The bureaucrats have banned the sale of “non-bottled” soybean or palm oil. At which point a story about cobras -- one that's far too good to actually check as to whether it really happened -- actually becomes a historical fact. It might be best thought of as akin to an economic fairy tale. Something worth repeating for the point being made, the lesson that can be learned.
Back in the days of the Raj, the British in Delhi noted that there were far too many cobras around. So, they instituted a bounty -- bring in a dead cobra and get paid. You can probably guess the next stage and it didn’t take long: People started breeding cobras in order to hand them in for the bounty. It took the bureaucracy some time to work this out but they did and stopped the bounty – at which point the cobra farmers released their stock and Delhi had more than it had started with.
That might well be one of those stories that journalists call “too good to check” but the point is worth understanding. Bureaucratic action can lead to unintended consequences. Which brings us back to Bangladesh and this idea that those oils cannot be sold “loose,” not in industrially-sealed packaging. The reason is that Ramadan is coming. D'ye see?
Well, no, perhaps not. Quite why oils must be sold in factory bottles during the month of fasting is not obvious really, is it? Unless you have that sort of mind necessary to be a bureaucrat.
For the government is keen that prices do not rise during Ramadan. Which is a problem when that government itself says that prices are rising around 6% every year and some independents insist it's more like 12%. Bureaucracies, of course, think that if the bureaucracy waves a hand then the real world will obey and then adults know that's not quite how it works.
Anyway, the bureaucrats have decided that since the prices of those oils have risen, also since it’s Ramadan already, the prices of oils must not rise any further. Which brings us to another of those fairy tales, again from British history but at home this time. King Canute had courtiers who insisted that he could do anything, such was his power. Even command the tides. So, he had his throne set on the seashore and commanded the tides not to come in. His wet feet then became the rebuke to those courtiers who insisted upon the impossible, upon the idea that political power could command reality.
If oils have gone up in price then oils have gone up in price. Demanding that the price does not change will just mean that the accommodation has to be along other axes. Say, if oils are sold outside industrial packaging, short measures might be provided. TkX per 100ml and TkX per 80ml are changes in price, after all. Therefore the bureaucrats have demanded that oils cannot be sold by the measure, but only by the industrially-sealed bottle.
It might be thought that this would solve the problem but of course it won't for still the tide comes in, still the price of oils has changed. At the very best there will simply be less oil put into the market for people to buy and so there will be a shortage. In fact, we can predict with absolute certainty that that will happen for the market price is the one -- the one price -- at which supply and demand balance each other. Push the price down below that balancing price and there will be shortages, just as sure as English kings get wet feet.
So, why do bureaucracies do these things? Breed cobras, cause shortages of food oils? Because bureaucracies are not paid on the results of their policies or actions, only on the intentions of them. So, declare that action is being taken to prevent oils from going up in price and that's the job done. Until, of course, something more must be done like preventing people from adapting in some other way, insist they can only buy oils in factory packaged bottles.
There was some advice that Ronald Reagan gave to his own bureaucracy. “Don't just do something, stand there!” It's good advice too. We should hold the bureaucrats to it as well.
Tim Worstall is a senior fellow at the Adam Smith Institute in London



