About a decade and a half ago, towards the end of 2007, the then government established a Regulatory Reform Commission.
It had the distinguished civil servant Akbar Ali Khan as its chairman with a small group of business leaders, economists, and civil servants as members.
It had a mandate to analyze regulatory issues faced by businesses and recommend regulatory reform actions to address these.
The commission had a two-year mandate to begin with but there was an expectation that this would become a permanent feature.
It was able to function for about a year and became dysfunctional after the current government came to power in 2009.
It appears that the new government took the view that regulatory reforms will proceed in the traditional way, i.e., through the initiative of individual ministries and agencies, and that a central unit such as a commission is not required to push reforms.
It is true that many reforms have indeed happened since then either because individual ministries took a reform initiative proactively or responded positively to suggestions or demands from the business community.
In some cases, the initiative may have come from central units such as the Prime Minister’s Office or the Bangladesh Investment Development Authority.
Despite all these efforts, the regulatory regime remains deficient.
This is evident from our scores on global indicators such as the now terminated Doing Business indicators of the World Bank, from the comments of businesspeople in seminars, conferences and interviews, as well from my informal conversations with them.
Regulatory deficiencies
The regulatory deficiencies are of many types.
Many regulations are redundant.
Even if these have been relevant in the past, they are no longer so in the changed circumstances.
Such regulations do not serve a purpose anymore, but businesses must incur costs in complying with these.
In some cases, the regulations are rarely applied, and officers may have forgotten about these.
However, the fact that they are in the rulebook means that some government officers can still randomly invoke that regulation to harass businesses.
A good example of outdated regulations was noted by the Regulatory Reform Commission in 2008.
While going through the compendium of laws prepared by the Law Ministry, Akbar Ali Khan discovered that according to the existing Postal Act, no one other than the Post Office can deliver letters, documents, or packages.
This law was a hang-over from the British era and no one had bothered to amend it and make it better aligned with today’s world.
It didn’t take Khan too long to realize what this meant.
It meant that the thriving courier industry in Bangladesh was actually illegal.
An activity which was not only profitable but also compensating for the inefficiency of the postal service had been operating all this long on rather shaky legal foundations.
The Regulatory Reform Commission recommended the required amendment to the Postal Act.
This was followed up by the government, which not only had the Act amended by Parliament but also, in due course, enacted the follow-on regulations.
Loopholes
In many cases, the regulations are relevant but not written in the appropriate way, leaving much scope for confusion and multiple interpretations.
This also leads to harassment of businesses without necessarily meeting any social goal.
Moreover, even if the regulations are relevant and appropriately formulated, there may be deficiencies in the way these are administered in practice.
In some cases, the problem is not regulations as they exist or administered, but that there are no regulations.
This is the problem of a regulatory gap.
The implications of such gaps were brought home a few years ago when Uber first started its operations in Bangladesh.
The regulatory authorities were confused.
Is this a taxi company, an internet platform or something else?
I do not know if the confusion has been fully resolved yet.
Another problem is the way new regulations are formulated, or amendments made to existing ones.
This is a very important aspect of the quality of a country’s regulatory system.
Government officials often see a problem, want to address it and come up with a new regulation or procedure which they think will do the job.
They may be well meaning but a failure to do a prior analysis of the costs and benefits of the regulatory action often means that the core problem remains unresolved while new ones are created.
Regulatory surprises bring down the quality of the regulatory regime.
It creates uncertainty and harassment and increases the costs of doing business.
In the world of Bangladeshi business, a new dawn often brings bad news – of a new regulation imposed on them without any prior notice.
All the above issues bring me to my main point.
I believe that there is a strong need to have a central body in government that will be a major driver of regulatory reforms in the country.
Such a body will do at least the following.
First, it may create an inventory of all existing rules and regulations in the country that affect businesses.
It may then review all these to assess which ones are redundant or irrelevant and should be done away with, which ones are relevant but need to be modified and modernized, and which ones may remain as is in the rulebook.
