Reliable Brokers
Online Investing
Alerts & Analysis
Easy Trading

Who regulates?

Diving into the debate on consumer sovereignty versus bureaucratic oversight through the case of Sonali Life Insurance and more

Update : 04 Aug 2024, 10:03 AM

Sonali Life Insurance and its directors is one of those stories where the courts are having a close look. Allegations, claims and so on. So, not a story that we can be emphatic about in detail. However, we can make a more general and very important point over the story. How much regulation should there be? Or, more accurately, who should regulate?

We never have to go far to find people who insist there must be rules for everything. Rules set by the government, the bureaucracy, to show all what is allowed as well as what is mandatory. This is not, perhaps, how a free society operates. There are some who insist -- anarchists perhaps -- that there must be no such rules at all. That's not how any society operates. 

So, we want some method of deciding, some rubric by which we can judge, which things need to be regulated and by whom? That second part -- the “who does it?” -- is as important as the first. 

In terms of what must be regulated the dividing line is perhaps somewhere between which side of the road to drive on and which side of the pavement to walk on. In the second that's something that can just be dealt with by people was they wander along even if firm rules might make it better. In the first case it's vital that there's an agreement and also enforcement of it -- however much Dhaka traffic tries to convince us there isn't. 

But the part of this which interests me is who makes the rules? There is something called consumer sovereignty, all those producers want access to the money in our wallets. We therefore have power over the producers -- the ability to grant or deny their access to our money. On the other hand there are also people who will happily lie, cheat, take our money and run for the hills.

So it's quite possibly not true that we the consumer can regulate all areas of life all the time. So, what's our rule? What's our rubric about who regulates? When is it correct that we, through our buying habits, can do that work and when do we need to bring in the bureaucrats, the law and the courts? 

We therefore have power over the producers -- the ability to grant or deny their access to our money

Obviously, there are those who will always say that second -- have a rule about everything all the time. Once we've put mothers in law to one side we can have a more realistic argument. For there will always be inefficiencies in the government regulating -- therefore we only want to do that when the benefits are greater than the costs of those inefficiencies.

The answer lies in how often we buy that thing? A consumer purchase that we make daily or perhaps monthly is something we end up with a lot of experience of. And if tens of millions of us are doing it  daily or weekly then that's an awful lot of regulatory power. Soap that doesn't lather, toothpaste that turns teeth black, bread made of sawdust, rice full of weevils pretty quickly disappears from the market.

Sure, it's not desirable that any of those things happen even once but simple market pressures will eliminate them quickly enough. Faster than any alternative method too. So, those things we can leave to the market -- to the producer's desire to clean out our wallets. 

But there are some things that we buy rarely. Even those that we buy only once or twice in a lifetime. Say, a mortgage. There are even things we buy very rarely but where the quality only becomes apparent many years into the future. Say, a pension or perhaps life insurance. We find out the quality there decades after that initial purchase. Those market processes -- that feedback of discovered quality in relation to price and promises -- take far too long to be a useful method of regulation of some sectors. 

So, things bought infrequently and with a long period of time before we find out how good they are need to be regulated by the state and bureaucracy. Perhaps heavily. Things that are ordinary daily purchases we can largely leave to the market, to us, to control.

Which brings us back to Sonali -- this is one of those things to be heavily regulated and checked by the state. Especially since the entire point of life insurance is to have a great big pile of money waiting for us at some unknown future date. We'd really very much prefer that the vermin don't get in and eat the banknotes over those years, you know?

 

Tim Worstall is a senior fellow at the Adam Smith Institute in London.

Top Brokers