Reliable Brokers
Online Investing
Alerts & Analysis
Easy Trading

OP-ED: The herd immunity conundrum in Bangladesh

A combination of infection and vaccination should be the goal for developing countries

Update : 18 Feb 2021, 01:25 AM

According to Bangladesh’s demographic data, 40% of the population is below the age of 18, thus excluding them from the vaccination program. Now, assuming that 10% of the population cannot be vaccinated due to a variety of reasons (pregnant women, women nursing babies, very sick, and elderly), only 50% of the population can be vaccinated. 

The vaccine target group is, therefore, only 50% of the entire population. If we vaccinate 100% of the “target” group, we can only achieve 50% immunity of the whole community. Considering all the difficulties of accessing people in remote rural locations coupled with the so-called “vaccine hesitancy” among a large segment of the population, it is not possible to achieve more than 50%-60% vaccination of the target group. Therefore, it is nearly impossible to go beyond 25%-30% community immunity through vaccination alone. 

According to government statistics, about 0.5 million people have been infected by the coronavirus. It is widely accepted that the government data is an underestimation. In addition, there are asymptomatic cases of Covid-19. The real number of infected people, ie, those with antibodies, is probably 10 to 20 times greater -- varying somewhere between 5 to 10 million; for a population of 170 million, this translates to 3% to 6% of the entire population. 

Intuitively, these figures may appear to be too low, but we must keep in mind that the pandemic has largely spared the rural population. Taking the higher figures for immunity resulting from both natural infection and vaccination, one arrives at a total immunity figure of 36%, which is half that of the 70% immunity requirement advocated by epidemiologists. Some will argue that South Asia has some favourable characteristics that lower the immunity requirement for achieving herd immunity. How low can that be? The truth is, we simply do not know, and as it happens, even experts do not. 

The manner in which the infection rate has come down in both Bangladesh and India suggests that there are unknown factors guiding the propagation of infection due to SARS-Cov-2. New Delhi recorded zero daily death recently, whereas a few months back, that figure was more than 100. 

The serological studies of the New Delhi population over the last eight months indicate a gradual increase in the number of people with antibodies. The latest survey (reported in Hindustan Times, January 26, 2021) conducted between January 11 and January 21 indicated that 56% of the 28,000 people tested had antibodies. The last survey of the New Delhi population for antibodies in October was more than 30% lower. However, how and why the infection in the entire country has come down remains a mystery. From the New Delhi data, it appears that the herd immunity figure for South Asia could be around 60%. 

Until and unless “herd immunity” can be achieved, eventually children will be infected, because they cannot be vaccinated. By sheltering our school-children, we have created a time bomb waiting to explode as soon as schools re-open. Infections are bound to increase unless of course coronavirus disappears as mysteriously as it emerged, very much like the SARS and MERS, or eventually becomes endemic. In the latter case, it is likely to bother us for another two to three years. Will schools remain shut for that long? 

Since children do not need hospitalization, and most of the infections are asymptomatic, we could very easily have allowed the rural schools to remain open. This would have yielded dual benefits. First, those that cannot access digital online learning fully would not have been excluded from the learning process during the pandemic. Second, by intermingling in schools, children would have developed immunity, and as a result we would have gained a 5%-10% overall community immunity. 

Clearly, Bangladesh and India did not have a raging pandemic causing hundreds of thousands of deaths as expected for large population countries with poor medical facilities. As a result, there is plenty of scepticism regarding the “herd immunity” percentage (1-1/R0, where R0 is the initial reproduction number) for population that have some sort of natural immunity to viruses in general. 

Nevertheless, it is highly unlikely that such “natural immunity” will provide a benefit of lowering the herd immunity requirement figure by 20% or more. Thus, even if the herd immunity requirement is 50%, the target is clearly impossible to achieve by vaccination alone. In the beginning of the pandemic, when things were going out of control, many argued that in developing countries, “infection” is the only way out of the pandemic. 

This approach has been found to be not very efficient, because only a small percentage of the population is carrying antibodies even after one year of the coronavirus propagation. Therefore, a combination of infection and vaccination should be the goal for developing countries with unfavourable demographics and large “vaccine hesitancy.” 

This may also be economically the most prudent approach, because if third, fourth, and even fifth and sixth vaccine doses are required, the financial implications are huge.

Ijaz Hossain is Professor of the Department of Chemical Engineering at Buet.

Top Brokers