Paul Krugman, the Nobel laureate economist published a column in the New York Times in June, titled “Profits without production.”
As an ardent follower of Keynesian economics, Krugman, since the financial crisis started in 2008, has been arguing strongly for increasing public expenditure to increase the rate of GDP growth in the US, in a similar manner to John Maynard Keynes suggestions during the 1930’s Great Depression.
In his article, Krugman highlighted a few profitable IT companies such as Apple, Microsoft, and Yahoo, which have made huge profits by using their innovation and market power. Many such companies have large amounts of not-invested, idle cash. Apple alone has a cash balance of $145bn. Such companies have no need to invest their cash surplus.
According to Krugman, this is a show of their market power and dominance, a phenomenon which he has classified as “monopoly rent:” their balance sheets don’t so much represent return on investment, as reflect the value of their market dominance.
Similarly, many US banks, some of which had to be previously bailed out by the Federal Government during the crisis, are also sitting on large amounts of cash, even after they recovered their positions and paid back the public money. This reflects a market dominance similar to that of large IT companies.
While the government has tried to increase public investment in recent years, private companies have been doing the opposite. For Krugman, this lack of demand and investment has been the cause for the slow US recovery.
Since investment is a key factor in GDP growth, the lack of investment from companies inevitably lowers growth rates.
In this background, I would like to discuss why GDP growth rate in Bangladesh has slowed down to about 6%, when it was expected to grow by more than 7% during the last two years.
Slower implementation of ADP projects and the misuse of huge amounts of bank loans by some groups such as Hall-Mark, Destiny, and Bismillah have clearly played a part in dragging down GDP growth in Bangladesh.
Recent reports on the state owned banks indicate very large amounts of fake loans being taken out. Prior to that, there was the share market scam that siphoned billions out of the market.
As oligopolies, Bangladeshi banks tend to make hefty profits despite the scams. They made huge profits from the share market and real estate sectors during the 2010 bubble.
Despite a plethora of idle cash, unfortunately, the banks are not putting it to good, productive use. Banks in Bangladesh have very high spreads between borrowing and lending rates, which is often a strong deterrent for investment.
The Bangladesh Bank has further been pressured into allowing banks to invest 25% of equity in the share market and another 30% in real estate. In a small size capital market, this combined ratio should not exceed 10-15 %.
All of these add up to a gloomy economic outlook, along with the political crisis and hartals, that puts downward pressure on economic growth.
The recent budget has reduced relative allocation for education and health sectors and put more money into mega projects such as the Padma Bridge, which may or may not even get started. Even if it gets under way, the flow of cash to the local economy will be very small and slow at first; even when all hurdles are crossed and the project starts, there is no doubt that it will take several years for the bridge to be use-able.
On the bright side, we have seen growth in the past decade reduce the poverty level of those living in the most abject conditions to below 30%.
The question we may now raise is: If the financial scams had not occurred, could we have perhaps reduced poverty levels further?
The answer is an obvious yes. 1% increase in GDP can mean employment to about 20 million people.
However, under the present situation , attaining the target growth of 7% will not be possible.
In this election year, this simply is bluffing the nation into a false sense of hope and achievement.
The real economy is starved of cash flow due to investment shortages from both the public and private sectors.
Exports may also grow at a slower rate after the Rana Plaza disaster where the negligence underlying the building collapse caused the death of over 1,100 workers.
Although European and US brands have undertaken commitments to help improve safety in the industry, this may not stop some overseas RMG buyers from shifting orders to other countries like Cambodia and India.
Attempts to diversify the market for Bangladeshi RMG products have been rather slow and the suspension of GSP by the US government has been a another blow for export prospects.
Considering all the above information it seems as if Bangladesh is set for a tough time in the coming years due to many of the events that took place during the current government’s tenure.
The main contributing factors that help raise the GDP of a nation are investment and net exports (the difference between a nation’s imports and exports); figures for both have shown a downward trend.
For a developing country like Bangladesh, failure of governance affects the lives of the poor more adversely than the affluent sections of the population.
Unless remedies are found for the problems undermining the Bangladeshi economy, and banks are able and willing to find more productive uses for their capital, it is highly unlikely that GDP growth rates will match the figures quoted by the government.



