The politics of the new Bangladesh isn't really for me to comment upon – I'm a foreigner after all.
However, Muhammad Yunus is currently the Chief Adviser to the interim government and it's worth having a little look at what -- in proper economic terms -- was his great achievement. Yes, Grameen and so on -- but to strip back from the activity to the point that he proved.
It's generally taken as being that microfinance works. That lending small amounts to poor people then produces a burst of entrepreneurism that creates economic growth. Say, $100 here to get a small-scale chicken farm going, $100 to get a tailoring operation working. And, well, again, yes. That the poor are capital constrained is obviously true, but it's also not true that simply providing capital to the poor makes them richer. There are, after all, those who will simply drink a new income or asset. Or even instead of drinking it just waste it -- there's an old line from a baseball player who went bust: But, what did you do with all the money? Well, 90% went on slow horses, fast women, and whiskey; the rest, I wasted.
There have also been all sorts of attempts to hand out money to the poor and very few operating businesses resulted and certainly the capital deployed wasn't returned. But for Yunus it was. So, what was different? What was the special magic sauce?
One of the reasons the poor are capital constrained is that they have no security for whatever loans might be provided to cure that capital constraint. The English joke about this is that a bank will only lend you an umbrella when it isn't raining. You've got to prove that you can pay the loan back without the business being successful before you can get the loan that is.
Yunus noted one big thing. Everyone does have an asset, their social reputation. So, if we organize people into groups, groups of friends and already contacts, then we can use the social pressure from those groups to push for repayment of financing loans. Further, if only one member of such a group can have a loan at any one time then those eager to develop their own ideas will place pressure on the earlier borrowers to repay.
In economic terms this was the big insight Yunus had. It's a very grand one too and that Nobel is well deserved, but that's what the insight was. Social standing, social status, is a real thing in human societies. Yes, this is true among the poor just as much as it is in any other part of society -- we are all human after all. Thus this very thing, status among the social group, can be used as security for loans that solve that capital shortage.
As I said, it's a grand insight and one that has made the world a better place.
But it is also possible to go further. When the M-Pesa system of electronic money (effectively, SIM credit over the Vodafone network) was first set up in East Africa the operators were completely dumbfounded. Very large numbers of people were not using the system as a source of credit at all. Rather, and this was concentrated among the very poor, people were retaining positivebalances in the system.
Yes, the poor would like a source of credit to use to set up a small scale business. No doubt about that. But when there actually was a proper banking system for the poor, what they really wanted, according to their actions, was a place to save.
One of the things about poverty is that income can be highly variable. Further, if you save a few week's money -- for the bad times, an illness, for that period between planting and harvesting work -- then the rats might eat cash money. Or someone might find it and drink it. Or steal it and so on -- secure savings are secure. What the poor actually wanted -- as that M-Pesa system showed -- was a system of secure savings for the sort of small sums that the poor can put by for the bad times.
There was a similar result in an Indian study of basic incomes -- folk got free money for a year. One of the things they did was increase their savings to cover those bad times.
Until we've seen it demonstrated it's one of those things that we'll not believe. One of the things the poor really want is a secure method of saving. The road that led to us all finding this out started with Yunus.
Wouldn't it be fun if we really did it now? Actual banks -- electronic, physical, matters not -- that would deal with a few hundred Taka here or there, a couple of thousand? A reliable and safe way to put a few day's wages aside for those bad times when there are no day's wages.
Yes, we all agree now, the poor want capital. But they also want safe savings.
Tim Worstall is a senior fellow at the Adam Smith Institute in London.



