Raja Kunwar Singh, a military commander from Jagdishpur who was a rebel general during the 1857 revolt, was recently celebrated by Indian Home Minister Amit Shah in order to boost a BJP hopeful-Chief Minister of Bihar. This event, which is reported to have broken the Guiness Record for flag-waving, is part of a long tradition of the ‘57 rebellion being misinterpreted for jingoistic and nationalist purposes.
The Hindu nationalist Savarkar argued that it was a pan-India, nationalist war against British rule, but this view has been criticised by modern historians such as SN Sen, RC Majumdar, E Stokes, and K Wagner. They have discarded this dramatic and anachronistic view of the rebellion in favour of examining the different circumstances that lead to opportunistic revolts in 1857-8.
The nationalist historian Majumdar called the revolt neither first, nor national, nor a war of Independence, aiming directly at Savarkar’s thesis. The chasm between these two interpretations of the revolt is best seen in the story of Babu Kunwar. Kunwar Singh came from a long line of Bihari zamindaris, but due to the extravagant lifestyles of Kunwar and his father, as well costly lawsuits they’d both undertaken, Raja Kunwar was deeply in debt.
This spendthrift nature had, however, endeared him to British and Indian elites who he loved to entertain, and also enhanced his prestige among his subjects. Due to his near illiteracy, Kunwar was taken advantage of by his creditors, but the friends that his lavish lifestyle and mild nature had won him would be of service.
The Commissioner at Patna, Tayler, petitioned the government to help Kunwar when it appeared that he would obtain a loan from the Marathas. The EIC government began to help Kunwar to manage his estates, but after the Marathas reneged on the promised loan, these efforts fell apart and by 1857, Kunwar had a Rs 20 lakh loan to pay off.
Two months after the rebellion had begun, on June 25, Babu Kunwar was worried that he’d be able to stay solvent without continued help from the EIC and begged the government for help with managing his estates. He asked for a sizable loan to keep his creditors at bay, saying: “The petitioner considers himself a well-wisher and servant of the Government and prays for its prosperity.”
Tayler requested Kunwar to meet him at Patna so they could discuss a solution, but by July 25, Babu Kunwar Singh was in rebellion. So what led this “well-wisher and servant of the government” to become a major enemy of it within a month? Tayler had retained the utmost faith in his friend Kunwar until the end, and later argued that he would not have turned to rebellion had the government helped him in time.
However, Tayler’s replacement as Commissioner, Samuells, blamed Tayler, suggesting that Kunwar had interpreted Tayler’s request to come to Patna as a plan to imprison him. As Kunwar saw Tayler as a friend, it seems unlikely that he’d believe his friend would treat him like a common criminal. Rather, Kunwar had been carefully monitoring the movements of the rebellious sepoys from Dinapore and was likely afraid to leave his estates in case they used this opportunity to attack Jagdishpur.
If this is the case, then why did he join these rebels?
It’s likely that Kunwar’s hand was forced by his subordinate Harekrishnan Singh, who had joined the rebels without Kunwar’s permission. Hedayat Ali, and anonymous letters cited by Commissioner Samuells accuse Kunwar of conspiring with the rebels, however, these claim without evidence that Kunwar had been orchestrating events since January 1857.
Furthermore, if these letters implicated Kunwar, it’s unlikely that Tayler, who had seen them, would attest to his loyalty as late as July 8. The strongest evidence against Kunwar being a long-term conspirator is offered by his family member Nishan Singh.
In 1858, Singh testified that the late Kunwar (who had died from an arm wound) had been forced to rebel when the Dinapore Sepoys threatened to loot Jagdishpur if Kunwar were to stay loyal to the government. Although Kunwar’s true nature as a reluctant rebel is in opposition to the view of Kunwar that the BJP has tried to promote this past weekend in Bihar, it fits better with the facts.
First, Kunwar’s close friendship and legal dealings with British officials show that he much preferred legal recourse and the high life to rebellion. Unlike popular poems portraying Kunwar as an anti-judiciary activist, Kunwar’s legal successes against his brothers suggest that he saw the courts as trustworthy. Furthermore, Kunwar’s family had long been EIC loyalists, with some British continuing to speak positively of him even after the rebellion.
Historian Kim Wagner has suggested that, like Kunwar, Rani of Jhansi and Nana Sahib had also been given ultimatums by mutinous sepoys, coercing them into becoming leaders. While the popular view of Kunwar, and Savarkar’s “great man” view of him, as an anti-British nationalist are undoubtedly more romantic, they are not only inaccurate but disrespectful to the memory of Raja Kunwar.
The zamindar appears to have seen himself as a good ruler of his estates, and was determined to manage his finances to keep them solvent. He also saw himself as a loyal servant to the government, and a good friend to the British officials who’d previously ruled favourably to him and had done more to help him with his financial woes than the Indian bankers and go-betweens who’d frequently undermined him for their profit.
By portraying him as the opposite of who he wanted to be, the BJP celebration of his role as a rebel has done a disservice to the once-loyal Kunwar, by making his identity the one that he only reluctantly accepted when held hostage at gunpoint.
Shah stated that “history has not done justice to Babu Kunwar Singh. Historians have not written about him in the manner that he deserved.” Ironically, it is his view of Kunwar that does injustice, and is ignorant of Kunwar’s history.
Hira Jungkow is a freelance contributor.



