Autocracy is as much linguistic and discursive, as it is material and substantive. It is a case of governance not just by weapons but also by words. It is a terror not only for people’s lives and properties but also for language, truth and truth-making.
The people of Bangladesh lived through an autocratic rule for over 15 years. It began in the guise of democracy in early 2009 with Sheikh Hasina as prime minister. Soon afterwards, it turned into an authoritarian rule where her own wishes dictated almost everything. She emerged as a seasoned autocrat who retained her power against all odds.
She exploited all state machinery including the parliament, the judiciary, security forces, and the intelligentsia in her stated ambition to rule the country till 2041. However, all her material and discursive tricks and strategies failed in the end. Swallowing her own words that “Sheikh Hasina palai na,” she ultimately fled to India on August 5, 2024 after an involuntary resignation.
Any handbook of autocrats will tell us how they exploit language and propaganda machines to construct versions of truths not only about their own rules, but also about people and society. The singular aim of such epistemic work is to gain legitimacy and longevity of the regime.
The concept of “post-truth” may provide a handy theoretical lens to talk about autocrats’ versions of truth. However, I would argue that post-truth is too civil to connote the epistemic power and its brutal consequences that were associated with the autocracy in Bangladesh. I therefore suggest using the term “epistemic terror.” Such violence presents a non-civilian form of what scholars have called “epistemic injustice.”
Bangladeshi students started protesting an unjust quota system in government jobs in June. Their protests were small-scale and peaceful. However, the movement changed its scope and character in early July mainly due to Hasina’s epistemic instigation. On her return from a “failed” official visit to China, she spoke at a press conference during which her attention was drawn to the ongoing student movement.
Instead of listening to the grievances of the students, Hasina mocked them using her typical verbalism. Forgetting that the government removed the quota in 2018, she fired a rhetorical bullet: Who deserves the quota privileges? The descendants of freedom fighters or those of razakars?
The students were infuriated by her insult. They formed an anti-discrimination movement and declared a nation-wide blockade. As expected, the police were dictated to control the situation by applying whatever means was needed. Chhatra League hoodlums were also set on innocent students on campuses, in residential halls and in the streets. The result was hundreds of deaths and casualties across the country.
Even though videos of point-blank shooting of students were circulating across the media, the government was stubborn in its denial claiming that no students were killed by the police. Hasina’s own version of the truth was that the students and the movement were hijacked by BNP and Jamaat to create anarchy and to unseat her from power. Even though most of the students who were killed had no affiliation with either political party, she deployed all her epistemic force in constructing her own truth. This truth also gave her legitimacy to ban Jamaat as a political party by an executive order on August 1, 2024.
The police fired bullets to kill and minted words to justify killings
One typical feature of the epistemic terror by the state machinery during Hasina’s 15-year rule was related to the damage of public properties and infrastructures. There is a credible theory that it is usually the police and Awami League activists who set fire on buses and trains only to blame such destruction on opposition party members. Exploiting this epistemic strategy was more imperative in the recent crisis than ever before.
As expected, metro rail stations and other infrastructures were damaged, and the blame was placed on the protestors. Hasina visited these sites and wept allegedly fake tears. While her regime was directly responsible for the student deaths, she asked in a rhetorical manner, who would take responsibility for these damages.
Her epistemic shamelessness was clear in the official order that declared July 30 a national mourning day. The order said that the government would commemorate those killed by the “violence, arson, setting fire, plundering and other terrorist activities unleashed in the name of [the] student movement against the quota system.”
Perhaps a classic example of epistemic terrorism was shooting from helicopters and how it was discoursed by Hasina. The government deployed all its killing strategies and weapons against innocent people. One unique strategy was firing bullets from helicopters which injured children on rooftops and inside their houses. However, she used her epistemic arsenal to explain that there was fire around and helicopters were used to drop water to extinguish it. This turned bullets into water and also denied children’s casualties.
A more “civilized” form of epistemic violence during the regime was reconstituting the police not only as a security force, but also a discursive machine. The media wing opened for the police department was an epistemic counterpart to the physical “security” operations. The police fired bullets to kill and minted words to justify killings. The epistemic arm of the police department constituted unwanted people or entities as “terrorists” or “razakars,” foreclosing the questioning of the state-sponsored terrorism.
Not all epistemic acts by autocratic rulers are necessarily violent. Some can be less brutal and more entertaining. Therefore, it is possible to suggest weak and strong forms of epistemic terrorism.
There have been many examples of the weak form in the past 15 years. In fact, whenever there was a crisis in the country -- whether natural or caused by Hasina’s rule -- she would utilize her epistemic spell. For example, she addressed the short supply of onions in the market by constructing the truth that onions were not essential for cooking. Similarly, she is recorded to have said that she made egg-plant dishes from pumpkin. She also gave culinary advice to people about the food value of jackfruit burgers.
Hasina’s epistemic terror challenged people’s everyday sense of life, living, society, and the world. This terror had its highest expression in the recent crisis when the deployment of the army was justified in the name of security. In her epistemic logic, killing people was necessary for their security.
Autocracy gave her an unprecedented epistemic power which was more dangerous than post-truth. It is nothing short of epistemic terrorism -- an act aimed at discursively justifying all brutalities during her autocratic rule.
Obaidul Hamid is an associate professor at the University of Queensland in Australia. He researches language, education, and society in the developing world.



