Reliable Brokers
Online Investing
Alerts & Analysis
Easy Trading

Benefitting from black money

Update : 12 Jun 2013, 06:12 PM

In his most recent budget the Finance Minister AMA Muhith took another stab at whitening what analysts claim is a vast, and unaccounted for, black economy.

With some estimates claiming that as much as 60% of the country’s GDP is in the black economy, this is a vast source of inefficiency with regard to the nation’s growth.

The choice of the real estate sector as the vehicle to do this was however ill informed and perhaps wasteful, if not harmful.

Real estate is in no need of a boost. Already the capital has land prices equivalent to cities such as London or New York, with many residents unable to afford to buy properties of their own.

Under Muhith’s plan owners of undeclared “black assets” can invest their money with no questions asked, in real estate for as little as, a one off tax of 10%.

Needless to say, most of those who would be investing probably already have a house, so we will not see a growth in new home owners, merely business men investing in a scarce asset, further inflating the price and thereby enriching those on the property ladder to the detriment of those who are not on it at all.

An area of construction that does need this inflow of capital is industrial building stock.

With the Prime Minister having said that as much as 90% of the industrial building stock may be non-compliant, upgrading existing factories is not only necessary to avoid more loss of life, it could also be a major economic boon.

Financing such upgrades is currently difficult; as the budget has made clear, lending is down as are imports. This suggests that whilst exports in the garments sector are robust, this is coming out of physical infrastructure that is not keeping apace.

With several state-owned banks moribund due to poor management and corruption, could three birds not be killed with one stone?

Instead of offering the amnesty for investment in real estate, a better solution would be to allow black-money holders to whiten their money by buying bonds from troubled state-owned banks.

The bonds would pay nothing but face value on maturity, but the amount returned would then be white. This capital, which costs the bank nothing, could then be made available to the garment sector at an extremely affordable rate. Everyone wins.

The factory owners could then be given a realistic time-frame to upgrade and make compliant all industrial building stock, financed by the banks selling bonds in exchange for black money.

The government could then have an open tender for construction companies to register to do the work of upgrading, in order that only registered, and thereby fully auditable, construction or engineering companies could undertake the work, thereby minimising corruption.

This could also enable a proactive approach to be taken with regards to spending on capital goods, which could improve the productivity of Bangladeshi garment factories. It could also enable the government to look at the most advantageous way of getting domestic firms to undertake essential work; the installation of compliant electrical infrastructure in factories, or other essential engineering work, for instance.

The broad scale of such a program would give rise to other possible benefits because it could well enhance the capacity of local firms to become more competitive in construction and engineering, in the medium to long term.

If the government guarantees and audits the process this could see huge amounts invested in two of the most productive areas of the economy: garments and construction.

Greater productivity in garments would help shore up the country’s largest export sector in the medium term, whilst the increased activity in the construction and engineering sectors, would help boost investment in the short term, assisting these segments of the economy, without needlessly inflating an all ready over-heated real estate sector.

With a potential $60bn floating around unaccounted for, it would not be unrealistic, if the scheme was well implemented, to net amounts more than or equivalent to that which is received in foreign direct investment (FDI) which stood at $1.7bn in 2012.  

Top Brokers