Reliable Brokers
Online Investing
Alerts & Analysis
Easy Trading

THE LAST WORD

Should prices in construction be monitored?

Addressing these concerns necessitates a reevaluation of business models and a bold approach towards dismantling barriers to trade

 

Update : 07 Apr 2024, 01:48 AM

Economic analysis can be difficult at a large scale when looking at a whole economy. 167 million people, each doing their own thing -- a reasonable description of the economy of Bangladesh -- is just difficult to analyze. However, when we come down to analyzing the actions of some small group it's much, much easier.

 

The specific here is the construction industry in Bangladesh. They've: “demanded the formation of a monitoring agency to determine prices of construction materials and product quality.”

 

The claim is twofold. Firstly, that prices change and even that they become unmoored from international ones. Thus there should be something that settles what those prices should be. Also that the quality needs to be judged by someone. Secondly, that the business model currently being used doesn't deal with things like inflation in those costs of construction materials.

 

The short answer to the second complaint is, change your business model. What is really being said is that apartments are sold off-plan at fixed prices. But if the prices of construction materials change then the construction companies open themselves up to losses. To which the correct answer is, in fact, diddums. If you employ a contract structure that opens you to risk then that's your problem.

 

Sure, changing that contract structure might cause some problems, not changing it exposes the constructors to risks. But that's what capitalists are there for in an economy -- to carry risk. Yes, they get the profits if they get that risk/reward ratio right and they carry the losses if they don't. But sorry, you don't get those profits unless you're willing to also carry those losses should they occur for this is what the game is. 

 

It's the first complaint which is more interesting. So, yes, prices change. Domestic and international prices will change differently too -- supply and demand doesn't vary equally across geography. Well, it doesn't unless there's free trade across that geography so that the arbitrage (buying where it's cheap, shipping to sell where it's expensive) can take place and thereby equalize prices.

 

The problem we've got in Bangladesh -- well, let's start with the complaint of the constructors: “Many times it is seen that the price of imported raw material decreases, but the price of the product does not decrease in the country. But, if there is a little increase in the prices of those products, the price is increased significantly in the country.” Ok, so importers put up prices when international prices rise and don’t reduce them when they fall …

 

This is another of these easy economic questions to answer. There aren't enough people able to import construction materials. Prices that are fluid upwards and sticky downwards -- that's a signal that the suppliers have economic power in the market. Just observing that happening means that we can assume that someone, somewhere, has that power.

 

But who? The international market in construction materials is highly competitive. We can prove that easily enough, by the very thing being complained about -- the international price of construction materials sometimes falls. Prices are not sticky downwards. But, in contrast, the price of construction materials in Bangladesh is sticky downwards. Therefore the problem must be the boundary between the international and Bangladesh markets. Can't be anywhere else at all.

 

Here we have that other piece of convincing evidence. Trade of construction materials into Bangladesh is not free enough -- just as with the onions. If domestic prices do not fall when international ones do then there are too many trade restrictions. This is one of those things that is definitional -- prices will only not fall if someone has market and economic power to make sure they don't and that they don't means that someone has that market and economic power we don't want them to have.

 

So, just abolish all the restrictions of the movement of construction materials across the border and destroy that pricing power.

 

Whole economies are difficult to manage, we all agree there. Important things like trade, they're easy -- just don't manage them.

 

Tim Worstall is a senior fellow at the Adam Smith Institute in London.

Top Brokers