It will then send its recommendations to the relevant ministries in government for the necessary follow-up.
This will be an exercise in cleaning the stock of existing regulations.
While individual ministries may take initiative to do a similar review and assessment within the ministry, cross-country experience tells us that such exercises usually end up being piece-meal.
Only a central unit can effectively carry out such reviews, of course with the help of the ministries.
The second important task such a unit can perform is to improve the flow of new regulations and help avoid regulatory surprises.
I think the time has come to seriously think about instituting a system of regulatory impact assessments in the country.
We can begin with the most important regulatory proposals, and subject them to an impact analysis.
Impact analysis
The idea of an impact analysis is not novel in Bangladesh.
When a government agency does a project, say a road, a hospital, or a power transmission line, it is required to carry out a cost-benefit analysis and justify the planned investment.
The Planning Commission then reviews the analysis and approves or rejects the project.
Whether these exercises are done properly is of course a matter of debate – Bangladesh is replete with examples of projects that were done on purely political considerations with little analysis of the costs and benefits to society.
But the rules of business of the government do require such analysis.
If a cost-benefit analysis is required of projects, why shouldn’t one insist on something similar for rules and regulations?
The responsibility for preparing the analysis may lie with the line ministry or agency which is proposing the new rule or regulation.
The analysis, or at least a summary of it, can then be attached to the regulatory proposal when it goes for review to the appropriate reviewing body, be it the cabinet or any other body.
The central body that I am proposing can oversee this process.
It can develop a set of criteria to decide which rules and regulations will be subjected to the impact analysis.
This unit may also provide training and technical support to the line ministries and agencies in preparing the impact assessments.
The third, and perhaps the most important task, that this central body can perform is to think about regulatory gaps.
This has become a particularly serious issue given the rapid developments in technology that we see all around us.
It is true that in the past decade or so, there have been several legal and regulatory reforms that are providing a legal underpinning to activities that leverage technology.
These include laws and regulations regarding e-payments, digital signature, and mobile financial services, just to name a few.
However, conversations with businesspeople indicate that the process is slow compared to the pace at which technology is evolving, and is often reactive rather than proactive.
This means that entrepreneurs in Bangladesh may have lost many golden opportunities to provide new types of goods and services leveraging technology, not just to the domestic market but perhaps to the global marketplace as well.
While individual ministries and agencies may sometimes do a reasonable job of reacting to developments and taking appropriate reform actions, their reaction speed may be slow.
More importantly, they may not have the capacity or incentive to think ahead.
This is where a well-equipped central body with the right incentives and attitudes can play a very useful role in proactively thinking about new laws and regulations, way ahead of the time when these will be needed.
In other words, they should be monitoring technological developments which may be relevant for Bangladesh, work out the legal and regulatory implications of these, learn how other countries are dealing with such technological innovations and prepare a roadmap of how Bangladesh should proceed.
It should then carry out advocacy work with the ministries and persuade them to start preparing the required laws and regulations so that these are in place by the time the technology hits our shores.
Many countries have established such central bodies to push regulatory reforms. Examples include South Korea’s Regulatory Reform Committee, Mexico’s COFEMER (Federal Regulatory Improvement Commission) and the UK’s Better Regulation Executive.
Bangladesh can learn from them as well from the sector specific regulatory commissions we have ourselves set up, such as the Bangladesh Telecommunications Regulatory Commission or the Bangladesh Energy Regulatory Commission.
The Regulatory Reform Commission established in late 2007 died a slow death because of the political transition.
But its relevance is still alive. In fact, with the economy of Bangladesh becoming more dynamic and complex over the past 15 years and in this world of rapid technological change with all its regulatory implications, the need for such a body is now even more urgent than it was a decade and a half ago.
I think the time has come to consider reviving the Regulatory Reform Commission in some form.
The author is an economist, previously with an international development agency



