Reliable Brokers
Online Investing
Alerts & Analysis
Easy Trading

THE LAST WORD BY TIM WORSTALL

To pet or not to pet

What is the ulterior motive behind the new pet tax?

Update : 31 Dec 2022, 04:51 PM

Dhaka South City Corporation (DSCC) is to enforce its pet tax. 

The best way to understand this is through Northcote Parkinson's book “Parkinson's Law.”

The book started out as a comic essay for Punch magazine - he noted that if current trends continued then soon enough the Royal Navy would have more Admirals than ships, more bureaucrats than sailors. 

These have indeed come to pass of course.

Parkinson's Law - 70 odd years later can be taken as one true description and explanation of bureaucratic behaviour. 

And it's this which links to the DSCC's actions over pet licences. 

The aim and purpose of a bureaucracy is to increase the budget of the bureaucracy and the number of people employed by it. There is no other goal. 

For a bureaucracy has no measurable output, it has no customers who willingly pay for it. 

So, the only measure of it doing well is that it gains more money and more people to do even more next year. 

So, the aim of any bureaucracy is simply to grow - just like most other organisms in fact. 

Once we've got this idea firmly fixed in our minds, the DSCC action becomes entirely understandable. 

There's no merit to having pet or dog licences. 

It is true that my native Britain used to have them but we stopped four decades ago, on the very simple grounds that there was no benefit to having them. 

People paid for a licence which paid for the bureaucracy that collected the licence fee and checked that people had a licence. 

No further contribution to government revenues was made at all. The system merely covered its own costs even at the best of times. 

But it's exactly these things which make it the perfect bureaucratic plan. 

There's no observable output or benefit. 

All that the dog licence bureaucracy can claim is that all the people with dogs have licences. 

And that the fees for having a licence cover the cost of making sure that every dog has a licence. 

We've achieved nothing on any grand or large scale but we have created a bureaucracy which will employ people. 

We've also given bureaucracy its own funding source. So it is now entirely self-contained, achieves nothing but continues to exist.

This is bureaucratic nirvana, which is why the DSC is doing it, of course. 

It increases the number of people employed by DSCC and thus increases the importance of those who run the bureaucracy of DSCC, and achieves absolutely and entirely nothing else at all. 

This is where the tension comes in of course. 

We all have to do something - go to the offices and get our licence. 

We also have to pay Tk500 for the privilege. But we gain nothing from that privilege. No one is suggesting that there will be anything from this. Not even the bureaucrats. 

The only value that will arise is that pets will have licences. Or at least, that's true only if we ignore the motivation of the bureaucracy itself. 

From that viewpoint, this all makes perfect sense. 

What is society itself if it is not the very thing that bureaucracy feeds upon? 

How can anyone think that not having more bureaucrats would be a good idea? Which is that tension. 

The aim here, of the pet licences, is to provide more jobs for people in comfy offices and that's all it would provide. 

But this is to forget that jobs are a cost of getting something done. We might want that thing done, it might be good that the thing is done. 

But the jobs, the human labour, they're a cost of getting it done. This does mean that more jobs in comfy offices are not a good thing in themselves. 

They are a cost, obviously. This means that when someone proposes a scheme, we can see the jobs. 

But we have to ask, well, what are we getting for them? Or even, what are we getting from them - what's the output of this work, these jobs, that offsets the costs of our having to pay these salaries? 

When the answer is simply that we must pay for the licences so as to pay the costs of the system which issues licences, well, at that point we can tell them to go chase their own tails, can't we? 

Or, at least we should.

Tim Worstall is a senior fellow at the Adam Smith Institute in London

Top Brokers