Start ups aren't everything to an economy -- but in the long run they're pretty much everything. Thus this newspaper's approval of Agrotech is entirely correct. That start-up is aiming at improving conditions in the agriculture sector. Such start-ups will indeed be our agents of change in the economy over time and that's their importance.
That opening line is, of course, something between a repeat and an echo of Paul Krugman's line about productivity not being everything, but in the long run it's pretty much everything as a determinant of living standards. The link being that it's start-ups which improve productivity.
This doesn't accord with the way most of us think about these matters. Large companies get better at what they do over time and that's what drives the economy forward is a more general belief. And it's true, large companies do get better. It's just one of those things that a factory, a plant, tends to become more productive over time.
Perhaps only a few percent a year but it does indeed happen and over time that adds up. This is one of the things that rather puzzles economists -- why, using the same technology, doing the same things, should a factory become more productive? The usual answer is, even if it's really a bit of hand waving, that the people in the factory just become better at using it as they use it more.
But that's not enough, that gradual improvement in the productivity of extant producers. Not enough if we want the 5% and 6% growth that Bangladesh is aiming for, not even enough for the 2% or 3% that a mature economy might hope for. To gain that we need radical change in what is being done, how it is being done, to happen somewhere in the economy.
As it happens, this is what start-ups do. It's rare for an extant company to radically change either what it does or how it does it. That rejuvenation of Apple into a phone maker is evidence that it can happen, but that use of that one company as everyone's example of it happening shows how rare it is.
The doing of new things in new ways is really driven by the old companies exiting the market -- going bust -- and new companies taking their place. Or, to get this the right way around, the new companies arising and killing off the old.
This means that start ups are indeed our economic future and we'd like to encourage them. But the most important thing here isn't, in fact, actual encouragement -- it's not stopping them. There are plenty of people out there willing to have a go at something new. The difficulty is, all too often, regulation that stops them from being able to do so.
This is where the “free” part of “free markets” really comes into play. It doesn't mean, it's not meant to mean, that markets are free of all regulation. Rather, people are free to enter the market. New suppliers, new production units, companies, co-operatives, are able to enter the market, see if anyone wants their output and, well, they are free to have a go.
So this doesn't, at all, mean that a free market economy cannot be regulated. Not poisoning the environment, or the customers, that's a pretty good regulation to have. Paying the workers, that's a good regulation. And so on.
The free part really means that anyone who signs up to the general rules of the game is free to have a go.
It's this which produces the flood of people trying. Given how hard it is to make a start up work -- I've tried several times and look at me, I'm back to writing for a living -- we need that flood to have enough successes to drive forward the economy over time.
So, the real lesson from all of this is that whatever our regulatory system we have to make sure it doesn't get in the way of those small companies trying to do new things, or old things in new ways.
Yes, it's entirely true that start-ups are our future, they are what will make our children, our future selves, richer than we are today. That means we've got to make sure to leave room for them to start-up. Leave that market with free entry, that is, the important part of the free market.
Tim Worstall is a senior fellow at the Adam Smith Institute in London



