As the nation continues to mourn the 1127 lives lost and many more maimed, injured and disabled in the aftermath of the Rana Plaza tragedy, our collective focus is towards setting a path for a better way forward for the Ready Made Garments (RMG) industry. Not only does RMG account for $20bn of exports by revenue and almost 80% of exports from Bangladesh, it is critically responsible for the livelihoods of nearly 4 million people, many of whom are women, and the many millions more associated with the industry.
Understandably, the world has been watching the events unfold and has been keen to get involved. However, most importantly at this time, Bangladesh needs a domestic plan for its most important industry. It is in this context that a group of individuals, from various industries, sectors and civil society, with very varied backgrounds, came together to take a more holistic look at the situation, to collaborate with those both inside and outside the industry and to put together an inclusive reform plan.
The aim from the outset was not to apply blame but to come up with a plan that would move the whole industry forward and set it on a better path for future growth for the benefit of everyone. The resulting plan that has come out of this collaborative process is known as the “10-point plan.”
There are already a number of very good initiatives underway by the Government, BGMEA, ILO and foreign buyers. The 10-point plan doesn’t seek to replace these in any way but rather seeks to identify the synergy between them, to fill in any gaps remaining and then to look at measures necessary to build not only a safer but also a stronger industry.
Crucially, the outcome of implementation of a plan such as this would be to restore confidence around the world in garments made in Bangladesh. For those garments to be coming out of an industry that we are all proud to host and for the “Made in Bangladesh” label to be a mark of both affordable high quality as well as responsible and ethical sourcing.
Factory classification and compliance
Work is already underway to check structural integrity of all factory buildings but the 10-point plan suggests that we build on this to ensure an effective and wide-ranging audit of all RMG factories is carried out within a realistic but sensible timeframe. An independent body assisted by BGMEA/BKMEA, BUET/DUET, with a neutral “chair” forming a National Action Plan (NAP) could carry out this task.
In the future this independent body would need to be replaced with a long-term independent inspectorate for ongoing compliance monitoring. Creation of an independent inspectorate as a joint stakeholder initiative is central to the 10 point plan and to the creation of a safer and stronger RMG industry. The inspectorate would be set up in collaboration with the ILO or other agencies, including input from other health and safety inspectorates, as well as with input from foreign buyers. It is very important that this inspectorate is independent, set up with the collaboration of all stakeholders and is trusted by all stakeholders.
A simple classification process of Tier 1, Tier 2 and Tier 3 would be easily recognisable and ongoing audits should ensure that we never again see another Rana Plaza kind of disaster.
The Bangladesh Fire and Buildings Safety Accord launched in April at the ILO offices in Geneva and backed by many large buyers is a good start along the process of effective auditing. Sadly, since it is driven by the buyers, it applies only to factories which are supplying those buyers. For any accord to be truly effective, it needs to incorporate the whole industry and all factories. It would be good therefore to see the Bangladesh Fire and Buildings Safety Accord incorporated within the broader 10-point plan and be extended in such a way as to make it realistically effective.
Within the 10-point plan the Tier 3 factories, those with high or imminent risk and which need immediate remedial action, would have an action plan prepared and the audits carried out on the worst 1000 Tier 3 factories would be followed up by further rounds of inspection to ensure that all the action plan points are implemented.
Unless the problems with the worst factories in the industry are fixed, the whole industry will continue to be tainted with a reputation of poor safety and risky working conditions. At the same time, these factories cannot just be shut down. They employ workers who need jobs and provide production capacity for the country. It is a central part of the 10-point plan that these factories are dealt with fairly and with transparency; not with a culture of blame, but with a realistic and workable plan of action. That would bring the factories up to the standard required, thereby safeguarding jobs, maintaining production capacity and strengthening the “Made in Bangladesh” reputation.
BGMEA
The BGMEA is, of course, central to the reform of the RMG industry. They can play a complementary role in implementing self-monitoring, and ensuring and enforcing compliance through compulsory training programmes on worker rights, workplace safety, facility inspection and corrective steps so that compliance requirements go beyond a simple checklist and become a culture of good practice throughout the industry.
The 10-point plan suggests that all new factories coming into existence should be Tier 1 factories and that these would be audited by the independent inspectorate prior to getting BGMEA membership. Without BGMEA membership factories cannot export and so, through membership entry requirements, it will be possible in the future to ensure only factories which are compliant can join the industry.
Factory relocations and financing
The industry has grown over many years and the factories within it are of varying sizes and at various points in their business growth. There are many factories in Bangladesh which are located in purpose-built buildings and which are fully compliant.
However, there are many more which are in shared, multi-purpose or converted buildings: buildings which may not be fit for the purpose.
