Reliable Brokers
Online Investing
Alerts & Analysis
Easy Trading

Maids, masters, and monsters

Update : 09 Jul 2017, 06:52 PM

For the last two days, the photo of a woman, reportedly the wife of a defense officer, who cruelly beat up a teenage domestic help, has been featured all over social media -- triggering, one more time, the question about the real conditions of thousands of young girls working as domestic help in our homes.

Maltreatment of people who work for us in our homes is not a new issue. In fact, if we go back three decades, almost all of us will be able to recall that, in most homes, domestic help were not treated fairly.

That trend persists. The cruelty is bordering on savagery when the help is a girl or a boy between 8-12.

Incidentally, we protest at the international forums about the reported mistreatment of our female workers abroad but do little in the local sphere to tackle the abuse of young workers.

The 70s famine and the deluge

The famine in 1974 drove millions towards the city in search of not work, but food.

This was the time when the phenomenon of hiring people from the villages to work in our homes saw a major boost.

Sorry to say, I remember very well that the women employed were not given a salary at the end of the month.

The deal was three meals a day and work from morning till late at night. In a situation where countless people were eager to accept whatever was offered to them, the premise for exploitation was created.

I am not saying all homes treated their domestic help unjustly but this is a fact, a very polarising “us vs them situation” was enforced -- under which, two kinds of rice were cooked, one for the family, and another, a coarse variety, for the maids.

If a domestic help has been abused, assaulted in the household of a government official, the responsibility lies with the government to take swift action

Won’t be surprised to find such systems still prevalent. I don’t know how many people recall this, but I certainly do.

Then, in the early 80s, with the country facing better agricultural growth, the flow of people entering the domestic workforce had to be paid.

Looking back, one feels that with payment came the unwritten right to raise the hand

Ashamed to say, educated people with a facade of culture and compassion resorted to scalding young maids with hot iron, a kitchen spatula, or by pouring hot water.

The physical exploitation

Then came the murky side of domestic help exploitation under which young girls from villages were brought and forced to offer sexual favours to people known to the master or mistress of the house.

A real life experience has to be shared here: One day, sometime back in the 80s, I came back from school to find police presence at home.

In the drawing room, my grandmother was seated on a chair, fuming, and two persons, husband and wife, who lived opposite our house, were standing looking contrite.

The police officer had handcuffs in his hands, constables ready to follow an order.

It transpired that the seemingly respectable couple lured our domestic help to their house under some false pretext and was making her engage in commercial sex.

A local shop-keeper got a glimpse of the girl sleeping in the house with heavy make-up. Suspicious of her role, he informed my grandmother.

Total honesty or else

At the heart of much of our social violence and rage aimed at those who work for us is a very absurd/impractical expectation: All working class people must be spotlessly honest.

So, the smuggler who has made millions breaking all possible laws, the unscrupulous loan defaulter, the shyster politician, the swindler, and also the wide variety of social scoundrels at large expect that anyone working for them, has to be scrupulously honest.

This illogical demand extends to our public service providers like rickshaw-pullers and CNG-wallahs: If they ask for Tk10 more, a lot of people flare up, if the CNG demands Tk100 more, we raise hell -- though, we have no hesitation in fawning to all the affluent people with countless skeletons in the cupboard.

Why do we want people from a background of deprivation to be the epitome of virtue?

Why can’t they be humans like the rest of us: Flawed, susceptible to corruption, and imperfect?

In the recent case, reportedly, the cause was the young maid’s failure to fry eggs the way she was instructed to do so. She made a mistake and hence all hell broke down.

A policy safeguarding domestic help

There have been discussions on a policy that would guard domestic help and ensure that no master or mistress is falsely accused of violence or ill treatment. A young girl or boy will always be vulnerable to damaging external influences and this the master or mistress needs to handle just the way they would do in the case of their children.

We need a very clearly defined law in this regard, which will be circulated to every house of a ward by the ward commissioner’s office and plastered at every alley of the city with clear mobile numbers to contact the police.

From the law enforcers, what we expect is the dedication of Constable Parvez Mia, who risked his life to save passengers from a bus which fell in a water-filled ditch. Again, in this regard, at least we want the law to set some laudable examples.

The punishment for the recent case

Social media informs that the woman who is accused of beating a young household help is the wife of a defense official. If that is so, the silence of the respective force is disconcerting.

If a domestic help has been abused, assaulted in the household of a government official, the responsibility lies with the government to take swift action.

Otherwise, the silence or attempts at obfuscation will prove that, with the right connections, maltreatment of the help can easily be tackled.

Surely, this, in the long run, will come back to haunt the authority when it protests prejudiced treatment of citizens abroad.

Towheed Feroze is a journalist working in the development sector.

Top Brokers