Reliable Brokers
Online Investing
Alerts & Analysis
Easy Trading

Should we rethink automatic promotions in schools?

Learning deficit from Covid closures is a reality that we must acknowledge and address

Update : 27 Mar 2022, 09:31 PM

The global pandemic has taken its toll on the world economy -- and not to mention on the state of public health and education across the world. 

As of March 27, 2022, more than 481 million people have been infected by the virus -- resulting in the death of more than 6.1 million people. Moreover, the virus has affected different regions with different intensities -- and the uncertainties associated with the various manifestations of the virus has made it extremely difficult for the policymakers to come up with a coherent strategy to address the intertwined challenges associated with the socio-economic fallout from this once in a lifetime global pandemic. 

Thus, it is not surprising that according to the World Economic Outlook -- more than 90 million people are expected to fall into extreme deprivation -- and that the incidence of extreme poverty is expected to rise for the first time in the last two decades. It is also not startling that this pandemic has skewed the level of inequality both within and across countries -- as it has brought hardship for people employed in the informal sector with little or no education, and for women. 

Clearly, this disruption in our social and economic life has had strong implications for the education sector -- and thus, the developing countries have tried different policy instruments to mitigate the deficit in learning.

Prior to Covid, Bangladesh had made impressive grounds in ensuring the access to education of children, especially girls. Yet, the pre-Covid-19 literacy rates masked an inconvenient truth -- which is that schooling has not always resulted in learning. 

In fact, a World Bank study noted that students lack 4.5 years of learning in the first 11 years of schooling -- underscoring the lack of quality that has already plagued our education system.  

Moreover, this deficit has only amplified due to the closures caused by Covid-19. For instance, I visited my ancestral home in Bhola very recently where I spoke to numerous teachers who teach in primary schools to understand the magnitude of the deficit in learning that has happened due to nearly two years of school closures. And some of the anecdotes that I heard need serious attention while we try to design an education policy to mitigate this crisis of learning.

First: Given that the schools were closed for almost two years, rural children who were attending grades two and three have now received automatic promotions -- and thus, they currently attend grades four and five respectively. This means that the children who could barely understand letters of the alphabet and numbers are now expected to write paragraphs and undertake mathematical calculations, which is beyond their cognitive ability. 

Second: It also got mentioned that distance learning did not work well for the rural children -- which means that the teachers teaching grades four and five are now facing a very complex task and with almost no practical way to mitigate this crisis of learning. In fact, a survey undertaken in May 2020 did hint towards this outcome -- where only a quarter of the 5,000 respondents with access to TV mentioned watching classes. What is even more concerning is that even within this group, nearly one-third complained that the classes were difficult to follow.   

It is also noted that the teachers are requested by the higher authorities that they should try to deal with the deficit in learning by teaching an extra 20 minutes each day. However, this is turning out to be an optical solution for a very deep problem. It is therefore concerning that these issues are not receiving much discussion while things are returning to normalcy. In fact, policymakers in the education sector must ask some fundamental questions:

  •  Given that the world is navigating through a once-in-a-century global pandemic -- is it not time we accept that human beings have lost a year in their lives and just move on? 

 

  • Is finishing SSC with a very poor learning base at 16 more important than finishing it at 17 with a stronger base? 

 

  • Can automatic promotions really solve the problem that we are facing in the education sector -- especially in the rural areas where distance learning has not really worked? 

 

  • Do we really want more young people in the job market with an empty certificate backed by limited skills or knowledge? 

 

  • How long must this crisis of skills endure till we take notice of it? 

The crisis of learning that I have begun to notice in rural Bangladesh -- where 60% of the country’s population still lives -- is a serious issue of public policy and it needs both out-of-the-box thinking and critical introspection. What we do not need is simple optically savvy but ineffective policy for addressing a very complex problem. 

More importantly, we must rethink the logic underlying automatic promotions for students at the primary level if we accept that learning does not automatically emerge from schooling.    

Dr Ashikur Rahman is Senior Economist at Policy Research Institute (PRI). Email: [email protected] 

Top Brokers