Reliable Brokers
Online Investing
Alerts & Analysis
Easy Trading

THE LAST WORD BY TIM WORSTALL

How is economic freedom, black money tax and housing market all connected?

They are all aspects of the same problem and all have the same solution

Update : 06 Mar 2022, 11:10 AM

It is rare for us to find the three stories which so delightfully support each other on matters economic but this newspaper has managed it just this past week.

The first is that Bangladesh has fallen down the list of the Heritage Foundation's listing of countries by their economic freedom.

The second is a report on the problems in the Bangladeshi housing market.

The third is about the tax rate folks pay for moving black money into the stock market.

Now most will think they're all terribly different things and that they have entirely different solutions.

To me, as to most economists, they're the same thing.

They are all aspects of the same problem and all have the same solution.

The economic freedom report is, well, it's sort of about economic freedom.

But really, the listings are about how easy it is to do something in the economy legally and efficiently.

This does map over economic freedom, of course it does, even if they're very slightly different concepts.

So, how difficult is it to register a company, to be legal to operate and pay tax?

To get a court judgment against the crooks who ripped you off? To be able to close everything down when you realize that the business was a mistake?

Clearly, the more difficult these things are the more likely you'll not bother.

Or do so illegally – what we call a “grey” economy. You would like to be legal, you could be, and it is just difficult to be so as opposed to the “black” economy which is retailing yaba at parties.

Remedy

OK, so how do we deal with this? We make the machinery of the state more efficient.

In my native Britain it can be legal to go with a fully functioning, tax registered, new company in about 30 minutes.

For perhaps £30 as well, three hours of minimum wage labour.

I can also close it down again at about the same level of cost and difficulty.

So, anyone trying a new business does just naturally sign up and work legally.

Or take that housing market problem.

One of the big difficulties recognized is how difficult it is to throw someone out if they don't pay their mortgage.

Partly the legal rights they've got, partly the sheer ghastliness of trying to deal with the Bangladeshi civil courts system.

This of course makes mortgages more difficult to get – how can people get their money back if they can't throw you out if you don't pay?

That also makes mortgages more expensive as things in short supply always are.

We are again talking about the efficiency of the Bangladeshi state, aren't we?

The final one is about the stock exchange.

If you've some black money and you invest it through the market then you can just pay a 5% tax and keep very quiet about where that cash came from.

Clearly, this is people washing something that might have been illegally made or not having paid tax upon.

Quite true, but we'd much rather have them there in the legal economy, investing properly, wouldn't we?

So, we make it easy for them to do so.

Sure, it's all a bit of a swizz but still – we get that money now into the legal economy, into legal investments, which is again that same thing.

We want it to be easy for people to be in the legal economy.

So, we will have a better economy if it is easier to be in that legal economy.

That definition of economic freedom that Heritage is using is really, well, how easy is it to be in that legal economy?

The housing problems are at least partially – if not majorly – that it is difficult to be there.

And lastly, the washing of money into the stock market - Well, sure.

We know that folks do untaxed, even illegal stuff.

But let us make it easy for them to get into that legal economy all the same.

Or, to put it really simply, if doing business and paying tax in the legal economy is easy then we'll have both more business and also more people doing it all legally.

And, of course, thereby paying their tax and obeying the law.

There's an old acronym in American English – KISS - keep it simple, stupid.

This applies, especially, to seemingly complicated things like being legal in an economy.

Make the rules simple, make them actually work, and you'll be amazed at how much economic growth you get out of it.

Or as Adam Smith put it, peace, easy taxes and the tolerable administration of justice.

Top Brokers