Subjecting children to the scourge of corporal punishment in schools is wrong, totally unnecessary, and completely without justification. There are no circumstances that justify corporal punishment.
If anyone needs to be given corporal punishment, it’s the teachers themselves for failing in their duties to the child, the school and the nation.
I have taught at different schools in Bangladesh and overseas for over 30-years. I’m now retired, and thanks to Almighty Allah for his loving guidance, I have a clear conscience. I know full well how frustrating and annoying it is to have students who misbehave and disrupt on-going lessons. It can be irritating at the very least and hair-pulling frustrating at the worst, but that is still not a justification for corporal punishment and going to the extreme of beating a child for some meaningless, trivial error or misdemeanour.
Throughout my career, from day one, I’m proud to say, I have never subjected a pupil to corporal punishment. Although I will admit the temptation presented itself often. To have done so, knowing it to be wrong, would have meant that I had failed as a teacher, being unable to control a group of youths much far junior to me in experience; injured my dignity as a person who abhors violence of any degree in society; and perhaps damage the child for life, mentally or physically, in the process. If I had done such a despicable act I may have even aided in creating a social monster or “time bomb.”
As much as one may be tempted, corporal punishment simply doesn't work. I have observed many teachers of questionable compassion and character over the years in Bangladesh and learned from their sometimes-horrific mistakes.
I believe that corporal punishment teaches children violence as the solution to problems and that might is right. That is not a lesson a schoolteacher should be imparting to the pupils. There are enough violent people in the present generation without creating a whole new generation of violence-seekers and violence-makers. We must stop the decay in society that we are witnessing almost daily in our universities and streets, and now is as good a time as any to begin.
While corporal punishment might seem like a quick-fix solution at first, it isn’t. It just creates more problems, not necessarily in the classroom, but in society. The teacher may even think he’s won both the battle and war, with his quick-fix therapy, but only time will tell if s/he’s created a human time-bomb that might explode in the home or society with devastating results in the years that follow.
Other forms of classroom management are less obvious and take longer to show results, but are well worth the effort in order to teach young people proper behaviour, respect for themselves, respect for society, and those trying to help them, alongside the information taught.
This does not mean that you let the students run riot and do whatever they want in the classroom. That would neither be good for them or the other students who are watching and learning from bad behaviour and mimicking it.
There are ways to control the class using other methods, humane methods, methods conducive to learning. Sometimes there are days when nothing seems to work and your only option is to remove the offending person from the classroom and allow him to cool off and think about his actions, but not to hit him ... never to hit him. The Americans call this a "time-out." The youth is given time to ponder and think about their actions and it’s very effective. The pupil becomes his own judge and jury.
Teachers should be professional and adult in their approach; above taunting, teasing, and engaging in any form of verbal or physical abuse of any kind and never lowering themselves to the level of children's schoolyard/street methods of sorting out problems, culminating in black eyes, sore limbs, bloodied noses or shattered dignities.
It is important to ensure non-violent, non-threatening behaviour; simple procedures like having clear classroom rules for conduct and being very consistent in policing that (without using violence or verbal abuse) is the way to go.
Each year, when I used to receive a fresh batch of pupils to teach, I spent the first few minutes reading and discussing the rules of my classroom with them, and what to expect as a result of breaking these rules. I created a sort of agreement … a partnership … an understanding, for the betterment of all.
It worked like a charm and never let me down. Getting students to participate in determining the rules helps enormously in fostering good discipline; it also fosters better bonding between teacher and pupil. It’s true democracy in action.
When an "offence" was committed, it was viewed not only as an offence against me (the teacher), but against all present. Most times I did not even need to become involved, other pupils spoke out, reminded the offender of the rules, and this resolved the problem amicably. If you have the respect of the pupils they themselves will reinforce that respect.
Another strategy I employed was giving the offending student something to do, something to occupy his mind and distract him from bad behaviour. The vast majority of behaviour problems are a simple case of boredom. The pupil might be very bright and accomplish the task at hand much quicker than the rest and become bored by sitting still and twiddling his thumbs while waiting for others to finish.
In summary, corporal punishment achieves nothing good, and guarantees bad. As there is now a law in Bangladesh banning corporal punishment in schools, headmasters would be doing their school and country a great service by bringing to book and sacking the offenders who bring this kind of disgrace to our profession.
I have proven to myself that corporal punishment is without justification under all circumstances, totally unnecessary, and anyone with a conscience should know that it’s wrong.



