Reliable Brokers
Online Investing
Alerts & Analysis
Easy Trading

THE LAST WORD BY TIM WORSTALL

The logistics of progress

What should our national logistics plan look like?

Update : 06 Aug 2022, 03:56 PM

National plans for things rarely work out. The reason why is that the nation -- or that part of it that creates the plan -- rarely knows what is necessary to know in creating the plan. 

We have our evidence in this very newspaper, in the various stories of what is changing now that the Padma Bridge is operational. 

As we saw a few weeks back, now that the bridge is open, train ticket sales from Khulna have fallen. 

This is obvious enough, the bus now takes half the time of the train so why wouldn't people switch? 

But we’ve also got the airlines worrying about ticket sales to Barisal and Jessore. 

Prices have been lowered and one airline has stopped flying one of the routes.

And the changes carry on too.

Now exports are leaving from Mongla Port rather than trying to escape via the nightmare that is Chittagong. 

These are all good things arriving as a result of that Padma Bridge, and that was, clearly and obviously, a result of considerable government planning and intervention.

However, we’ve also got a call for a “holistic national logistics policy” -- and this opens up a considerable danger. 

Because there will undoubtedly be people who then say that this should mean lots more government detailing the intricacies of logistics. 

Which isn’t the correct reaction at all.

Look at how the Padma development has changed the usage of rail and air. 

Now, if we actually had a planning agency of the necessary skill then those two changes would have been predicted as a result of the bridge opening. 

Instructions would have gone to the two state-run (the railways and one of the affected airlines Biman) organizations warning them of what was about to happen.

The plan would have taken them into consideration and would have altered operations accordingly. But it didn’t now, did it? 

So, therefore, we’ve not got the planning organization with the necessary skill to create a detailed national plan, have we? 

We shouldn’t go off shouting at the bureaucrats over this, it's not exactly their fault. 

Hayek got his Nobel for essentially pointing out that no central system and no plan could ever get to that level of detail simply because the centre never has enough information to be able to do so. 

An economy is just too complex a thing for all the interactions to be understood, let alone calculated and planned. 

No, computers do not solve this problem as the excellent essay “In Soviet Union Optimisation Problem Solves You” details (although to be fair that’s only for those who want the, umm, details).

However, we do indeed need at least some approach to this basic problem: What are the logistics of the nation going to be? 

So there’s got to be some plan, somewhere, but if we can't have one in detail then what should the plan be? 

To borrow from Britain's experience, we used to have a properly planned port and dock scheme, the National Dock Labour Scheme. 

Of course, this ended up being run, by and in favour of, the unions and labour, but that's not what was really wrong with it. 

All the major ports in the country were part of it and most of the smaller ones.

Today’s largest container port is Felixstowe and all of the docks of London (and many other places, in fact all of the old port cities) are entirely closed and finished. 

The reason being that Felixstowe was too small to be part of the national scheme. 

Therefore the private owners could do as they wished -- which they did, from 1967 onwards. 

They were free of that national plan that is. 

They invested in the port, in containerization, in efficiency, and beat all those other ports who failed -- largely enough -- because they were part of the plan.

All of which leaves us with what our national logistics plan or policy should be. 

Leave people be and let them get on with it. 

The centre cannot possibly know enough to actually craft a useful plan, and past experience shows that those free of such plans do better at solving problems anyway.

Yes, of course, there's still a place for governance -- the Padma Bridge was most unlikely to be built as an entirely private sector operation -- but that plan, that policy, has to be at a very high level of abstraction for it to be useful.

The other way of putting this is that those who have to do the logistics, the private economic actors out there, are the people with the knowledge and information necessary to plan logistics. 

Therefore they should be the people both driving and doing the logistics plan, shouldn't they? 

Tim Worstall is a senior fellow at the Adam Smith Institute in London

Top Brokers