Publish : 17 Dec 2021, 11:09 AMUpdate : 17 Dec 2021, 11:09 AM
It is telling that the subtitle of the Indian edition of the book is India’s Secret War in East Pakistan. In stark contrast with the Americans, the Indian prime minister and her close confidants are shown as “coldly calculating strategists, even if their actions served a humane cause.”
That the government of Indira Gandhi handled a humanitarian crisis of unimaginable magnitude, set in a political tinderbox consisting of communal tensions and simmering radicalism, wrapped up in an international environment that was far from friendly, is something that is well understood from Sisson and Rose. Bass adds to this by showing that India started preparing for war not as a last resort, but from the early days of the crackdown.
That India might have invaded Pakistan even if the latter hadn’t bombed Indian airfields on December 3 does not, of course, change the fact that India bore a tremendous humanitarian burden. A substantial literature on humanitarian intervention has emerged since the Western involvement in the Balkans during the 1990s. Analysis of the Indian actions in 1971 in light of that literature would be an interesting read.
Equally interesting would be an analysis of the War in Bangladesh against the incipient globalization, not just in the economic domain of multinational corporations and cross-border trade and flows of hot money, but also in the sociopolitical sphere of the diaspora in the West of former imperial subjects, non-government organizations stepping in where the state didn’t exist and society failed to cope, new forms of politics based on individual rights challenging not just the heavy hand of the state but also age-old social oppressions, and sociocultural trends such as the counterculture, rock music, and pop art that used novel audiovisual technologies to percolate and ricochet activists’ ideas and actions around the world.
Each of these trends played a part in Bangladesh, both before and after 1971. For example, the East Bengali diaspora in London was not only crucial for raising international awareness of the Bangladesh cause and the relief efforts for the refugees in India, but during the previous decade they provided an educational environment for people like Rehman Sobhan, Moudud Ahmed, Shafiq Rehman, Kamal Hossain, and Fazle Hasan Abed to hone their ideas.
The last man would found the Bangladesh Rehabilitation Assistance Committee (Brac) after the War, which would eventually go on to become the world’s largest NGO. Others in this group were crucial in the formative years of the country, working in the economic bureaucracy and policymaking, media, and politics under successive governments.
Back in 1971, international awareness was raised not just in the corridors of foreign ministries and embassies. Through novel use of popular media, activists targeted Western public opinion directly. After all, the Concert for Bangladesh was the first benefit event of this kind in history! Bob Dylan or the Beatles, and Che Guevara or Chairman Mao for that matter, weren’t exactly unknown to the East Pakistani youth, and the spirit of the soixante-huitard was very much echoed in their own uprising from a couple of years earlier against the Ayub Khan regime.
It wasn’t just the famous and the glamorous who clamoured for an end to the atrocities in Bangladesh. Fascinating recent work by Rachel Stevens of Melbourne University, for example, shows that individuals in suburban Australia, with little in common with the victims of the War, spearheaded a groundswell of activism independent of the Australian government effort, foreshadowing anti-Apartheid movements of the 1970s and 1980s and the climate activism of our own time.
Global trends of diaspora, NGO, pop culture, and citizen activism are mentioned by Srinath Raghavan, a New Delhi based scholar, in 1971: A Global History of the Creation of Bangladesh. The book might be considered a bit of a misnomer in the sense that Raghavan doesn’t delve into any of these global -- that is, trends and developments not directly pertaining to, or above and beyond, nations and states -- dimensions. Rather, notwithstanding the name, his focus is on the international -- that is, matters concerning and actions of nation-states -- context of 1971.
Ekattor-er boiguli
It is telling that the subtitle of the Indian edition of the book is India’s Secret War in East Pakistan. In stark contrast with the Americans, the Indian prime minister and her close confidants are shown as “coldly calculating strategists, even if their actions served a humane cause.”
That the government of Indira Gandhi handled a humanitarian crisis of unimaginable magnitude, set in a political tinderbox consisting of communal tensions and simmering radicalism, wrapped up in an international environment that was far from friendly, is something that is well understood from Sisson and Rose. Bass adds to this by showing that India started preparing for war not as a last resort, but from the early days of the crackdown.
That India might have invaded Pakistan even if the latter hadn’t bombed Indian airfields on December 3 does not, of course, change the fact that India bore a tremendous humanitarian burden. A substantial literature on humanitarian intervention has emerged since the Western involvement in the Balkans during the 1990s. Analysis of the Indian actions in 1971 in light of that literature would be an interesting read.
Equally interesting would be an analysis of the War in Bangladesh against the incipient globalization, not just in the economic domain of multinational corporations and cross-border trade and flows of hot money, but also in the sociopolitical sphere of the diaspora in the West of former imperial subjects, non-government organizations stepping in where the state didn’t exist and society failed to cope, new forms of politics based on individual rights challenging not just the heavy hand of the state but also age-old social oppressions, and sociocultural trends such as the counterculture, rock music, and pop art that used novel audiovisual technologies to percolate and ricochet activists’ ideas and actions around the world.
Each of these trends played a part in Bangladesh, both before and after 1971. For example, the East Bengali diaspora in London was not only crucial for raising international awareness of the Bangladesh cause and the relief efforts for the refugees in India, but during the previous decade they provided an educational environment for people like Rehman Sobhan, Moudud Ahmed, Shafiq Rehman, Kamal Hossain, and Fazle Hasan Abed to hone their ideas.
The last man would found the Bangladesh Rehabilitation Assistance Committee (Brac) after the War, which would eventually go on to become the world’s largest NGO. Others in this group were crucial in the formative years of the country, working in the economic bureaucracy and policymaking, media, and politics under successive governments.
Back in 1971, international awareness was raised not just in the corridors of foreign ministries and embassies. Through novel use of popular media, activists targeted Western public opinion directly. After all, the Concert for Bangladesh was the first benefit event of this kind in history! Bob Dylan or the Beatles, and Che Guevara or Chairman Mao for that matter, weren’t exactly unknown to the East Pakistani youth, and the spirit of the soixante-huitard was very much echoed in their own uprising from a couple of years earlier against the Ayub Khan regime.
It wasn’t just the famous and the glamorous who clamoured for an end to the atrocities in Bangladesh. Fascinating recent work by Rachel Stevens of Melbourne University, for example, shows that individuals in suburban Australia, with little in common with the victims of the War, spearheaded a groundswell of activism independent of the Australian government effort, foreshadowing anti-Apartheid movements of the 1970s and 1980s and the climate activism of our own time.
Global trends of diaspora, NGO, pop culture, and citizen activism are mentioned by Srinath Raghavan, a New Delhi based scholar, in 1971: A Global History of the Creation of Bangladesh. The book might be considered a bit of a misnomer in the sense that Raghavan doesn’t delve into any of these global -- that is, trends and developments not directly pertaining to, or above and beyond, nations and states -- dimensions. Rather, notwithstanding the name, his focus is on the international -- that is, matters concerning and actions of nation-states -- context of 1971.
Jyoti Rahman is a reader. He writes about what he reads at www.jrahman.substack.com.