Spectrum for the mobile networks is like air, invisible but keeps the network alive and healthy.
If there is shortage of spectrum, the scarcity makes the network choke and feel exhausted.
The exhaustion is severe when the growth in network usage outpaces the availability of spectrum and expansion of the physical access network.
Spectrum is one of the key components in the mobile network infrastructure, not having enough spectrum results in mainly two consequences.
First, it means more investment in physical sites (towers, base stations, etc) to cover up for the spectrum shortage.
Second, it means inferior service quality for the end users.
The data usage growth and the increasing smartphone penetration are causing a data surge in the operators’ networks.
To cater for the data growth, the operators need more spectrum because the demand for higher speed and throughput by the customers is directly demanding deployment of more spectrum and more sites.
The indoor coverage and coverage on the go also needs to be improved, spectrum plays an important role there as well.
The more and more bandwidth hungry applications people will use it will demand more and more spectrum.
The 4G and 5G technologies are more suitable for data services in the sense that these technologies can handle much more spectrum simultaneously and have certain unique advantages over the previous generation of technologies.
The 2022 spectrum auction should now mitigate the long-stated spectrum crunch for the mobile operators.
Even though the spectrum auction was titled to be a 5G spectrum auction, more or less both the bands offered in the spectrum auction, 2,300 MHz (2.3 GHz) and 2,600 MHz (2.6 GHz), are well suited for 4G technologies.
The spectrums sold in these two bands are technology neutral meaning that these spectrums can be used for any technology e.g. 2G/3G/4G/5G and beyond.
So, the operators can shuffle the spectrum among the technologies as per the need of that particular technology.
This is what we know as technology neutrality of spectrum, a very positive step taken by the regulators.
2022 auction
The 2022 auction was special for a few reasons.
One was of course a huge amount of spectrum was sold at one go, which was unique and unforeseen in the spectrum auction history of the country.
BTRC decided to lower down the base price significantly and also made more spectrum available unlike any other previous auctions.
Altogether 190 MHz spectrum was sold, 120 MHz in 2,600 MHz band and 70 GHz in the 2,300MHz band, at a base price of $6.5 million per MHz.
If we want to do a quick comparison with the earlier auction prices, to make the prices comparable we need to adjust for the system difference of paired spectrum versus non-paired spectrum.
In the previous two auctions, spectrum was sold in paired spectrum (FDD) system but the 2022 auction was non-paired (TDD) system.
In a paired spectrum system, for example 1,800 MHz and 2,100 MHz auction, each 1 MHz spectrum literally means 1+1 MHz or 2 MHz.
In paired spectrum (FDD) systems 1 MHz is needed for uplink and another 1 MHz is needed for downlink.
So, if we rationalize this, the 1,800 MHz spectrum base price was $15 million per MHz in 2018 and $15.5 million in 2021.
Similarly, the 2,100 MHz spectrum price was $13.5 million per MHz in both 2018 and 2021 auctions.
But in 2021, there was huge competition between the top two operators for the last 5 MHz block and the price went up to $23.375 million per MHz and Grameenphone bought it at this price.
It meant that there was a big demand for spectrum and the final price shot up 1.7 times of the base price.
Comparatively, the base price in the 2022 auction was much lower at $6.5 million per MHz, less than 50% of the previous price on average.
Even though the bands are not the same, 2,300 MHz and 2,600 MHz are very much standard bands and widely used for 4G and 5G around the globe.
The base price of the auction is usually decided by the demand of spectrum by the market players, supply of the spectrum and how much the operators value the spectrum.
It is possible to calculate the value generated for the operators by considering the past business data and a forecasted cash flow for the future.
Some other factors that are used in this kind of valuation model is local economic situation, per capita income, disposable income for telecom services etc. to ascertain an estimated value.
The operators do their own homework and reach an acceptable price limit for the spectrum.
The regulators can do the same at their end to estimate a value for the industry.
Spectrum is a limited natural resource for any country and each country tries to generate maximum value out of its scarce spectrum resource.
The value for the country is created in two steps- the first one is at the time of selling and the second is indirectly through the value generated by the operators and the customers.
Since spectrum is a key ingredient of the network infrastructure build-out, the price and availability of spectrum will ultimately affect the retail price and the service quality.
The government can take two alternate positions.
One option is to maximize the initial value by targeting comparatively higher prices in the auction.
The sale proceeds will go to the government exchequer and will be ultimately spent for public benefits.
The other approach can be to keep the spectrum price at a minimum level and allow operators to acquire enough spectrum at a lower price, such that the operators can leverage on higher quantity and lower price.
The customers in the end should be benefited as they would enjoy better service quality at a lower cost.
The 2022 auction ought to be a big relief for the operators; they could acquire a much larger chunk of spectrum at a much more affordable price.
The additional spectrum would allow them to overcome the capacity constraints of 3G and 4G networks, to improve on service quality and to plan for 5G network launch aggressively.
The days ahead should only be brighter.
The author is a telecom professional, who worked extensively at Grameenphone in various capacities from 1997 until 2019



