Reliable Brokers
Online Investing
Alerts & Analysis
Easy Trading

PATTERNS & TRENDS BY SYED AKHTAR MAHMOOD

Tipping points and great accelerations

It is to the credit of successive governments that they often responded with the required policy, if not always at the desired speed

Update : 29 Mar 2022, 01:18 PM

There is something interesting about Bangladesh’s post-independence economic transformation.

While different economic variables have steadily improved over time, their long run trends have a remarkable feature, i.e. the existence of tipping points where the growth trajectory shifts and there is a significant acceleration in the absolute value of the variables, and often in their growth rates too. 

Consider the first chart which shows the long-run trend in the GDP growth rate. 

GDP growth fluctuated quite a bit in the 1960s and 1970s before entering a phase of modest, but steady growth between 1984 and 2004, and accelerating growth from 2005 onwards. 

We thus see two tipping points in the long-run trajectory of GDP growth, one in the early 1980s and one two decades later.

Figure 1: Long-term GDP growth pattern in Bangladesh: 1961-2019But the story does not end there. 

We see such tipping points, indeed more striking ones, for several other variables too. 

After growing at a relatively moderate rate for several years, suddenly there is a 3-fold or 4-fold increase in the variable within a short period of time. 

I term these changes ‘great accelerations’.  

The length of the periods when these ‘great accelerations’ happen has ranged from just a few years to more than a decade.

The beginning of such periods of acceleration are the tipping points. 

The second chart shows a series of such tipping points and the ‘great accelerations’ that followed.

Figure 2: Great accelerations in growth enabling factors: 1972-2019

Before going into the details of this fascinating chart, let me explain how this is constructed. 

For each of the variables depicted in the chart, a tipping point was identified through eyeballing.

Since the units of measurement are not the same for the different variables, I converted the nominal values to index values. 

But I did the indexation in a manner such that I can show the series of great accelerations vividly on a single chart.

What I did is the following. 

For the year which represents the tipping point for a variable, the value of that variable was indexed to 100 and values for subsequent years were indexed to this value. 

For example, I identified 1988 as a tipping point in total export earnings. 

The actual value of export earnings that year was $1.443 billion. 

This value was indexed to 100. 

Thus, for the following year, i.e 1989, when the actual value was $1.595 billion, the index value is about 110.   

In many cases, the acceleration phase lasted for several years before the variables moved to a slower-growth trajectory. 

In some cases, such as exports, the growth rate slowed for a few years before accelerating again (the second chart only shows the first acceleration phase for exports). The chart is meant to be illustrative. 

Thus, in some cases, it does not show the entire phase of acceleration but a large part of it. 

The main point of the chart is to show that there was a series of such ‘great accelerations’ in the post-independence period. 

The impact of these accelerations, discussed below by time-periods, may have been magnified because these happened one after the other. 

1970s to 1990s - The shift to a private sector-oriented economy 

The first great acceleration of the growth enabling factors in the post-independence period is in the share of private sector credit in total credit. 

Bangladesh’s development has happened largely in the context of a private sector-oriented economy. 

However, in the early years after independence, when the focus was on building a socialist economic system, only one-fifth of total credit went to the private sector. 

The scenario started changing dramatically from the mid-1970s. 

By 1988-89 the share had reached 70%, and by 2019, a peak of 89% - a stark reflection of the move away from a state-dominated to a private sector-oriented economy in Bangladesh. 

All the credit that flowed to the private sector was not efficiently used and some was not paid back – the large, and rising proportion of non-performing loans is evidence of this. 

However, the very substantial increase in credit inflow to businesses allowed economic actors to respond to emerging opportunities, including those created by policy actions.    

Export growth

The increase in private sector credit flows facilitated growth in export earnings, where the second great acceleration in our story takes place. 

A paradigm shift occurred in Bangladesh’s export scene with the emergence of the export-oriented ready-made garment industry. 

Although the first consignment of garment exports had gone out in 1978, the industry really took off in the early 1980s.

Rising garment exports boosted total exports. 

After growing slowly till the mid to late 1980s, total exports experienced a growth acceleration that lasted till the end of the 1990s. 

Total exports increased five-fold within a decade and half, driven primarily by garments which accounted for 75% of all exports by the end of this period. 

Rural road connectivity

The 1980s witnessed the beginning of another trend, i.e., the substantial expansion of the feeder road network which helps link the villages and small towns of Bangladesh to each other and to the rest of the country. 

This is the third great acceleration in our story. 

In 1988 Bangladesh had about 3000 km. of feeder roads, five times that in 1979 when it was just above 600 km.  

However, a massive expansion happened after 1988 and by 1997, there was a little over 15,500 km. of feeder roads linking villages, small towns, and larger cities all over Bangladesh – a five-fold increase within a decade. 

