Reliable Brokers
Online Investing
Alerts & Analysis
Easy Trading

For the people?

Update : 12 Dec 2021, 01:52 AM

In 2019, I wrote a dissertation on the question of whether democracy was in retreat. For my research, I had to look at the rankings of Freedom House, the Bertelsmann Foundation, and the Economist Intelligence Unit. 

On the eve of Joe Biden’s Summit for Democracy, the President of Freedom House Michael J Abramowitz wrote an Op-Ed in The Washington Post in which he states that “democracy appears to be steadily losing ground against authoritarianism.” He referred to a Freedom House report “documenting 15 consecutive years of decline in political rights and civil liberties worldwide.” 

Joe Biden says that “No democracy is perfect, and no democracy is ever final. Every gain made, every barrier broken, is the result of determined, unceasing work.” For Biden and many of us around the world, whether on the right or left, the defining question of our time is whether democracies can deliver better results for the people than autocracies.

This is also an existential question for Bangladesh. Our country was founded out of a struggle for democracy in 1971. Much like the United States, Bangladesh was born in a war against tyranny. 

Like America, Bangladesh cherishes the ideals of its revolutionary War of Independence. The territorial boundary of Bangladesh was also established as the result of a democratic mandate in the British Raj. 

Yet, after independence, Bangladesh has been at its best a dysfunctional democracy and at its worst an outpost of autocracy. We are still aiming for course correction. 

Our political culture -- replete with muscle power and corruption -- has no appetite for debating policy. Instead, we are stuck with the ghosts of the past. Lawmaking and policymaking have been left to discreet mandarins. 

If you want to know why Bangladesh wasn’t invited to Biden’s Summit for Democracy, look no further than the Freedom in the World report published by Freedom House. 

The methodology is divided between political rights and civil liberties. The section on political rights is sub-divided into the electoral process; political pluralism and participation; and the functioning of government. 

This includes questions on whether national lawmakers were elected in free and fair elections or whether national lawmakers can freely vote in a legislature. On both counts, Bangladesh does not fare well due to controversial elections and the constitution’s restriction on the voting rights of MPs. 

You also have to look at the composition of parliament. The makeup of the current parliament is dominated by the ruling party amidst a feeble opposition. A genuine democracy does not have a parliament with this kind of makeup. 

The section on civil liberties is sub-divided into freedom of expression and belief; freedom of association; rule of law; and personal autonomy and individual rights. 

On freedom of expression, Bangladesh’s score has gravely deteriorated in recent years. Bangladesh fares relatively well in terms of personal autonomy and individual rights like property rights and freedom of movement. 

Many countries perceived to be on a path of democratization were not invited. Ethiopia and Sudan didn’t make the list. Long-standing American allies with elected governments like Turkey and Singapore also didn’t make the list. 

Bangladesh’s government, political parties and civil society organizations should analyze the Freedom House methodology for improving governance. Improving our rankings will go a long way in putting Bangladesh on a sustainable path of multiparty democracy. 

Perhaps, we can begin with an acknowledgement from both the Awami League and BNP that mistakes have been made and it is time for course correction. Millions of Bangladeshis have grown up between 1990 and 2014 which was a period of turbulent multiparty democracy and caretaker governments. 

Millions more have grown up since 2014 seeing the dominance of one party. We need policy-oriented, constructive, and competitive politics which respects a peaceful and cyclical transfer of power. 

This is about good governance. We cannot uphold our national interests if we fail in good governance.  

Umran Chowdhury works in the legal field. 

Top Brokers