Publish : 12 Dec 2021, 02:02 AMUpdate : 12 Dec 2021, 02:02 AM
Over a decade ago, upon hearing about an upcoming trip to Dhaka, a friend invited me to an event. “Great, that’s about the same time Meherjaan will be released, and you must come to the premiere.”
“Meherjaan?”,I asked, not knowing anything about the big screen love story starring Jaya Bachchan and Victor Banerjee set in 1971. As it happened, family commitments meant I couldn’t attend the party.
People who did attend, however, were probably not prepared for the backlash from the Bangla blogosphere. Director Rubaiyat Hossain had portrayed the ultimate effrontery: A Bengali girl falling in love with a Pakistani soldier. Didn’t she -- both the eponymous character and the director -- know that there was a war going on?
Of course, the sound and the fury around Meherjaan were mild compared to the reaction to Sarmila Bose’s Dead Reckoning: Memories of the 1971 Bangladesh War.
Whereas the movie was fiction, the book was a piece of scholastic research. Bose, an Oxford academic, questioned the fundamental Bangladeshi narratives around the pre-planned, West Pakistgan originated nature of the genocide -- in fact, that a genocide happened at all.
Instead of meeting Bose’s assertions intellectually, many Bengali Studies scholars engaged in casual, social media attacks. The exceptions were Akhtaruzzaman Mandal, Nayanika Mookherjee, Dina Siddiqui, Afsan Chowdhury, Urvashi Butalia, and Naeem Mohaiemen.
The essay for the Economic and Political Weekly and follow-up response to Bose’s reply in the same journal by Mohaiemen, a Columbia anthropologist, are the most effective refutation of Bose’s thesis to date.
In the past decade, a number of books have appeared on Bangladesh’s Liberation War. This series covers three volumes focusing on the war from within the lens of conflict studies and great game maneuvering -- by Garry J Bass, Srinath Raghavan, and Salil Tripathi.
Amid the ritual commemoration of the 50th anniversary of Victory Day, these books -- both reading what they cover and discussing what they miss -- are useful for a more nuanced understanding of the events that led to the country’s foundation.
Of course, this series is by no means an exhaustive literature review on 1971. Some key books and work on particular aspects of the creation of Bangladesh -- economic causes and consequences, refugee flows and communal and ethnic dimensions, gender violence -- are not explored in the series, mainly because these are not the focus of Bass, Raghavan, and Tripathi. However, in reviewing these three books, other relevant works on 1971 are also discussed.
Most reviews of non-fiction have an element of -- the author covered XYZ, but missed ABC. For example, in his review of these new books in a subsequent essay for WDW Review (The Ginger Merchant of History), Mohaiemen concludes that -- “History’s “ginger merchant” was far more crucial in the build up and conduct of this war than is acknowledged…”
Ginger merchant -- adar byapari -- is the proverbial Bengali small trader who is supposedly uninformed about the ocean liners that symbolize the global capital and everything that is dictated by it.
In the context of 1971, Mohaiemen contends that “… the radical leftist guerilla, or the desperate peasant fighter, are the ginger merchants who constituted turbulent street forces that made crucial differences to the fateful negotiations”that preceded the War.
What any review considers to be missing tells us as much about the reviewer as it does about what is being reviewed. This review is not immune from the tendency to state what might be missing from the books.
Nonetheless, to keep the discussion focused, I am going to explore two questions: What does the author propose to tell us that we wouldn’t have known from the existing literature; and does the author in fact manage to tell us what he proposes?
Ekattor-er boiguli
Over a decade ago, upon hearing about an upcoming trip to Dhaka, a friend invited me to an event. “Great, that’s about the same time Meherjaan will be released, and you must come to the premiere.”
“Meherjaan?”, I asked, not knowing anything about the big screen love story starring Jaya Bachchan and Victor Banerjee set in 1971. As it happened, family commitments meant I couldn’t attend the party.
People who did attend, however, were probably not prepared for the backlash from the Bangla blogosphere. Director Rubaiyat Hossain had portrayed the ultimate effrontery: A Bengali girl falling in love with a Pakistani soldier. Didn’t she -- both the eponymous character and the director -- know that there was a war going on?
Of course, the sound and the fury around Meherjaan were mild compared to the reaction to Sarmila Bose’s Dead Reckoning: Memories of the 1971 Bangladesh War.
Whereas the movie was fiction, the book was a piece of scholastic research. Bose, an Oxford academic, questioned the fundamental Bangladeshi narratives around the pre-planned, West Pakistgan originated nature of the genocide -- in fact, that a genocide happened at all.
Instead of meeting Bose’s assertions intellectually, many Bengali Studies scholars engaged in casual, social media attacks. The exceptions were Akhtaruzzaman Mandal, Nayanika Mookherjee, Dina Siddiqui, Afsan Chowdhury, Urvashi Butalia, and Naeem Mohaiemen.
The essay for the Economic and Political Weekly and follow-up response to Bose’s reply in the same journal by Mohaiemen, a Columbia anthropologist, are the most effective refutation of Bose’s thesis to date.
In the past decade, a number of books have appeared on Bangladesh’s Liberation War. This series covers three volumes focusing on the war from within the lens of conflict studies and great game maneuvering -- by Garry J Bass, Srinath Raghavan, and Salil Tripathi.
Amid the ritual commemoration of the 50th anniversary of Victory Day, these books -- both reading what they cover and discussing what they miss -- are useful for a more nuanced understanding of the events that led to the country’s foundation.
Of course, this series is by no means an exhaustive literature review on 1971. Some key books and work on particular aspects of the creation of Bangladesh -- economic causes and consequences, refugee flows and communal and ethnic dimensions, gender violence -- are not explored in the series, mainly because these are not the focus of Bass, Raghavan, and Tripathi. However, in reviewing these three books, other relevant works on 1971 are also discussed.
Most reviews of non-fiction have an element of -- the author covered XYZ, but missed ABC. For example, in his review of these new books in a subsequent essay for WDW Review (The Ginger Merchant of History), Mohaiemen concludes that -- “History’s “ginger merchant” was far more crucial in the build up and conduct of this war than is acknowledged…”
Ginger merchant -- adar byapari -- is the proverbial Bengali small trader who is supposedly uninformed about the ocean liners that symbolize the global capital and everything that is dictated by it.
In the context of 1971, Mohaiemen contends that “… the radical leftist guerilla, or the desperate peasant fighter, are the ginger merchants who constituted turbulent street forces that made crucial differences to the fateful negotiations” that preceded the War.
What any review considers to be missing tells us as much about the reviewer as it does about what is being reviewed. This review is not immune from the tendency to state what might be missing from the books.
Nonetheless, to keep the discussion focused, I am going to explore two questions: What does the author propose to tell us that we wouldn’t have known from the existing literature; and does the author in fact manage to tell us what he proposes?
Jyoti Rahman is a reader. He writes about what he reads at www.jrahman.substack.com.