Now that politics has changed there will be the inevitable cries that everything must change. Some things should change too. But it's still worth insisting that some changes could be bad. A few examples from Britain:
The UK has had national planning of land use since 1947 -- the Town and Country Planning Act. This insists that you can only build anything where the national plan, and layers and layers of bureaucracy, say you can. Britain has had a growing shortage of housing for nearly 80 years now.
The British government decided, on the creation of the National Health Service, that it would be responsible for planning the training of doctors and nurses for the nation. That happened in 1948. Britain has a significant shortage of doctors and nurses and imports many from overseas while the training places that are available have multiple applicants for each slot.
The British railways were nationalized just after WWII. Passenger journeys halved in the following decades. The railways were privatized and passenger journeys doubled again.
The water companies were nationalized and then the government would not invest in them. Because there was always something more important, more fun, or more politically relevant to spend the money upon than the drains. The water companies were privatized again, and investment soared.
There's even one in Scotland. The government runs the ferry company out to the lightly inhabited islands -- not a silly idea. They needed new ferries, and the government owned a shipyard that could build ferries. So, that's where the contract went. The ferries are currently six years late and the government contract to build the ferries has bankrupted the government's own shipyard.
Maybe the government planning, running, actual companies and services isn't a good idea. On the other hand, even if the government is really terrible at most things, it's still possible for capitalism, markets, and the private sector to be even worse than the government at some things.
Britain did have a time of private armies, for example, we called it the Wars of the Roses. It's fair today that no one very much enjoyed that century. Private law has always existed everywhere about civil matters, but we really would be most unhappy if there were a form of private criminal law. When that does occur we call it gangsterism.
There are grey areas too, things where there's no particular harm, or good, to public or private provision. Public libraries are fine, just as private ones are.
The point to be made here in this time of renewal is that there really must be a mixed economy. There are some things that both need to be done and can only be effectively done by the government and there are also things that we don't want to allow the government anywhere near. That grey area almost becomes just a matter of taste.
But if we're about to rethink everything -- which is what a time of change actually is, a time to rethink -- the vital point is to be aware of which tool, government or markets, we should use to solve which problem. A lot of which will mean not doing it as the British government has over this past century.
Tim Worstall is a senior fellow at the Adam Smith Institute in London.



