Reliable Brokers
Online Investing
Alerts & Analysis
Easy Trading

Rotten eggs and justice on trial

Is mob rage taking over Bangladesh's courts?

Update : 28 Oct 2024, 07:36 AM

In what should be a house of justice, a disconcerting theatre of mob rule has emerged. Court premises across Bangladesh are increasingly the site of extrajudicial verdicts delivered, not by judges, but by angry mobs wielding rotten eggs, shoes, and fists. 

Whether the accused were former ministers, journalists, student leaders or a retired judge, all seem to face an unofficial trial by ordeal, shaming, and violence before the actual legal proceedings even begin.

This violent outburst -- directed at those charged but not yet proven guilty -- represents a new wave of moral decay that we as a society must reckon with. 

Asif Nazrul, legal advisor to the interim government, noted, "No one should ever be attacked while going to court, it is not justified in any way." His words highlight the dire need for basic decorum in our courts. And yet, this sentiment seems lost on the mob.

The breakdown of the rule of law

The root of the issue is that mob justice undermines the foundation of any legitimate legal system. Allowing a crowd to impose its own notion of "justice" is a regression to the days before law and order, when vengeful villagers would set upon those they deemed guilty, long before any evidence was weighed. 

Every individual -- no matter how heinous their alleged crimes -- is entitled to a fair trial, as promised by the very Constitution that frames our justice system. Without this assurance, we are left in a system where suspicion, hatred, and personal vendettas can override truth.

What happened to the solemn words of William Blackstone, who famously stated, “It is better that 10 guilty persons escape than that one innocent suffer?” In recent times, it seems that we have abandoned these principles in favour of a perverse catharsis, a temporary outlet for collective anger. 

Public sentiment on mob justice

An online survey by a national daily asked the public, “Do you support extra-lawful attacks on defendants in the court premises?” A resounding 87% responded with a "no," signalling that most people do, in fact, disapprove of these displays of mob justice. And yet, 11% responded affirmatively, suggesting there is a significant minority who feel such acts are justified. 

It’s disturbing to think that more than 1,900 people in a sample of 19,517 actually condone assaulting individuals before they have had their day in court.

These numbers are troubling, as they suggest that many see mob action as a substitute for justice -- a notion inseparably linked to frustration with the system's inefficiency. 

Rotten eggs and the theatre of the absurd

One wonders what a Victorian satirist like Jonathan Swift would make of this mess. Perhaps he would pen a “Modest Proposal” on the proper methods of pelting the accused with rotten eggs -- a public display where vendors could set up shop outside courtrooms, selling produce for a nominal fee to disillusioned bystanders. 

Such a grotesque notion, humorous in its absurdity, highlights the sheer incongruity of the situation: An institution meant to uphold justice devolving into an arena where justice is secondary to the public’s primal urges.

The mob mentality has created an atmosphere where hurling insults and objects at the accused is now expected. Lawyers reportedly prepare in advance for high-profile cases, rallying the crowd with slogans and derogatory chants. Such behaviour warps the court into a performance hall, complete with hecklers and bystanders as the unwitting audience. 

“General students protested by throwing eggs,” said a student leader, as though this form of protest were as normal as a picket line outside a factory. Yet, in truth, this isn’t a protest; it’s a mockery of the justice process, a public spectacle that embarrasses the very institution it invades.

The issue is not merely one of misbehaviour but a question of authority

The right to a fair trial for all

To defend an individual’s right to a fair trial is not to condone their alleged actions; it is to safeguard the process that prevents the innocent from suffering unjustly. 

Consider Victor Hugo’s Les Misérables, where even the most despicable characters -- crooked officials, heartless jailers, morally bankrupt individuals -- are portrayed as deserving justice, for they too are human. Mob justice is a negation of this principle, a hasty, irreversible judgement that cannot be undone once it strikes.

“When a person is arrested and brought to justice, there is no scope to torture him physically or mentally,” said ZI Khan Panna, chairperson of Ain o Salish Kendra. This fundamental concept has clearly eluded the mob, for whom punishment without due process is apparently permissible if the crime seems severe enough. 

However, allowing such behaviour in court premises damages the credibility of justice and sets a precedent that could someday be used against anyone, innocent or guilty.

A culture of vindictiveness

What’s more, this mob mentality raises a culture of vindictiveness. As anger spills into courtrooms, it transforms the judiciary into a theatre of cruelty. 

Take the case of Saber Hossain Chowdhury, former Forest and Environment Minister, who faced egg-pelting and physical threats as he was escorted to a hearing. 

Similarly, eggs and shoes were hurled at JSD President Hasanul Haq Inu and even a former judge, AHM Shamsuddin Chowdhury, as they faced their respective charges.

This vindictiveness knows no bounds. Shoes, eggs, even outright slaps have become instruments wielded not for justice but for revenge -- a spectacle reminiscent of medieval stocks, where criminals were publicly humiliated. In our age of information, though, this ritualized shaming is amplified online, each assault recorded and shared, cheered on by likes and shares.

The need for institutional authority

The issue is not merely one of misbehaviour but a question of authority. Allowing such acts to continue sends a message that law enforcement and court authorities are unable to protect the accused or maintain order. It sets a dangerous precedent that encourages others to follow suit, eroding the sanctity of judicial proceedings.

As Farzana Rupa, another victim of mob wrath, experienced firsthand, mob justice can escalate rapidly. “You have to make it safe,” pleaded Sara Hossain, urging officials to uphold the law within the courtroom and prevent this circus-like atmosphere from continuing.

The long road back to justice

If we are to prevent this behaviour from becoming a norm, the judiciary must take firm action. Security forces must ensure that anyone, no matter the accusations against them, can stand trial without fear of harm. Institutions must strive to regain public trust by demonstrating that they can and will uphold the law. But more than that, the public needs to reexamine its own role in this erosion of judicial integrity. 

Justice isn’t a right for just the innocent; it is the foundation of a society that values human dignity, no matter how flawed the individual. If we let mob justice prevail today, who is to say that tomorrow it won’t be you or me facing a barrage of rotten eggs, for crimes real or imagined, before the gavel falls?


HM Nazmul Alam is a Lecturer, Department of English and Modern Languages, International University of Business, Agriculture and Technology. He can be reached at [email protected]

Top Brokers