An editorial in this newspaper suggests that startups are the future of the economy. Indeed they are. And yet, despite the fact that I write for this newspaper, it's necessary to disagree more than a little bit with one part of this call: “We need to facilitate the flexibility of our regulatory environment so that it is more conducive to startups.”
Well, yes, and also no.
For as Ronald Reagan said, the scariest phrase in the language is “I'm from the government and I'm here to help.”
It's not that we need regulation that facilitates start ups, it’s that we need the absence of regulation that stops start-ups. This is more than merely a linguistic quibble, it goes to the very heart of the problem.
Take the RMG business which is such a central feature of today’s Bangladeshi economy. No part of the government planned it, succoured it, supported it -- they didn't even know about it. It really did start with some sewing machines in a couple of apartments and took off from there. That was, I'm told, back in 1974 -- please write to the editor to correct me. It was the entire absence of anyone telling people that they could, couldn’t -- or if they did they must do it this way -- that allowed that initial experiment.
And that’s the point that must be made. We can also look at this from the 30,000-foot view in the rich economies today. Many observers tell us that the US, or the UK, Germany, simply aren’t innovative enough. There aren’t enough people trying to do old things in new ways.
That needs a little explanation.
There are two sources of growth: There is doing new things, but there's also doing old things in new ways. As long as we use fewer resources in this new way, only then will we have economic growth. Because using fewer resources means there are now resources free to go off and do other things. We live, by definition, in a universe of scarce economic resources. So, freeing some of them up by using fewer of them for one task means we have growth -- we can now do more stuff.
The complaint in the rich economies these days is that far few people try to do those old things in new ways. All of the effort goes into doing the new things now technologically possible. All the growth is in new mobile phone apps and no one is making healthcare better, or sorting out the education system. The reason being that entry into healthcare or education is hugely regulated. Entry into this week’s dodgy crypto idea isn’t.
So where does all that entrepreneurial activity go?
Now, this doesn't mean that we require, or even desire, zero regulation. It does, though, mean we need to be very careful about the regulation we do have. Take that crypto world out there. Yes, vast amounts of dodgy, criminal activity going on. A personal (historical, I hasten to add, not as an activity) interest is the way in which financial markets scam investors. Crypto has seen every mistake, fraud, and corruption that financial markets have developed over millennia being deployed at warp speed. And yet there might, just might, be still some useful concept at the heart of the idea. So have laws against fraud and corruption, not laws that regulate crypto. Have laws against killing customers, not detailed regulation of the ways that might happen for one particular sector.
Regulation should be at that 30,000-foot level already mentioned. Ready (through the courts and the law) to grind small and however slow against those who make a mockery of it. But leaving the room for people to try new things without needing permission, registration nor licences.
Because that's what a start up is. It's an attempt to do something in a new way. It's also, almost always, something that's the idiot brainchild of some nightmare -- the product of too much cheese before bed perhaps. But one in 1,000, maybe one in a million, actually works and it’s those that drive life forward.
I spent most of the 1990s in Russia. One day Anatoly Sobchak, then Mayor of St Petersburg (and Vladimir Putin’s boss at the time) said that you don’t need a licence, a permit, to be in business. Just do it and come back and tell us when it’s working. Then you can register for tax and all that. He was somewhat surprised to find his office surrounded by swirling queues of people the next day. All looking for that permit to state that they didn’t need a permit.
We need, that is, more Sobchaks and fewer who think that the queue for the permits is necessary. Or, to put the same point another way, the government regime we need for start-ups is not to have one, the flexibility required is that there is none.
The correct response of the government to someone announcing they’ve got a couple of rented apartments with a few sewing machines is: “What the hell are you telling me that for? Come back when you've got an industry I should care about.” For the thing is, you see, and I swear this is absolutely and wholly true, that’s how the largest industry in Bangladesh really did start.
And wouldn’t it be fun to have more of those?
Tim Worstall is a senior fellow at the Adam Smith Institute in London



