Mark Zuckerberg lost $29 billion in one day. This should serve as persuasive evidence that wealth taxation is a silly thing to be doing.
For if gains in unrealized wealth -- and, yes, people are seriously suggesting we do this -- are to be taxed, then unrealized losses in wealth must logically attract a tax refund.
The net effect of which is that trying to tax unrealized wealth is going to be, at best, pretty much revenue neutral.
There are varied proposals out there for society to start taxing wealth.
Oxfam releases reports each year demanding that this be done. US Senator Elizabeth Warren has made a specific proposal: that 2 or 5% of the wealth of each billionaire should be paid in tax each year.
There are also those who insist that gains in wealth should be taxed as they happen.
Standard economics says this is all a very bad idea indeed. The go-to economist here is James Mirrlees, who gained the Nobel for his work on optimal tax systems.
The answer being that we like investment because it makes our future world richer. So why do we want to tax those who successfully invest and make our future world richer?
Tax bad things -- pollution, say -- sure. Tax things like resource rents (say, the value of oil or gas still in the ground) because no one has made them, that's a grand idea.
But taxing the very process that makes our children richer sounds like a very odd thing to try.
We can even agree that we're not going to let the billionaires pay nothing to society. That means taxing them when they sell investments and start to spend the money on fleets of Rolls Royces -- that's fine. In fact, it's the suggested taxation system, a progressive consumption tax, that stems from Mirrlees' work.
But this isn't good enough for today's culture warriors. If people make money by working in business, they'll get rich! We can't have that, so we must tax all that off them even if they don't sell their shares or business.
Except this runs into that Zuckerberg problem. If we're to tax Jeff Bezos on the $20 billion he made as Amazon shares rose last week, then we've got to provide a tax rebate to Mark Zuckerberg for the $29 billion he lost last week. Note that neither of them sold any shares, this is all just on paper.
But now think of the effect upon revenue if we provide tax refunds on nominal losses as well as charge taxes on nominal gains. The net revenue we gain from the whole system will depend upon the net change in the total wealth of the society, won't it? For we can't have a tax system which just says tax those guys running Big Tech. It has to be neutral as to who has the money and how they made it.
Imagine that we limit our tax system to stocks and shares, just as a mental exercise. The total revenue from the tax will depend therefore on the valuation of the entire stock market. Because if that stays the same then there will be no revenue.
Sure, some people will make money – Bezos, say -- but at the same time other folk must lose – Zuckerberg, say.
If the total stock market stays the same value, then it's a zero sum game, obviously. And if we tax gains and refund losses in a zero sum game then we gain no revenue overall at all.
Now, if the stock market kept going up in value, then, yes, we would gain some revenue. But not all that much as stock markets don't particularly increase in relation to GDP. We'd also find ourselves with certain problems like at the beginning of the pandemic.
Between December 2019 when the first news of a new influenza-type thing started making the rounds and the reality of lockdowns in March, the US stock markets declined by fully 30% overall. Which would have created an awful lot of tax refunds just as governments required ever more cash to pay to beat covid.
Wealth taxation is a bad idea for theoretical reasons -- why do we want to tax what makes the future richer? But more than that, any system of taxing unrealized wealth runs into the problem that it wouldn't actually raise much tax revenue.
After all, if one individual can lose $29 billion in a day then we're going to have to be ready to issue some pretty big tax refund checks, aren't we?
Tim Worstall is a senior fellow at the Adam Smith Institute in London