Of course, factory relocations, even in small numbers represent huge challenges, but they also represent a very real opportunity to reform the industry en masse and build a future Made-in-Bangladesh brand that is rooted in safety and compliance.
Factory relocations will require collaboration. It will require support from the government in terms of making land available, and provide financing options, infrastructure, and utilities, particularly gas lines, to those locations.
Potentially relocating 1000 or more factories will take some time and the 10-point plan indicates that this is possible within 4 years and will cost as much as $1bn. The financing could be provided by a combination of loans from multi-lateral and bi-lateral partners as well as local banks through a Government of Bangladesh RMG Transformation fund and a time-bound export tax, with the government providing relocation incentives under certain circumstances. There is already a precedent set for this type of funding structure with the IPFF which is administered by the Bangladesh Bank for lending in the energy sector.
For the workers
The minimum wage in Bangladesh was set in 2006 at Tk1,662 per month and was raised to Tk3,000 per month in 2010. It hasn’t been increased since but the Wage Board Committee under the Labour Ministry are currently looking at it. With inflation running at above 7% annually and inflation of essentials and staples often being much higher than that, there is clearly a need for a more regular and systematic review of the minimum wage.
However, there is also a need for the garments industry in Bangladesh to remain competitive. Mike Flanagan, a retail-sourcing consultant, stated that if Bangladesh raised its prices even 50 cents, the results would be devastating. “There won’t be four million garment-making jobs in Bangladesh,” he wrote in an e-mail. “There probably won’t be 4,000.”
The 10-point plan recommends linking the minimum wage to productivity because that is the only sustainable way to increase wages in real terms in any industry and country.
Trade unions are already present in the garments industry but it is often felt in this country that a workers’ participatory committee is a more effective way to resolve issues and enable collective bargaining. An additional entity could be BRIDGE which would include initiatives including setting up free schools for workers’ children, training centres to improve skills and give awareness training on rights and issues.
The addition of good practices such as these within the industry could encourage factories to affiliate with bodies like the United Nations Global Compact (UNGC) and be endorsed by international organisations.
The 10-point plan has been devised as a plan for Bangladesh by Bangladesh. While it looks to the buyers for collaboration on compliance, particularly in the development of a unified single compliance code for the country, it hasn’t asked the buyers to commit any funding as the Bangladesh Fire and Buildings Safety Accord has. To keep the industry strong and independent it is important that safety concerns are addressed and financed by Bangladesh and it is not the responsibility of the buyers to pay for this. It is the responsibility of the buyers to pay a fair price for a garment, not to negotiate an unrealistically low price for a garment on the one hand and then pay for safety considerations on the other.
We do however understand that consumers in particular, through retailers, are often interested to pay a little more for worker welfare. The creation of a worker welfare trust fund could be used as a provident or pension fund for workers and would be able to offer immediate financial assistance when something goes wrong. This is something that some buyers already have as part of their broader corporate social responsibility. The welfare fund could be jointly built by the manufacturers and the buyers.
Creating it as a separate fund would simply extend that principle and be demonstrable in annual reports to shareholders.
The longer term
The long-term growth in the industry and sustainability of higher wages requires moving up the value chain: increasing the design component, improving technology, and developing home-grown brands. The horrific tragedy at Rana Plaza has forced the Bangladesh garments industry to confront problems that have been festering in the industry for some years now. It has forged partnerships between the industry and civil society in the production of this plan alone, which haven’t previously happened before.
The scale of the tragedy is so devastating that on one thing we can all agree – we must do something to prevent this from ever happening again. But we can also take from this the opportunity that we can do more. We can set the foundations for a safer and stronger industry going forward, one on which the country can continue to grow and within which the people will prosper.
The full text of “The 10-Point Reform Roadmap for a Sustainable Bangladesh RMG Sector” can be read here: http://www.scribd.com/doc/144709575/RMG-Sector-10-Point-Plan.
RMG ACTion is a group comprising of Nazim Farhan Choudhury, Deputy Managing Director, Adcomm; Syed Faruque, CEO, Winners Creations Ltd; Rubana Huq, Managing Director, Mohammadi Group; Asif Ibrahim, Vice Chairman, Newage Group of Industries & UNESCAP Business Advisory Council Member; Ifty Islam, Managing Partner, Asian Tiger Capital Partners; Shariful Islam, Founder, Bangladesh Brand Forum; Saif Kamal, Head of Marketing and Communications, Dhaka Tribune; Masud Khan, Lawyer, Legal Circle & Director, Amadeyr Cloud Ltd; Dr Ahsan Mansur, Executive Director, Policy Research Institute; Samantha Morshed MBE, CEO, Hathay Bunano ps; Peer-jada Qureshi, Lawyer, UK.



