As of this writing, the conquest of Ukraine is well underway. The Russian army will, with their tanks and artillery combined with their air force, continue to strike hard against the armed forces of Ukraine. Most of the Ukrainian air force will likely be destroyed in the first few days. While putting up stiff opposition, the armed forces of Ukraine are unlikely to exist as combat units for more than five or six weeks.
A new government will be installed by the Russian army. The leaders of the existing Ukraine government will be jailed. A substantial part of the Russian army will remain in Ukraine to keep control and put down any opposition. The US made some effort, since 2014, to arm and develop the Ukrainian armed forces. This effort was insufficient and was based on wishful thinking, not on a realistic analysis of the problem.
Obama typically failed to grasp the central issue of building the Ukrainian armed forces to a level that was able to delay and make painful an invasion by the Russians. Trump had no interest or understanding of the issues. The events around his first impeachment made this clear. Biden had no systematic or realistic plan for building the Ukrainian army.
We have seen in Afghanistan, Iraq, and now Ukraine a surprising inability by the US to build up military forces in foreign countries. This arises, in this instance, from a naive assessment of the objectives of the Russian government. The Western countries will put their sanctions in place, but with what results it is hard to predict.
It appears that energy related transactions have been exempted from the sanction regime, thus there will be little change in the flow of oil, gas, and coal from Russia. Energy prices will decline from the present highs once the limited extent of the sanctions is understood. Neither Biden nor Europe are apparently willing to countenance sanctions that will raise their energy price.
There will thus be a temporary increase in energy prices due to expectations of sanctions limiting transactions, but there should be no long-term increase. In the US, prices for automobile and aviation travel will increase for a few months. This will contribute to inflation and annoy most Americans who now have to pay higher prices to fuel their cars. All of this will hurt the Democrats’ prospects, already dim, in the November 2022 elections.
Bulgaria, Romania, Poland, and the three Baltic states will be very disturbed by the conquest of Ukraine and the weak sanctions imposed. The Eastern European members of Nato have called for an Article 4 consultation based on the fear of this group of members that they face growing dangers from Russia. Article 4 enables members to call for discussion of how to manage emerging dangers, but what will happen as a result?
Will the Nato countries increase their military spending up to their promised targets? No.
Will Nato position more forces close to the Russian border or position their reserves closer? Only for a short time.
Will Nato install more permanent military bases in Eastern Europe? No.
Are the citizens of the UK, US, and France ready to fight for the Baltic states? No.
If Putin lines up 50,000 troops on the borders of the Baltic states, what will Nato really do? Don’t ask
Perhaps Putin’s real objective is to destroy the European security system and show the world that Nato is an empty box. Can Biden provide the leadership to bring Nato members together? I very much doubt that the large Nato countries are ready to spend more money on defense, build up forward bases, or increase the size of their military forces, so it seems doubtful.
If you live in Latvia, Estonia, or Lithuania you should be frightened. In brief, Ukraine will become a country under the boot of the Russians. The sanctions will not be effective. An insurgency against the Russians will not make much progress.
The Democrats will lose the 2022 and 2024 elections in the US. The Republicans will follow Trump’s anti-Nato pro-Putin approach. Nato will become a toothless organization. Eastern European countries will weaken politically and economically, dominated by fear of Russia.
Forrest Cookson is an economist who has served as the first president of AmCham and has been a consultant for the Bangladesh Bureau of Statistics.



