Reliable Brokers
Online Investing
Alerts & Analysis
Easy Trading

THE LAST WORD BY TIM WORSTALL

In times of hunger

Price fixing is not a solution, subsidizing people is

Update : 12 Jun 2022, 11:11 AM

Given the rising food prices, one of the old folk tales is making a reappearance: All these people trading in futures markets -- the “financialization of food” as it can be called -- are causing the price rises in the physical food markets. 

This simply isn’t true even as it’s one of those ideas that rears its ugly head again and again.

As this newspaper itself reported, various people are worried about this. It’s an old thing of course, something goes wrong so therefore it must be them out there, those others, causing it. Western Europe used to blame witches, blaming Jewish people led to a horrendous result, and now it's speculators, the capitalists just out for profit. 

They play with money and the poor starve and, well, we all know how that argument then goes on.

This modern definition of that “other” causing all the problems is as ludicrous as those earlier two. For speculation in futures markets simply doesn't affect the current and present price of food at all. 

The entire system works the other way around.

Yes, certainly futures prices -- those on those financial exchanges -- can go all over the place and they are indeed driven by speculation.

But each and every one of those contracts comes to an end; there's a delivery date. 

And on the delivery date the price of the wheat, or the maize, the rice, whatever, is the price in the physical markets. 

That is, whatever the futures, the speculative price has done then the day it actually matters, when it matures, it's the real-world price which determines the futures price, not the other way around.

So however much speculation anyone’s done with mere money it ends up being the real-world supply and demand that matters to the price they get for their speculation.

The speculation doesn’t determine the real world, it's the other way around.

All those complaints about the speculative froth in the financial markets can therefore be rejected. They’re simply not true. 

However, there’s another type of speculation that can change those physical, real-world prices. That is when someone buys and then stockpiles. 

They need to actually take that real-world product and take it away from the market. 

They must store it, stockpile it for their actions to change that real-world price. 

That can indeed happen and it can be vile when it does. But there’s also a way to check whether it is: 

If stocks are rising then perhaps this is what is driving the price rises. But if stocks are not rising then they’re not. 

This then gives us a test for what is causing price rises in foodstuffs. 

It could indeed be speculation that is causing it but, given that futures markets cannot -- only physical ones -- then it can only be true that speculation is driving up food prices if stocks of food are being kept off the market.

If there are no rises in stocks then it's simply not speculation -- whether we blame witches or capitalist speculators -- causing the food price changes. 

This means that we’ve actually got a change in real supply and real demand. 

This is important to grasp. Because if we do have a real change in supply and or demand then price controls and bureaucratic intervention in prices simply aren’t going to work. 

Because they cannot address the actual problem, which is that people desire more food than there is at lower or past prices. 

This is not a problem that can be solved by people sitting in offices no matter how important the title on their desk nameplate. 

This doesn't mean there's nothing we can do, it just tells us what we should do. 

The thing about food being that, of course, it is an essential. Gain access to less than that minimum and we die. 

This is not a result that we desire, so of course we should do something. 

But the “what” is that we should provide aid to the poor to enable them to access the now more expensive food. Trying to change the market price won't work.

Giving the poorest of the poor a little more money so they can buy, in those markets, the now more expensive food does. 

The greater expense of food means that we richer folk -- yes, we are, reading an English language newspaper, we are -- can cope even if we’d prefer not to. 

We’ll cope, in part, by eating a little less or differently. 

The poor cannot do that as they’re only just above the minimum calorie requirement already.

All of which is really just a reflection of a very basic economic concept. 

Things that we wish had or would not happen do indeed happen. 

There are things we can do about this, of course, but the answer is never to mess with the markets nor is it to try and price fix.

Instead, the solution is to subsidize people. People can’t afford food? 

Give them some money. 

In the end it’s not just more effective it's hugely, grossly, cheaper.


Tim Worstall is a senior fellow at the Adam Smith Institute in London

Top Brokers