A cornerstone of democracy is free speech and a free, objective, neutral media. Reporting on Ukraine, however, has exposed deep, worrying biases that appear to be widespread in the mainstream (Western) media where reporting double standards have become commonplace.
First, let us be clear: The devastation seen in Ukraine is unconscionable, and the plight of civilians heart-breaking. However, the global South witnessed in amazement the sheer racism that was in evidence in the media reportage of the war. I refer to reporters who were “bewildered” by the large-scale exodus of European refugees from Ukraine, unable to comprehend how white, Christian, Europeans could be so treated (while clearly this is fine if you aren’t white, Christian, and European).
The unspeakable was spoken, unapologetically, spontaneously, and alas, truthfully. The global South once again quietly noted something that has been demonstrated time and time again over many decades. White lives matter much; other lives matter less.
If you are black and Muslim, may Allah help you.
The gap between Western ideals and ground realities have always been large especially when the South was concerned. This gap continues to grow. And this is the reason why much of the global South remains unimpressed by Western accusations of human rights violations by Russia since, obviously, no such violations took place elsewhere, such as in the Middle East, save of course for minor collateral damage.
As a Bangladeshi, I am personally at a loss to comprehend why the Western powers did so little to fight for the rights of the Rohingya or to heavily and decisively sanction Myanmar for carrying out genocide. I am also a bit puzzled by the decision of the US to label the Rohingya exodus and mass murders as genocide only now, in 2022, after a lapse of so many years. At the same time, the Western media and its leaders have wasted no time in levelling genocide charges against Russia from day one.
It is no secret that our generation had looked up to the West for education, inspiration, guidance, direction, liberal values along with music, philosophy, books, jeans, hamburgers, coke and even dope in many cases. Despite Western arrogance and a history of cruelty perpetrated across the world, there was also a quieter, kinder, more reflective, entirely civilized side to the West that endeared it to the inhabitants of distant lands.
Increasingly, that enchantment is wearing thin and the West needs to do a bit of soul searching as to what the reasons are. What is increasingly apparent is that no attempt is made anymore to hide the plain and ugly truth that Tonto of the Lone Ranger would occasionally remind us of with those famous words: “Pale faces speak with forked tongue.”
I am surprised that the Ukraine war has gone on for as long as it has. I would have expected everyone to come together and force the warring parties to come to a settlement. Is it not clear that the longer that the conflict goes on, casualties and destruction will escalate, and the crisis deepen? Is it not the case now that everyone is rehearsing their nuclear codes -- thus pushing the world ever closer to the unthinkable?
Ukraine cannot come out of this war in one piece -- further delay only means the pieces left will get smaller and smaller. We don’t have information of any casualty numbers on the Ukrainian side. Russian military deaths have been put at 21,000. This is a huge figure; and implies that Moscow will not, indeed cannot, stop until its goals -- whatever those are -- are nearer the mark and its “honour” restored.
To put the casualty numbers in perspective, we should remember that during the brief 16-day war fought in 1971 in Bangladesh, the Indian Army lost 15,000 soldiers but it at least had a country to show for it. To date, Russia only has Mariupol -- and I fear that will not be quite enough.
It is important to come up with an exit strategy for a nuclear power that is already deeply sanctioned, cornered, humiliated and led by a strong, ruthless man who may indeed be somewhat delusional. Has the West now become so desperate that it would even consider a nuclear conflagration with Russia or sacrifice poor Ukraine to further its geo-political aims? Curiously, why aren’t we witnessing any anti-war movements yet, anywhere in the world?
Those of us who identify with the global South -- why should we care? In the short run, we are faced with high energy and food costs and a drastically diminished ability to trade with the warring countries. In the longer run, the conflict will cast a long shadow over the global economy and global economic institutions.
There are now even stronger signs that a potential Cold War II may usher in a bi-polar world economic order as well, which the South is unlikely to relish. Pressures are going to mount on the developing world to choose a side.
It will be damned if it does, and it will be damned if it doesn’t.
Khan Ahmed Sayeed Murshid is former director general, BIDS.



