It's possible to argue with the use of the word “improve”.
For of course we all have different tastes, and thus different ideas of what is in fact better. Ask any man with a teenage daughter about boys, parties, and modes of dress for a proof of that contention.
Thus it is that a report in this newspaper that the tax to GDP ratio will “improve” by rising in coming years is something that is open to question.
What, exactly, does improve mean here? The use actually employed was “rise” and, given the current levels in Bangladesh, even I would agree that the two – rise and improve – go together here.
To explain the background, GDP (gross domestic product) is the total value created in the domestic economy over the year. If 11.9 percent of that goes in tax then that's the portion of everything that the government has at its disposal to do the things that government must do.
I am a “minarchist”, someone who believes that small government is a good idea, an effective way of running the world, even the moral manner of doing so.
Even so, there are some things that must be done, that can only be done by government and therefore there are things that government must do. The difference between a minarchist and everyone else – and at my level of purity of belief in minarchism, that's just about everyone else – is that others say that government should do more than the merely necessary and go on to do things which are nice, or politic, or which some people would like government to do.
So, I think that the tax burden should be the absolute minimum to finance the government in doing those things which only government can do and which must still be done.
There is no absolute measure of what this is, but a reasonable rule of thumb is about 15 percent of GDP. Within that government can provide a basic welfare system, defend the country, make sure there's the necessary bureaucracy, finance a health care – we'll come to this in a moment – system, education and so on.
What it cannot do within such a measly share of that everything is run a significant redistribution system.
But then I don't think a government should be doing that. Many others, OK, let's be realistic here, near everyone else, thinks government should do more than that. That's fine, differences of view make the world more interesting.
What should be noted is that near no government spends more than about 20 percent of GDP on actually doing things.
Nearly anything larger than that is redistribution.
Taxation of the richer in order to pay for the poorer perhaps, or as it most likely turns out, taxation of everyone to redistribute to those who decide upon the redistribution. There is, after all, a reason why bureaucrats' salaries and pensions are rather better than those of the rest of us.
It's also true that things which must happen – that health care service – can be funded in different ways.
My native Britain taxes everyone, then the government actually produces the hospitals, doctors and health care and pays for that from tax revenues. That's the NHS.
The American system has people getting health care insurance through their workplace.
The Singapore system is a quarter the cost of the American, half that of the NHS. There, a tax free savings account is assigned to everyone, and this pays for their standard health care. Very large expenses are paid out of the general tax revenue instead.
There are advantages and problems with each of the systems but all do produce health care of a pretty high standard (the NHS is the worst of the three for the actual standard of health care), with very different implications for how much of GDP the government needs to pay for it.
It's entirely fair – true possibly – to say that Bangladesh's government doesn't have enough of the economy in order to be able to pay for those minimally necessary things.
So, in that sense, we can agree, “improve” and “more” mean the same thing here.
However, we also need to understand that this isn't always true. The French government takes – according to whose estimate you want to use – between 45 percent and 51 percent of the economy.
That's definitely too much. Enough and no more is the barrier between “more” meaning “improve” and “more” meaning to make worse.
The original article here also says that “The ratio is also a marker of how well the government controls a country's economic resources.”
Well, no, not really. It's a marker of what portion of the resources are controlled by the government. But that's not the same, not at all, as how well they control them.
One reason I am that minarchist as mentioned above is because I insist that government is a bad way of doing things, except for those few things which are both essential, and can only be done by government.
My real argument here is that the initial assumption was that more government is better.
This is not so.
As with anything else in life, we desire sufficient government and no more.
After all, why should government be any different from a biriyani? Essential at times, useful at others but definitely something that it's possible to have too much of.
Tim Worstall is a senior fellow at the Adam Smith Institute in London



