It's possible, just sometimes, to think that people might not really mean what they say. It's also possible to dress this up into more formal jargon.
This is what economists call the difference between expressed preferences and revealed preferences. People will say something -- in an opinion poll, even in the voting booth -- but then by their actual behaviour show that they don't quite mean that.
For instance, people who will vote for higher taxes but then work hard to make sure their own tax forms reduce the amount they must pay.
Which brings us to a group called the "Patriotic Millionaires." These are a group of rich people who insist that the world would be a better place if rich people paid more in taxes.
They might be right or wrong about this, of course. I think they're wrong, but then that's just my opinion against theirs. Which isn't really very interesting, shouting opinions at each other.
Except we can go a little deeper here and wonder whether these patriotic people who are calling for higher taxes from people just like them -- in fact, for higher taxes from exactly themselves -- mean quite what they say.
This group has two arms that I know of, one in the US and one in the UK. The interesting thing being that in either country it is possible to pay more to the government if you would like to. In fact, it's very easy.
In the US there's an account called "Gifts to the United States" and if you send them a check, they will cash it and you have paid more in tax. This account gets about $4 million a year.
So, yes, some people apparently really do think they should pay more tax. But not very much -- $4 million is about 0.001% of the current American tax bill.
So, from the actions of Americans -- rather than what people say to the newspapers -- the number of people who really believe that Americans' taxes should be higher than they are would appear to be pretty small.
In Britain it's a little more complicated as there is no one place to send money to. I did investigate this some years back though and it took the Treasury six months to find the answer. You can pay more money just by sending a check to the Treasury (make it out to "The Accountant") and there we are, you have paid more tax.
In the year they added up the figures for me they had received about half a million pounds. Four of those were bequests, left in people's wills. So the actual result was that five whole people had thought that taxes were too low that year and four of those were dead. This is not significant evidence that lots of people think taxes are too low.
The Patriotic Millionaires have been running for a few years now and they do issue a new press release every year to coincide with the World Economic Forum at Davos.
Every year I make the same point to them: You can pay more taxes any time you want, so, have any of you done so?
To which the answer is always: "But that's not the point." They want all other rich people to pay more tax -- not just the claim they originally make -- that they themselves are ready to pay more tax.
And of course demanding that other people pay more tax is different from voluntarily paying more tax yourself. If you claim the second but don't actually do it then it's fair enough if we suspect your actual -- as opposed to stated -- desire to do it, isn't?
Of course it's fun to point at the mild hypocrisy of such groups and public statements. But that basic distinction that economists make is still important. What matters is not what people say they will do but what they actually do. Further, we can gain much more information about what people really think by watching what they do rather than listening to what they say.
Revealed preferences are hugely more important than expressed preferences. But as I said up at the top this is just putting an obvious piece of knowledge about human beings into that economic jargon.
We all know that people don't always do what they say.
No doubt there's a Bengali equivalent of the English phrase "all mouth and no trousers" which contains that same meaning free of the economic jargon.
Tim Worstall is a senior fellow at the Adam Smith Institute in London



