Reliable Brokers
Online Investing
Alerts & Analysis
Easy Trading

THE LAST WORD

How crackdowns increase illegal activity

Understanding the limits of state suppression through the case of alcohol poisoning in Tamil Nadu

Update : 30 Jun 2024, 10:45 AM

An advantage of economics -- as with any other science that tries to uncover deeper meanings and causes -- is that once we've cracked the underlying causes of this particular thing here, then we've a tool that we can also apply to these other things over there. Of course, we've got to make sure that the underlying causes are the same before we apply our now new model. But that is the base aim here -- to uncover truths and causes that we can apply across many cases. 

The arak of Tamil Nadu

So let's look at the alcohol poisonings in Tamil Nadu, with half a hundred dead, many more poisoned, some of whom will go blind. This is, obviously, not good. But there are two levels of blame to assign here and the government is rightly blamed for one of them. Yes, the crook for the other one, but the government does have to bear some responsibility. 

The issue was with some arak. A distilled form of alcohol from either coconut water or sugarcane. One of those things that isn't difficult to make but is, unfortunately, difficult to make reliably well. The raw juice can just be left to ferment on its own -- it'll do that anyway if left alone. But to make it up into a hooch it needs to be distilled. Here lies the difficulty. Get it up to 60, 65C only and you'll poison everyone with methanol. Get it up to 75C and you'll get everyone happy drunk with ethanol. 

Now, if this is made commercially then this temperature regulation is the first thing money is spent upon so industrially produced booze is pretty safe in this sense. When it's made illegally out in the sticks, or in basements, then that temperature is rather harder to control and thus the frequent poisonings. The alleged perpetrator here has apparently racked up some 100 incidents of at least being investigated for hooch production. Even those experienced at it don't get it right all the time with primitive equipment. 

So someone made something potentially poisonous with bad equipment and so poisoned that half-century. They are clearly -- given the lack of a trial so far, potentially -- responsible for their actions. But the government is also responsible.

Go beyond what people will generally agree with and it simply doesn't work

For, it is actually distinctly cheaper to make booze and hooch in nice clean factories with good temperature controls. So, if the market was left alone we'd expect to see the good stuff out-compete the bad. Or, even, if the market were left un- or very lightly taxed, then we'd at least be able to insist that everyone test their production for methanol content -- before people try to drink it. We can even appeal to just good business sense. Anyone running a legal business would prefer to have a reputation for not poisoning people. 

Booze has been variously legal and illegal in Tamil Nadu over the decades. Every time it's been made illegal the number of methanol deaths rises. Then comes the reaction and so legality returns. Currently it's legal, but under state control and a significant reduction in retail outlets. So, more illegal distillation.

Restraining on restraint

The larger lesson for us to draw from this is that sure, maybe there are things we'd prefer. A sober population could even be one of them. But we've got to be very careful about stopping the people doing what the people want to do.

There are alternative methods of doling many things after all. Many of which are not under the control of the authorities. So, if we crack down -- too hard -- on the legal ways of doing something then people are going to go off and do things illegally. Which may well cause greater problems than what we were trying to solve in the first place. 

Of course, we don't intend to be light on murderers because people will just go off a murder spree. But it is true that cracking down on legal booze and hooch leads to people dying from badly made illegal stuff. Trying to tax people a lot leads to people working without telling the taxman. Making Indian onions illegal in Bangladesh (as sometimes happens with import licences) means people smuggle Indian onions.

That is, there's a definite limit to political and state power. Which is what you can convince a large enough portion of the population to actually do. Go beyond what people will generally agree with and it simply doesn't work. That's larger than just economics of course but it does still kill off many of the wilder plans people have for the economy. 


 Tim Worstall is a senior fellow at the Adam Smith Institute in London.

Top Brokers