Some local and overseas banks secretly collaborated to fix the rate of the South African Rand against the US Dollar.
The South African Competition Commission came to know about this and initiated an investigation.
During May 2015, their investigation found involvements of Citigroup, Nomura, Standard Bank, Investec, JP Morgan, BNP Paribas, Credit Suisse Group, Commerzbank AG, Standard New York Securities Inc., Macquarie Bank, Bank of America Merrill Lynch (BAML), ANZ Banking Group Ltd, Standard Chartered Plc and Barclays Africa (Absa), part of the Barclays Plc.
The commission alleged that the banks colluded with each other on prices for bids, offers and bid-offer spreads for spot trades in relation to currency trading involving the Dollar and the Rand.
Following this, the commission found that the banks directly and indirectly manipulated trade of the Dollar/Rand currency pair in relation to bids, offers, bid-offer spreads, spot exchange rate and the terms and/or margin of executing client orders at the fix.
The commission fined 10% of those banks' South African revenues.
Moreover, in May the following year, the commission announced that price fixing (both buying and selling prices), market division and tender collusion between competitors became criminal offences in terms of section 73A(1) to (4) of the Competition Act, 2009).
The South African Competition Act also prohibited direct or indirect price-fixing between competitors.
It also prohibited information exchange between competitors which gave rise to anti-competitive conduct.
The Bangladesh context
There are about 10 million Bangladeshi expatriates working in Middle Eastern countries.
They are a major source of foreign currency for the nation.
There are some exchanges in those countries which collect foreign exchange from expatriates and send them back to Bangladesh.
According to Bangladesh Foreign Exchange Dealers Association (Bafeda), these exchanges in other countries are making more profit than usual due to the lack of a uniform exchange rate in case of bringing remittance Dollars.
Bafeda has information that currently 90% of remittances come into the country through domestic and foreign exchanges, which set the rate for selling remittance Dollars to the banks.
It decided to set a Dollar rate on behalf of the country's banks to collect Dollars from the exchanges at a reasonable price, which they term "one country, one exchange rate."
If the rate is implemented, all the banks will buy Dollars from the exchanges at a fixed price.
As a result, competition among banks will decrease, and the Dollar market will stabilize.
A source present at the meeting said the bank officials at the meeting signed a letter of consent to accept these decisions.
In view of this decision, Bafeda issued a letter to hold a meeting with the Bangladesh Bank and the Association of Bankers, Bangladesh (ABB) on September 7 earlier this year with the central bank governor.
The governor tasked the ABB and Bafeda with setting the Dollar exchange rate.
On the other hand, Bangladesh Bank on September 8 claimed that it would allow the market, in relation to demand and supply, to fix the exchange rate of the US Dollar against the Taka.
As the demand for Dollars increased due to the ongoing crisis, amid contraction of the area of Dollar collection, the banks' interest in collecting Dollars increased.
Competition among them also increased.
Utilizing the opportunity, the exchanges are setting the Dollar price much higher than normal for their convenience.
Consequently, the banks are also selling the Dollar at a high price.
In a recent meeting, Bafeda decided to reduce the existing fixed rate of the Dollar.
Bangladesh's remittance inflow - which is already showing a steady decline - could continue on this downward trend in the coming months as banks decided to lower the Dollar rate in foreign exchanges from November 1, economists fear.
There is no dearth of evidence of fixation of the price of currency by trade associations.
A source present at the meeting said the bank officials at the meeting signed a letter of consent to accept these decisions.
The Competition Commission Act 2012, under sections 3 and 4, has jurisdiction on most economic activities except involving national security issues and goods and services not open for the private sector.
The banking sector is open to the private sector.
The fixation of currency exchange rate is prohibited under the BCC Act, and the commission may take action against the association for fixing the rate of the Dollar.
The banks in South Africa had colluded in a secret meeting, but the Bafeda had decided in an open meeting with consent from the governor of Bangladesh Bank and issued a press release to the stakeholders.
The acts of Bafeda and ABB are illegal and the decision encourages expatriates to use the hundi channel to get a fair price of their hard earned foreign currency.
Bangladeshi authorities have allowed banks to make profit keeping the rate below the set price determined by market mechanism.
Unfortunately, the legal experts and economists of the country remained silent except a few about the consequences of tampering currency rates.
IMF and World Bank also repeatedly requested for introducing floating currency rates to bring optimum amount of foreign currency through banking channels.
The Bangladesh Competition Commission may take up the issue with stakeholders to stop manipulating the exchange rate and increase inflow of the foreign currency in this crisis period of the nation.
It is known that BCC has shortage of manpower and other infrastructure to investigate case market manipulation, but in this case the evidence is available with Bangladesh and others.
Bafeda has decided to set a Dollar rate on behalf of the country's banks to collect Dollars from the exchanges at a fixed price, under the pretext of "One Country, One Exchange Rate."
All the banks will buy Dollars from the exchanges at this “fixed price.”
According to them this collusive agreement will reduce competition among banks, and the Dollar market will reportedly stabilize.
This action is illegal and has a very bad impact on our currency market.
The author is a legal economist and also non-government adviser at the Bangladesh Competition Commission. He can be reached at [email protected]



