Reliable Brokers
Online Investing
Alerts & Analysis
Easy Trading

All the elections we remember

We will now sit back and wait --- to see how the next election goes. The world is watching

Update : 06 Jul 2023, 08:55 AM

As we move toward a new exercise of the franchise at the end of this year or early the next, the mind travels back to all those times when elections, or talk about them, dominated discussions in homes and in public squares. It makes sense to reflect on them, given that we in Bangladesh have historically been an election-oriented people.


There are all the memories of elections in our part of the world. In the interest of history, it is only proper that we recall them and the ramifications thrown up by them. The very first election following the creation of Pakistan in 1947 took place on a provincial basis in East Bengal in March 1954. A discredited ruling Muslim League was routed by a united front (Jukto Front) led by Moulana Abdul Hamid Khan Bhashani, Sher-e-Bangla AK Fazlul Huq and Huseyn Shaheed Suhrawardy. Of the 309 seats in the provincial assembly, the front romped home with 223. 


The central authorities in Karachi were obviously unhappy with the results and set about maneouvering to have the new government, led by Chief Minister Fazlul Huq, removed. It was a job they did ruthlessly and brazenly two months later, in May 1954. The ministry was dismissed under Section 92-a. 


The history of elections in our part of the world, especially that concerning Pakistan and Bangladesh (remember, they were one country once upon a time), has never been of a comforting kind. At times there have been all the comic situations that left us all greatly amused and our interest in politics a trifle more aroused. For myself, I recall a day in 1964. That was the day when 80,000 Basic Democrats, under Field Marshal Ayub Khan's concept of democracy, were elected in East and West Pakistan. In Quetta, Balochistan, the candidate my father had voted for lost. 


But the triumphant nominee had no way of knowing that, did he? So he and his supporters, in a big procession, paraded the streets and at a point stopped before our house. Full-throated slogans of "Haq sahib zindabad" and "Mashriqi-Maghribi Pakistan Bhai Bhai" were raised. "Haq sahib" was, of course, my father. He, in his rather naughty way, acknowledged the greetings of the victorious man's campaigners.

In late 1964, as Pakistan prepared for its presidential election, again under the Basic Democracy system, it was interesting to read of the rousing receptions Fatima Jinnah, sister of Pakistan's founder Mohammad Ali Jinnah, was getting in East Pakistan. Everywhere she went, she was accompanied by an indefatigable Sheikh Mujibur Rahman, who in time would make his own impact on history as Bangabandhu. 

Miss Jinnah was the candidate of the Combined Opposition Parties (COP) against Ayub and it looked as if she would be able to unseat the military ruler. In the end, despite her very strong showing in the east, her defeat in the west ensured that Ayub would win. The presidential election was held on January 2, 1965.

In the course of the election campaign, one important opposition figure, Khwaja Nazimuddin, once governor general and prime minister of Pakistan, passed away. Retired lieutenant general Azam Khan, who had been close to Ayub Khan and was one of the men involved in the imposition of martial law in 1958 and subsequently governor of East Pakistan until he fell out with the president, went around the country soliciting support for Miss Jinnah. At one point, Ayub made a crude comment on Azam: "Uss ke demagh me bhusa bhara hua hai (there is chaff in his brain)". I recall that many Pakistanis thought it was a witty remark, which it was not.

In 1968, there were many people in the western part of Pakistan who were quite excited by the prospect of a Bhutto presidency. You see, Zulfikar Ali Bhutto had left the Ayub cabinet in mid-1966, formed the Pakistan People's Party in late 1967 and in early 1968 informed Pakistanis that he meant to challenge his former mentor at the next presidential election scheduled for 1970. 

The news even made it into TIME magazine. But, of course, there would be no Ayub-Bhutto contest since events were soon to overtake Pakistan. But let us remind ourselves that sometime in the early 1960s, when Bhutto was secretary general of Ayub Khan's Convention Muslim League and Pakistan's foreign minister, he proposed in public that Ayub Khan be declared president of Pakistan for life. That was quintessential Bhutto for you. We know of the rest of the course his life was to take.

The December 1970 elections in Pakistan, its first and one that led to its break-up, were hugely exciting. In East Pakistan, Bangabandhu Sheikh Mujibur Rahman crisscrossed the province seeking support for his party's Six Points. While he described the elections as a referendum on the Six Points, many of his West Pakistani opponents, such as Khan Abdul Qayyum Khan, glibly told West Pakistanis that they had visited Dhaka and had found no support for Mujib and his party among Bengalis.

Bhutto went around preaching a curious mix of Islam, democracy and socialism. He was neither Islamic nor democratic nor a socialist. In the east, Moulana Bhashani proved mercurial yet once again when he decided to stay away from the elections. On December 4, a mere three days before the voting, he "declared" the "independence" of East Pakistan from the rest of the country.

The results of the elections stunned the Yahya Khan regime, which had been advised by military intelligence that the Awami League would not win enough seats (no more than sixty) to form a government, which in turn meant that all the other parties could together cobble a government into shape in Islamabad. Of course, that did not happen. And of course the regime and men like Bhutto refused to hand over power to the Bengalis. The result was disaster for Pakistan, propitious for the people of Bangladesh.

You could go on talking about elections all night long. In free Bangladesh, Khondokar Moshtaque lost the 1973 elections, but then things were maneouvred in a way that the loser eventually became the victor. Moshtaque was to repay the debt through engineering the bloodletting of August 1975. In February 1979, all the old collaborators of the Pakistan army took part in general elections, thanks to the machinations of General Ziaur Rahman. 

Shah Azizur Rahman, who had on behalf of the Yahya Khan junta defended Pakistan at the United Nations in 1971, took over as Bangladesh's prime minister. One of the first acts of the Ziaur Rahman regime was to have the notorious Indemnity Ordinance, put in place by the Moshtaque cabal to provide legal protection to Bangabandhu's assassins, incorporated in the fifth amendment to the constitution.

In 1986, the Awami League was left red-faced when it announced its intention of taking part in the elections called by the Ershad regime. It was supposed to compete for 150 parliamentary seats, with the Bangladesh Nationalist Party going for the remaining 150 seats. Sheikh Hasina and Khaleda Zia were to make simultaneous announcements, at the same time and from different places. In the event, the BNP backed out without warning. Later, it castigated the Awami League as a party that had legitimized Ershad's military government.

We have had parliamentary elections, warts and all, in 1991, 1996, 2001, 2008, 2014 and 2018. In 1978, General Ziaur Rahman defeated General MAG Osmany for the presidency. In 1981, Justice Abdus Sattar, who had served as Pakistan's chief election commissioner in 1970 and was later Bangladesh's vice president, defeated the Awami League's Dr Kamal Hossain, who had been law and foreign minister in Bangabandhu's government, at the presidential election. In 1988, the Ershad military regime, to its undying shame, permitted an assassin of Bangabandhu to take part in the presidential election. 

We will now sit back and wait -- to see how the next election goes. The world is watching.

Top Brokers