The size of the network stabilized after this “great acceleration”.

2000 to now 

Agricultural mechanization

The fourth great acceleration started towards the end of the 1990s and continued for much of the first decade of the new millennium. 

This has to do with the import of agricultural machinery. 

As agricultural output expanded, demand for farm labor and draft power increased. 

However, supply of such critical inputs could not keep pace with demand and, in fact, went down in absolute terms. 

This partly resulted from the trends discussed above, such as increased connectivity that encouraged people to seek income earning opportunities outside villages. 

Natural disasters also contributed, by depleting the stock of draft animals.

Demand for agricultural mechanization increased and policy reforms expanded the space for private sector imports of agricultural machinery. 

The second chart shows the five-year moving averages in the index value of agricultural machinery imports (the averages were taken to smooth out year-to-year fluctuations and provide a clearer picture of the long run trend). 

We can see that the index value increased from 100 in 1997 (the tipping point for this variable) to 1046 in 2010 – a 10-fold increase over a 13-year period.  

Remittances

Another great acceleration started around the same time. 

This was with remittance inflows. 

The acceleration started in the late 1990s and continued for a little more than a decade. The first migrants from Bangladesh went to the Middle East in the early 1970s. 

Migration subsequently expanded, not only to the Middle East but also to other regions, such as East Asia, Europe, and North America. 

The expansion of Bangladesh’s foothold in global labor markets is reflected in the phenomenal rise in remittance inflows. 

The trend is that of relatively modest growth till the end of the 1990s, followed by a sharp acceleration in inflows after 2000. 

In 1976, the country received about $50 million in remittances; this increased steadily to reach $1.5 billion in 1997. 

These are official flows; it may be noted that sizable remittance inflows come through unofficial sources. 

The growth rates of remittance inflow were higher during these two decades compared to the next two, but this was from a low base. 

In absolute terms, the real acceleration in remittance inflows started around the turn of the century. 

By 2014, annual remittances had crossed $15 billion after which the growth slowed considerably. 

Mobile telephony

The sixth and seventh great accelerations – in mobile phone subscriptions and power generation - started close to each other in the middle of the first decade of the millennium. 

Mobile telephony started its journey in Bangladesh in 1998 and mobile phone subscriptions per capita increased at a slow pace till 1998. 

After this there was a modest acceleration, but subscriptions remained below 2 per 100 people till 2005. 

A paradigm shift happened after 2005 as subscriptions expanded exponentially. 

The year 2005 thus represents the beginning of another great acceleration. 

An important milestone was crossed in 2019 as the number of subscriptions exceeded the number of people in the country.  

Power generation

Inadequate and unreliable power supply had long been a major constraint on economic activity in Bangladesh, especially in the modern sector. 

Power generation capacity increased moderately in the second half of the 1990s but stagnated for several years after that. 

However, there was an acceleration in installed, and maximum, power generation capacity from 2008 onwards. 

By 2019, the latter was almost 13,000 MW, compared to about 3700 MW in 2007. 

This was the second great acceleration involving infrastructure, the first being in rural roads two decades earlier. 

Mobile financial services

The final great acceleration considered here is in mobile financial services, which took off after a 2011 regulatory reform created the space for such activity. 

One indicator of the spread of mobile financial services is the total value of mobile financial transactions. 

In fiscal year 2013/2014 (i.e., July 2013 – June 2014), the total transaction value was Tk78,000 crore. 

During fiscal year 2016/2017, i.e In 3 years, this had risen to Tk277,100 crore, and during 2020/21, to Tk686,600 crore, i.e., a nearly nine-fold increase in seven years.

These are just a few examples of tipping points and ‘great accelerations’. There are others too.

What is the significance of these, especially in relation to the narrative of Bangladesh’s economic transformation? 

I shall mention three things. 

First, there are important dynamics that create these tipping points. 

I submit that, in Bangladesh, it is the combination of entrepreneurial dynamism and responsive government actions that helped move different economic variables from one trajectory to another. 

Bangladeshi entrepreneurs, from the small farmers to the large conglomerates, have shown an uncanny ability to identify opportunities and grab these. 

In some cases, government policy created such opportunities. 

But in most cases the opportunities were created in the marketplace by domestic or global factors to which entrepreneurs responded. 

Such entrepreneurial initiatives, in turn, generated demand for policy action to maintain the momentum. 

It is to the credit of successive governments that they often responded with the required policy, if not always at the desired speed.

It should also be noted that the tipping points and ‘great accelerations’ mentioned above are not all independent of each other. 

In fact, there are many examples of synergies, where dramatic movements in one or more variables, in turn, led to similar movements in other variables. 

That is a story that I shall tell another day.       


The author is an economist, previously with an international development agency

Top Brokers