A useful guide to a successful economy is to not listen to the International Labour Organization (ILO) on how to have a successful economy. This isn't advice that is going to please the ILO, nor the sort of people who like to go to ILO conferences, but it's a good guide all the same.
The reason for this is a statement from the most recent ILO conference and meet in Bangladesh: “Bangladesh must formulate and implement an appropriate national wage policy on forecasting and comprehending inflation, as well as competitive pricing and wages, experts said at a program on Tuesday. Tuomo Poutiainen, country director of ILO for Bangladesh, said the country should also figure out, discuss, and establish a proper national wage system.” To which the answer is no.
We can have our desires about national wages be as high as possible. After all, the people of Bangladesh should be as well off as humanly possible. We can also have plans to create higher wages, things like let's have more economic development, let's grow the economy.
But having a plan and system for wages themselves isn't the right way to go about things. For wages are a derivative of that economic development. If Bangladesh becomes richer -- ie GDP rises -- then wages will rise. Simply because that's what rising GDP means. Every single taka of that national economy we're measuring as GDP is an income to someone. Because that's simply what we're measuring with GDP -- it's either all production, or all incomes, or all consumption, each of the three is equal to any one of the other two, by definition. So, if GDP rises then incomes must rise by exactly the same amount, by definition. Perhaps not each individual’s income, but certainly everyone’s income put together.
So, a plan to increase GDP -- more free markets, more foreign trade, better technology and rising productivity -- is a plan to raise wages.
But as I say, those wages are a product of the increase in national production. Targeting a wage system directly has a truly terrible track record over other countries and centuries. Because to try to have a “wage system” is to try to control the derivative rather than doing something about the underlying motive force of the system. And as any engineer will tell you, the way to control the outcome is not to try to control the product, but the production system which produces it.
The ILO -- like so many other parts of the UN -- think they have to have plans for each part of the production. Further, given that the ILO really is the international trade union movement, they think that concentrating upon the wages being paid is the way to have that successful economy. But that's not, in fact, how to get the growth which increases GDP at all.
At the extreme, this is as absurd as the old idea of trying to pull yourself up by your bootstraps. A richer country with a higher GDP will have higher wages -- that's what higher GDP means -- but that doesn't mean that higher wages will lead to an increase in GDP. In fact, it can mean the opposite -- if wages are “too high” then investment will fall and growth may stop.
It's entirely true that the government should have plans to do certain things. Defend the country, take care of the poor and incapable, some method of having a health service, try to beat climate change and all that. Things that are generally called public goods, things that it's very difficult or even impossible to do individually. But having a national plan for wages isn't one of those things, that's something that can be left entirely to the interaction of employers and would-be employees. Whatever the ILO says about it, that's really something we don't need.
Tim Worstall is a senior fellow at the Adam Smith Institute in London



