The present interim government will conduct a national election after some vital reforms are brought about throughout our national institutions, while essentially making it appear as though they are in for a long haul with a fair acceptance from all stakeholders. Active political parties are fine with it, so far anyway. Our Constitution allows political parties a license to form and run the government for five years through direct voting.
By principle, an interim government should not run the office for an indeterminate amount of time. But this argument is lost on the checkered history of how blatantly the Constitution was manipulated to serve the interest of past parties. The Constitution had been effectively made an instrument several times to justify the illegitimate actions of previous governments.
But there will definitely be a general election, ultimately, leading to the formation of a new government. This begs the question of whether the transition of power after the tenure of that government will be done so in a civilized manner or will we spiral into yet another loop of judicial and administrative mismanagement by a government to stay in power.
To avert such this possibility, experts have suggested two popular measures: Setting a term limit and for any elected prime minister to not remain as the executive chief of their political party indefinitely. While these suggestions are sensible, they also deserve some scrutiny.
Assumptions regarding the first measure include that the government would not resort to foul play and engineer the elections in a way which ensures their long-term rule. In other words, this is merely a treatment for the symptom, not the disease itself. Essentially, it is asking for the mercy of the prime minister to not run for a third time. It shifts the burden of arranging free, fair and participatory elections away from the Election Commission (EC) to the incumbent prime minister.
This strategy does not account for the possibility that a government may do away with the hypothetical law barring a prime minister from participating to get elected a third time. It also does not address whether a hypothetical twice-elected prime minister would always prefer their party to stay in power so that they get to be the president or even run for MP, which could still ensure that they have some influence over the government. Lest we forget, political hegemony is a real thing in Bangladesh.
It is high time we had a robust, effective, and de facto independent EC.
While the government controls the executive, the EC is supposed to be an independent constitutional commission. To keep the executive and the EC from colluding to host farcical elections, the leadership of the EC must be from outside government sponsored commissioners.
Well ahead of the 12th parliamentary election earlier this year, a search committee was formed to provide a list of eligible candidates for ECs back in 2022. Boycotted by the leading opposition, the committee received a list of 322 candidates (with a few repetitions) proposed by other political parties. The committee didn’t reveal which party nominated whom. Selected from that list, election commissioners conducted the January 7 election regardless. Unsurprisingly, bar one, the 321 candidates are not in today's advisors' panel of the interim government. This only goes to show how the selection of an election commissioner can be biased. If election commissioners are directly selected from the opposition or are even sponsored by the opposition, the probability of a fair election only goes up. It will create a balance of power between the commission and the government.
Another vital reform suggestion is the consideration of time and space when it comes to the act of voting itself during national elections. In the last 12th parliamentary election, there were 120 million voters, 42,000 polling centres, and 261,000 polling booths (approximately). To elect a government for the next five years, 12 crore voters are given only eight to nine hours to cast their votes; between 8am to 4pm.
It is practically impossible for law enforcement agencies to monitor and maintain law and order throughout the whole country, more so at the 42,000 polling centres on the day of election. Which is why, instead of one single day, elections should be held throughout 8-10 days in the span of a month. Each division can hold elections on different days, with Dhaka in two days, obviously due to its mass population. After polls, the ballot boxes can be kept and stored securely under a transparent system until all other votes are cast, while stamped ballots would be counted on a predetermined day to declare the elected MPs.
This is the risk management approach -- it lowers all duties, responsibilities, challenges, threats, and other external factors down to manageable levels. Members of law enforcement on election duty can be deployed exclusively in each election division before and during the day of its election. It will substantially augment their capabilities to tackle unwanted interventions in the electoral process which in turn can also avert electoral violence.
Zulkernain Khandaker is a freelance contributor. He can be reached at [email protected].



