Reliable Brokers
Online Investing
Alerts & Analysis
Easy Trading

Credit where it’s due

Does Fitch downgrading Bangladesh’s debt really matter?

Update : 09 Jun 2024, 03:02 AM

It's possible to worry that Fitch just downgraded Bangladesh's debt. It's also possible to -- and possibly more sensible to -- just shrug one's shoulders and say “ah, well” and just leave it at that. The downgrade was by one step and it didn't take the country's creditworthiness across any important boundary. BB- to B+ is from one level of “not investment grade” to another so there are no funds out there, no investors, who suddenly become more, or less, interested in buying our debt.

 

Two more technical details -- the first is that one of the three big agencies, Fitch, S&P, and Moody's, the action of any one doesn't really matter. It's two of the three, the average of the three, that does. Second, ratings agencies -- especially with reference to sovereigns (that means countries), don't really cause changes in the interest rates that must be paid. Rather, they reflect what has already happened. For a country borrowing money, a ratings agency is far more reactive to market processes than it is a cause of them.

 

So, you know, shrug.

 

That's not quite the end of it though. So, Fitch might just be reacting to markets, but why are markets acting that way to begin with? Prices are, after all, a signal -- they're information. We might not like the information but we'd better pay attention as the grand economic disasters of the 20th century all stemmed from the idea that we could ignore prices, disregard market messages.

 

There the message is a little more mixed. The government, the central bank, have already gone along, a bit at least, the road necessary to solve the problem. For, as reported, the problem is the “sustained weakening of the external buffers” which is a code for the foreign exchange reserves. There's a large flow of both in and out of the country. There are debts that have to be paid, short and long term. The outside world isn't hugely interested in receiving Taka in payment. So, how much foreign currency there is is important.

 

But how many of those debts can be paid in “non-Taka” money?

 

These reserves have been falling in recent months -- the last couple of years in fact. As this column has kept insisting this is because the authorities have been trying to prevent the price from changing too much. If you have an entirely free-market foreign exchange rate then it's impossible to have a shortage of foreign currency. People want to exchange more Taka for Dollars, then the price will change until everyone has done so. Sure, a falling rate here will mean imports are more expensive -- as also that exports will be cheaper. But it's a standard political thing that those who attempt to manage such things think a “strong” exchange rate is something important. When, in fact, it's a price just like any other.

 

As this column has also pointed out, get this really wrong and you end up like Sri Lanka, entirely going bust. It's gotten nowhere near that bad for us.

 

But, a high Taka/Dollar rate is what has been set. So, there's been that shortage of Dollars. This is the same thing as “weakening of the external buffers'.' Which leads to a lower credit rating. And then, however infinitesimally, a higher interest rate that must be paid on any new borrowings. Those price things will come out however we try to manipulate them.

 

Now, the central bank has stopped trying to fix the exchange rate. It's now allowing a “crawling peg” which means that it can change, but slowly. But this is the solution to the problem itself. If the foreign exchange rate is not fixed, if it's at market rates, then there can be no shortage of foreign exchange. Yes, the Taka/Dollar rate might change, but we can always get those Dollars. Therefore those external buffers aren't weakened and the bond rating isn't damaged.

 

The real lesson of all of this is that economies do add up. Yes, indeed, we can put our thumb on the scales at one point (say the exchange rate) but that will show up elsewhere -- here, as a lower credit rating and a higher interest rate to be paid on borrowings. Hey, maybe that's a good deal, maybe it's not; that's another discussion. But that intervention, the price-fixing, will absolutely turn up elsewhere and not necessarily to our overall benefit is wholly and absolutely true.   

 

Top Brokers