Reliable Brokers
Online Investing
Alerts & Analysis
Easy Trading

Mumbai’s mannequin morality

Update : 30 May 2013, 08:03 AM

This week the Brihanmumbai Municipal Corporation of the City of Mumbai, represented by 227 elected corporators unanimously passed an order to ban the display of bikini-clad mannequins outside lingerie shops in the city.

With Mumbai recording the second highest number of rapes in India, the civic authority felt scantily-dressed mannequins could lead to “wrong acts” by men.

The move has sparked off debate between conservatives and liberals across the country.

“The sight of plastic flesh dangling from shop windows has led to the pollution of minds in today’s generation.”

In one fell swoop, this statement from an elected representative of Mumbai’s civic authority led to an order, banning lingerie clad mannequins. Civic authorities cite provisions of the Indecent Representation of Women (Prohibition) Act to back their actions.

The argument that window displays cause a rise in sex crimes and make female passersby blush jars with a progressive cultural and social ethos and image that Mumbai, as a financial metropolis, cultivates in the global arena.

It presupposes women need the protective chauvinism of the state machinery, otherwise they cannot fend for themselves and that all men are potential criminals.

For a nation at a crossroads – half the population under the age of 25, aspiring to 21st century education and employment – this is the ultimate Indian irony. An obsession with codifying human behaviour through official edict drags us back to centuries-old approaches to gender.

Mumbai’s report card on moral policing displays such notions of inverted social and cultural purity. Like last year, avenger cop ACP Vasant Dhoble’s personal crusade against gambling and prostitution – a stick wielding spree to shut down nightclubs and shops.

A January advisory, invoking the Bombay Police Act, 1951, to warn couples not to stray to deserted beaches at low tide – euphemism for indecent behavior. Banning dance bars because dancing was derogatory to women and restrictions on US style cheerleaders for IPL matches in the city.

I have to ask, do we really need more laws and law enforcers to keep our women safe? Or are the real solutions elsewhere? At the risk of sounding extremely naïve, I believe the answers lie closer to home, a change in mindsets and societal pressure.

Take a look at what happened after the December incident in Delhi. The domestic and international outrage led to a new anti-rape law and a large corpus to tackle the issue.

Has it changed anything? We still hear and see the most horrific instances of violence against women, not just by their perpetrators but also cops on the streets. Ministries are also openly bickering over access to those funds, meant to find solutions.

Yet, there has also been a major shift in the frame of reference; the uproar, women tired of the harassment, demanding an end to police and government indifference and wanting recognition for all the men who stand by them. They are women who want the same things as everyone else, professional success unencumbered by blind acceptance of their traditional social duties.

The corporator behind Mumbai’s ban on bikini clad mannequins labels herself a “firebrand feminist” safeguarding a rich Indian culture and tradition and pushing for a punitive system to protect women, akin to conservative societies elsewhere.

It seems she is missing the point.

Those protesting on the streets aren’t really concerned with competing ideologies or notions of feminism. For them, in an ever globalising India, it is really an existential question.

They are asking for something far greater than compassion or the political expediency of dumbed down mannequin morality.

Top Brokers