Boris Johnson has emerged victorious in Britain’s House of Commons on his government’s Internal Market Bill. With 340 MPs supporting the bill and 263 opposing it, the government can now go ahead and inform the country that it is ready to renegotiate certain aspects of its Brexit deal with the European Union.
But this parliamentary victory looks poised to be a pyrrhic triumph, given that the EU has already signaled that by going forward with the Internal Market Bill, London would be headed for a violation of an international treaty to which it was a willing signatory last December. Again, given that no fewer than 30 Tory MPs abstained during the vote on the bill, it is a certainty that the measure has inflamed passions across large swathes of the population in the UK.
Treaties are always sacrosanct. Upholding them is a moral responsibility on the part of governments everywhere in these times. Indeed, the obligations which nations are expected to maintain in relations between and among themselves were made extremely clear through the decisions reached at the Congress of Vienna in post-Napoleonic times between 1812 and 1822, with such statesmen as Metternich, Castlereagh, and Talleyrand working out a system that would serve in subsequent centuries as a model for the development and sustenance of a balance of power between nations.
In modern times, the Congress of Vienna, though it was not an unqualified success, has served as an instance whereby nations could be persuaded to settle disputes of a bilateral as well as multilateral nature through bringing issues to the table, with national spokesmen making their points in detailed, determined, and meticulous manner.
By the time agreements were reached on ensuring stability in Europe, it was noticeable that the key to successful completion of negotiations was the element of compromise. Chauvinism or extreme demonstrations of nationalism are never conducive to bilateral or multilateral negotiations. A spirit of give-and-take has always worked best. The writer Mark Twain put it well: “The principle of give and take,” he noted, “is the principle of diplomacy -- give one and take ten.”
At least, that has been the way the modern world has operated till this point in time. What the Internal Market Bill threatens to do is obvious to all observers of diplomacy and international relations. It is a violation of international law which not only does discredit to the British prime minister but also -- and worryingly -- opens the door for governments elsewhere in the future to renege on agreements they may or will reach with other governments.
Treaties being a sacred trust between the signatories to them, a violation of them leads to a depressing explosion of mistrust which quickly mutates into previously unimaginable chaos.
We have all these recent instances of the depths to which the US has sunk in global perceptions of its role in the world. The Trump presidency, with its uneducated response to global realities, has walked away from the Iran nuclear deal, turned its back on the Paris Climate Accord, jettisoned its responsibilities to the World Health Organization, and infuriated Europe. All these acts, together with a ratcheting up of tensions with Canada over NAFTA and an escalating trade war with China, have put paid to the traditional role which the US has played for decades in a diversity of global crises.
The Good Friday Agreement in Northern Ireland and the Camp David Agreement between Egypt and Israel, both brokered by Washington, have held steady because the parties to them have scrupulously adhered to their letter and spirit.
The dangers attendant on violations of international treaties can be encapsulated in simple form: They make it rather excruciating for successor governments to have national reputations -- undermined by men like Trump -- restored to the old levels. And, of course, there have been times when a unilateral violation of a treaty has led to grave misery for the nations involved.
In 1975, the governments of Iraq and Iran, led by Saddam Hussein and the Shah, in that order, reached a deal on, among other issues, the Shatt al Arab waterway in what came to be known as the Algiers Accord. Five years later, with the Shah overthrown in an Islamic revolution in Tehran, Saddam Hussein tore up the treaty in September 1980. The ramifications were grave. Iran and Iraq went to war that was to last eight years, with not merely a loss of lives for both countries, but of the regional stability that the accord had guaranteed.
The repercussions of a violation of a deal are to be observed in the troubles that have been taking place of late in Hong Kong. Under an agreement signed by then British Prime Minister Margaret Thatcher and Chinese premier Zhao Ziyang in December 1984, Hong Kong was to be returned to the People’s Republic of China in 1997 on the stipulation that for the subsequent 50 years, till 2047, Hong Kong would continue to operate under a capitalist system.
In other words, it was a “One Country, Two Systems” deal that was initialed by London and Beijing. The capitalist system has endured in Hong Kong, but Beijing gave the world much cause for worry this year when it decreed that people could be extradited from Hong Kong to the mainland for trials over what it considered offenses. The proposition has since been withdrawn in light of the massive protests in Hong Kong, but one cannot escape the feeling that it was a bad move by the Chinese leadership. It ignored the inviolability of international agreements.
Agreements are not always comfortable for all the parties to them, but once they are hammered out, it becomes an obligation for all of them to hold fast to them despite any and all provocations. The Simla Agreement of 1972 between India and Pakistan as also the Indus Waters Treaty of 1960, despite the occasional hiccups, has remained intact. The Tripartite Agreement reached by Bangladesh, India, and Pakistan in 1974 has kept the peace in South Asia.
For all the misgivings about the efficacy of Saarc, no member-state has demonstrated any sign of wanting to walk out of it. Indeed, the original seven members were at a point joined by an eighth -- Afghanistan.
Article 27 of the Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties, adopted in 1969, puts it all in bold black and white: “A party may not invoke the provisions of its internal law as justification for its failure to perform a treaty.”
It will be interesting to see how Boris Johnson and his colleagues work around the problem in their quest to have Brexit put behind them. Note that three former British prime ministers -- John Major, Tony Blair, and David Cameron -- have publicly denounced Johnson’s move as undermining respect for the UK abroad.
In the corner, the EU fumes in righteous indignation.
Syed Badrul Ahsan is a journalist and biographer.



