Reliable Brokers
Online Investing
Alerts & Analysis
Easy Trading

Development philosophies and the issue of ethics

What use is growth if it does not contribute to welfare for the common people and if the voices of such people are absent

Update : 25 Oct 2024, 08:46 AM

Traditionally, “progress” and “development” are considered synonymous. As a result, these two words are often used interchangeably. But going beyond the literal meanings of them, if these words are looked through the prism of development ideas, the differences between them become clear. 

Progress refers to some quantitative changes -- increases or decreases. And that can happen in the case of an indicator -- for example, increases in national income or life expectancy or declines in under-five mortality. In contrast, development implies quantitative transformations -- structural reforms, changes in values, outlooks, and mentality. From another perspective, progress is vertical or longitudinal changes, while development is horizontal or latitudinal transformations. 

Two issues thus are critically important for development -- development philosophies and ethical development. The desired qualitative transformation sought in development must have a philosophical base. Does the pursued development trajectory increase deprivation or decrease it; does it raise disparities or reduce them; is it participatory or imposed; is it culturally-enshrined or rootless; and is it environment-friendly or environment-degrading? All these questions reflect some development philosophies, both in terms of development processes and development outcomes. 

For example, when we say that we want a disparity-reducing development, it implies that as development outcomes, we seek a balanced society. Similarly, participatory development means universality in the development process. If the idea of development philosophies is extended, issues of capitalist development versus socialist development also come in -- should the development trajectory follow a capitalist path or a socialist path.  

On many occasions, issues of balanced development have also been raised, where the act of balancing among different dimensions of development was highlighted. Aspects of gender-equity, environmental protection, intergenerational development have also been part of the development thoughts. 

For quite some time, with people being put at the centre of development, new dimensions have been added to development philosophies. Those who uphold this people-centred development philosophy, have said again and again that in the ultimate analysis, development means development of the people, for the people, and by the people. The emergence and the expansion of the idea of human development are rooted in such discourses. 

The human development thought appeared as an antithesis to the growth theory. The development philosophy behind the growth theory stresses that from analytical as well as measurement perspectives, development means expansion of income and wealth. For the advocates of this theory, if there are increases in individual and national income, the standard of living of the people and national prosperity would be enhanced. 

But over time, there has been national prosperity, but without any visible impact on the lives of the common people. Often, national income has not been equitably distributed, the income rise has not led to the improvement of human lives, and common people have remained at the periphery of development.

The philosophy of human development places human beings at the centre of all development activities. If growth does not contribute to human welfare, if the fruits of growth are not shared by common people, if the voices of the people are absent, that cannot be termed as development. 

Development means expansion of human choices -- enhancement of their capabilities, expansion of the opportunities and people’s participation in the development process. Thus, human development seems to represent the desired philosophy of development.

Traditionally, in many instances, the issue of development was presented as an abstract idea, as if development is value-neutral and independent of ethics. This is wrong. Development philosophies are very much value-laden and are deeply anchored in ethics. Even simple progress has an ethical perspective. 

Without changes in the mindset, it is not possible to build the qualitative structural reforms required for transforming progress into development

For example, two countries -- “A” and “B” have been able to reduce their population growth to 1%. So, looking at the outcomes, both the countries seem to have done equally well. But let us assume that while country “A” has achieved that feat by coercion and use of force, country “B” has achieved it through moral persuasion and incentives. Now from an ethical standard, while the success of country “B” would be celebrated, that of country “A” would be termed as immoral and not to be heralded.

Ethics are at the core of development philosophies. If a development philosophy is not respectful of human rights, violates human security, and does not ensure all kinds of equity, that philosophy is not acceptable from an ethical point of view. We should also discard a development philosophy which is patriarchal, which is blind to inter-generational rights and equities, which is not environment-friendly. 

One important dimension of a development philosophy is to have a solid framework for transparency and accountability. Where transparency is absent, accountability also vanishes. In the absence of accountability, autocratic power emerges, huge corruption creeps in, and all kinds of ethical foundations crumble down. An autocratic economic philosophy, devoid of ethics, appears in that context. In the consequent development trajectory, economic progress may take place, but that progress cannot be considered as a people-centred inclusive development.

In the ethical perspectives of development philosophies, a few other values are also critical. For example, the trust of people in the development process and their participation in it are important prerequisites to the development success of a country. The development path of a country will impact the lives of the people. Therefore, it is essential that the voice of the people is crucially significant in the decision-making process.  

This will not only integrate people in the development process, but will also improve the transparency and accountability of the system itself. The development philosophy of a society must be deep-rooted in its heritage, values, and culture. The culture of a society should be reflected in its development philosophy. The development programs and projects undertaken in an economy should not offend the local values and cultural sensitivities.

Similarly, patience, tolerance, and endurance are part of development philosophies. They have two dimensions. The first one relates to development discourses and debates, which help to build a development philosophy in a society. In the context of such debates and dialogues, inter-personal tolerance and respect for diverging views are essential. Lack of respect for others’ views cannot take a development discourse to a positive conclusion. 

The second one is in the area of social cohesion. People from different backgrounds, religions, colour and creed, socio-economic strata live in a society. But if divisions, rather than cohesion, exist among various groups, the development in that society is stunted. Patience, tolerance, and endurance have a major role in removing social divisions and building social cohesion.

Ultimately, the most difficult hindrance to human development philosophies is the mindset of the people. Without changes in the mindset, it is not possible to build the qualitative structural reforms required for transforming progress into development. And that transformation must start at the individual level, and ultimately taken to the social and the state level. 

Dr Selim Jahan is the Former Director, Human Development Report Office and Poverty Division, United Nations Development Program, New York, USA.

Top Brokers