stay in America’s good books, it better “align” with Trump’s goals. Translation? Help America rebuild itself while continuing to send your best and brightest our way.

The Trump-Modi bromance may be more wishful thinking than reality. While the rhetoric is high, the results have been underwhelming

Diplomatic concerns

But wait, Jaishankar also lavished praise on Trump’s role in revitalizing the Quad, a strategic alliance aimed at countering China. Yet, despite all this diplomatic back-patting, it’s hard to ignore the imbalance. 

The US seems happy to sell India weapons and bask in the goodwill of large rallies like the "Maha Kumbh Mela" event. But when it comes to concrete help in becoming an economic powerhouse? Crickets.

Adding to India’s diplomatic juggling act is its relationship with Russia. Historically a close ally, Moscow has been a reliable partner for defense equipment and energy resources. However, as India seeks to balance ties with both the US and Russia, complications arise. The recent rupee-rouble trade agreement, aimed at bypassing the US dollar for bilateral trade, has drawn attention. While it shows India’s effort to reduce dependency on the dollar, it also risks ruffling feathers in Washington.

The dollar’s dominance in global trade isn’t just a matter of convenience; it’s a pillar of US economic power. Any attempt to challenge this, even indirectly, is met with suspicion. Trump, known for his zero-tolerance approach to perceived threats, might view India’s rupee-rouble arrangement as a step too far. Unlike Russia, which can leverage its energy exports, India lacks the same bargaining chips, making it vulnerable to US pressures.

Meanwhile, China’s influence looms large. As President Xi Jinping received an invitation to Trump’s potential inauguration, whispers of strategic deals grow louder. Imagine Xi and Trump discussing mutually beneficial arrangements while India watches from the sidelines, juggling its complex equations with both nations.

On US grounds

And now for the plot twist. Trump’s likely administration lineup includes one Harmeet Dhillon, a Khalistani sympathizer who’s been very vocal about alleged Indian government actions against Sikhs abroad. Dhillon’s appointment to the US Justice Department could spell trouble for India. Imagine Home Minister Amit Shah or NSA Ajit Doval being implicated in cases that prevent them from stepping on US soil. It’s a diplomatic headache waiting to happen.

But India might find an unlikely ally in Kash Patel, a Gujarati-American and Trump loyalist nominated to head the FBI. Patel’s family’s journey from managing roadside motels to the corridors of power is inspiring. But will Patel stand up for India if push comes to shove?

Trump’s way or the highway

Trump’s vision for America’s allies is simple: Bend to my will, or else. His admiration for authoritarian leaders is no secret. Case in point: The first invitation to his second inauguration reportedly went to Hungary’s Viktor Orbán, a leader Trump admires for his hardline policies. And while President Xi Jinping received an invitation soon after, Modi is still waiting by the mailbox. Perhaps the invitation got lost, or maybe it’s a subtle reminder of where India stands in Trump’s pecking order.

At the end of the day, the Trump-Modi bromance may be more wishful thinking than reality. While the rhetoric is high, the results have been underwhelming. It’s worth remembering that for Trump, every relationship is transactional, and right now, India’s balance sheet doesn’t look too promising.

So, as New Delhi pins its hopes on a Trump-led America, it might be time to reassess. The world is changing, and alliances need to be built on mutual respect and shared goals, not photo-ops and platitudes. Until then, the Modi government might want to keep an eye on that mailbox. Who knows? Trump’s invitation could still arrive -- just fashionably late.

HM Nazmul Alam, Lecturer, Department of English and Modern Languages, International University of Business, Agriculture and Technology. Email: [email protected]

Top Brokers